6 ms·
It seems to me that the lesson to learn here is to be careful about agreeing to vesting. Pre-series A, the three founders owned most [1] of a company which had
by cperciva 15y ago
It seems to me that the lesson to learn here is to be careful about agreeing to vesting. Pre-series A, the three founders owned most [1] of a company which had a $6M pre-money valuation and was "on track to hit $1M in revenue" for the year. Post-series A, they each owned less than 3% of the company outright, with the rest of their shares vesting over four years [2]. What sort of idiot takes a deal which reduces them from owning stock valued at $1.5M to owning stock valued at $300k and an employment contract which gives them $300k/year of stock if they stay at the company?
Obviously if you're running out of runway, you take whatever terms you can get, since your company is worthless if it goes bankrupt; but if your company is profitable and your only concern is about allowing it to grow faster, why the heck would you take a deal which is practically begging your investors to fire you?
[1] We're not told how much Cambrian Ventures took, but for $250k it presumably wasn't a huge amount. I'm going to arbitrarily guess 25%.
[2] Based on the way the numbers work out, I'm guessing they kept 20% of their stock outright and gave back the remaining 80% to be four-year vested. This fits with the fact that the company was about a year old when they took the funding.
- damoncali 15y agoI don't know... You should probably subject everyone to vesting everyone at incorporation - to keep people from ditching early with a huge slug of equity. Good investors know this, and will often rightfully insist on some sort of vesting reset - depending on circumstances. It doesn't make you an idiot to take that deal. It makes you a part of the VC machine. It's just how it works. That said, I've seen people raise (smaller amounts) of money without any vesting provisions at all (i.e. the founders owned their shares outright). That, to my way of thinking, makes the investor the idiot. EDIT: I don't mean to imply that resets are a given. Only that they make sense in certain situations, both for founders and investors. There is no "standard", but there are "ways things are often done" for a reason.
- cperciva 15y agoYou should probably subject everyone to vesting everyone at incorporation - to keep people from ditching early with a huge slug of equity At incorporation, sure -- because at that point the entire value of the company is the work the founders will be doing in the future. But in the case of yousendit, they implemented vesting at a point where the company already had a significant value; the fact that it was able to survive having two of its three founders fired indicates that their contribution was made before the Series A, not after. It doesn't make you an idiot to take that deal. It makes you a part of the VC machine. It's just how it works. I'd say that anyone who accepts "that's just the way it works" as an answer is an idiot, but maybe that's just my cynicism showing. :-)
- mmaunder 15y agoOur series A investors wanted vesting and we said no. They were cool with it. Vesting for founders is insane. Never accept it. Vesting for execs is mandatory and has saved me once already, ironically because our investors demanded it. Once again I'm surprised at how very very few founders have a thorough knowledge of what they're signing up for and how to get what they want. It's your company. Act like it. You don't need permission and nothing is "standard". Also think hard before you get into bed with A level VC's and angels and make sure you are on your A game because the worlds most skilled investors come with a heavy premium. If you're bringing real value, there's nothing wrong with saying no.
- jpdoctor 15y ago> Our series A investors wanted vesting and we said no. It's really a noop on their part. They know full well that if a founder ever leaves the company they can recover the ownership by diluting the bejesus out of him after he's gone (and bonus: everyone else who has already left is also diluted to near-zero). Vesting just saves them the energy they'd have to exert on the backend.
- stdbrouw 15y agoStock and voting / vetoing rights usually go hand in hand, so it depends on company structure and how well the founders protected themselves against such events.
- patio11 15y agoVesting for founders is insane. Never accept it. This depends a bit on the maturity of the company. For example, at the seed stage, where the founders may only have known each other for 3 months of their lives, very credible people are going to tell you that they can name dozens of reasons why you should have vesting. If money first comes into the company around month 5 and you have a seed round closed around month 8, there's quite a window where acrimonious breakups can happen. In the event of an acrimonious breakup, fast forward four years. In the event you manage to pull the company back from the brink, do you want someone from two lifetimes ago in startup years a) owning ~1/4 of your company and b) looking like Huge Unknown Risk Factor every time you raise a new round or make similarly consequential decisions? That's why smart people who have seen bad breakups before are going to suggest vesting and it won't really be a suggestion. Now, on the flipside, if I hypothetically brought on my best friend to work on AR and took investing at the two year mark, any conversation beginning with "You should really give all your shares back" would be pretty darn brief.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jakejake 15y agoThe article pretty much states that it was likely a mistake to take that much funding when they had no idea how much they needed (or if they even needed funding). It seems like there is this messed up idea that a successful startup is when you get a ton of funding, the founders cash out and then who cares if company goes down the toilet (well, except the investors of course). I suppose that is successful in the sense that the founders get rich, but it seems like it's a selfish, thoughtless strategy. The idea of a lifestyle company is totally unattractive to venture capitalists to the point where you'd think that only total losers would aspire to create a stable company. If it's not a rocketship to the moon, then investors don't want to touch it. But a lifestyle company founder can get equally rich - just not one huge pile of money at one time. They can be paid handsomely though and create a great company that provides a great life for a lot of people instead of burning out and creating a miserable life for everybody except the founder.
- jacquesm 15y agoVastly many more people get rich with 'lifestyle' companies than get rich with moonshots. They won't be as obscenely rich but several million is definitely nothing strange (Euros or Dollars, pick your poison). VC's won't touch such businesses (and they shouldn't) because the return rate is not worth the hassle for them but that is just a matter of perspective. For founders the life style businesses are typically a safer bet and a life that is more conducive to having a family and a more or less normal life besides the business. For a VC babysitting a small but profitable company is just as much work as one that might hit out of the park. And the chance of a return multiplied by the return itself is way larger than it is for a life-style business. The risk profile of a VC is much different than the risk profile of most business people and they only come out ahead because they make multiple bets, which is something most business people can not do.
- ahoyhere 15y agoOn top of everything you said, folks should step back and realize that VCs or VC-related interests have historically powered all the most-read startup media (TechCrunch, HN, AVC, etc). This has an influence. According to Dow Jones Venturesource, there were only 522 M&As, buyouts, or IPOs in 2011 among venture-backed companies. 522. By contrast, over 300 people are injured by lightning strikes per year, in the US.
- baconner 15y agoThere are a lot of good business lessons to be learned here but there's a much more important lesson. In business and life in general you will sometimes make big mistakes and/or just plain get screwed over. This is going to hit most people's sense of self worth and ability to reason like a ton of bricks. You need to be able to recognize when you've been compromised so you don't end up digging a deeper hole like this fellow did. Sometimes you just have to move on. Revenge isn't going to get you anywhere.