3 ms·
[Spoilers] They don't need Chaos. They want to disable Rabbit, and they know Rabbit's certificates mostly tie back to a single CA, Credit Suisse. So they "revo
by tialaramex 3y ago
[Spoilers]
They don't need Chaos. They want to disable Rabbit, and they know Rabbit's certificates mostly tie back to a single CA, Credit Suisse. So they "revoke" Credit Suisse and accept the consequences, which (they acknowledge) are career ending for the Europeans. This is mostly a plot convenience because Rabbit is much too powerful to allow what Vinge wants to happen next.
No, you can't actually "revoke" a root CA, the decision to trust (or not) a root is local. So this part of the novel is a fantasy. But even if you assume it means that the European authorities can somehow reach into Credit Suisse and cause it to revoke all the intermediates (which maybe is a plausible reading) and so on down to end entity certificates, that doesn't really work either. Not on the time scale Vinge needs for the novel.
Hours are conceivable but unlikely. Days maybe. A week. But the novel needs it to be seconds.
There are two big obstacles to even the revocation which does really exist. Firstly humans are much more enthusiastic about seeing Dancing Pigs than they are about safety, because safety is a very abstract idea, whereas seeing dancing pigs is an immediate reward. This is the Dancing Pigs problem, and we've put some effort in, it's less likely a random Chrome user would get their face ripped to pieces because they wanted Dancing Pigs and so they bypassed the security checks that would protected them - than say - fifteen years ago, but only somewhat.
Secondly though, there's not a great enthusiasm technically for this sort of counter-measure. It's so rarely beneficial in practice. Most of the time those humans were right, we were just denying them Dancing Pigs. Their face might get ripped to pieces, but to be honest it's as likely to be because they deliberate went to "Rip My Face To Pieces.example" as through anything we could have prevented. This is only barely a technical problem. So, when there are things we could do to get closer to what's in the novel, why would we?
Building the PKI which exists in Vinge's novel is probably a bad expenditure of resources.
- schoen 3y agoThat's funny, I read that book before I worked on PKI directly. Maybe I should read it again now that I have more detailed experience (and maybe be frustrated by the implausibility that you mention!).