8 ms·
USCG says ‘debris field’ discovered within search area for missing submersible
- seydor 3y agoI ve been reading about this submarine for days in the frontpages along with live coverage. I wonder how many knew about another shipwreck where more than 500 are feared dead trying to cross to europe.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- solarmist 3y agoHow is this related? Or is this an “oh did you know in addition to the titanic…” Edit: I meant this literally. I didn’t know about this or that it also happened this week.
- dboreham 3y agoIt's related in that both are maritime disasters that happened in the past week.
- solarmist 3y agoAh. Okay, I didn’t know about that.
- dcsommer 3y ago500 > 5
- dingusdew 3y ago[dead]
- bugglebeetle 3y agoI think the amount of resources being marshaled, including those of the US Navy, to try and save a bunch of wealthy people who went on a pointless suicide run, actually says quite a bit about how are world is ordered. The US Navy could easily be deployed to save migrant ships or in a similar humanitarian capacity, but that would set a “bad precedent” in terms of our obligation to these people.
- housemusicfan 3y agoI'm going to go out on a limb and say the US Coast Guard (not Navy) and the Canadians were deployed because the mini-sub went missing off the coast of America and not off the coast of Greece in the Mediterranean. By that logic, they could just as easily dispatch the Indian Navy.
- bugglebeetle 3y agoNo, the US Navy, in addition to the US Coast Guard is involved as well: > However, on Wednesday a U.S. Navy official told ABC News it had sent a portable crane system that can reach 20,000 feet deep to St. John’s, Newfoundland, so it can be welded onto a ship to take it to the search area for the missing submersible. > Additionally, the Navy announced it was sending experts and a Flyaway Deep Ocean Salvage System, or FADOSS, which it described as a “motion compensated lift system designed to provide reliable deep ocean lifting capacity for the recovery of large, bulky, and heavy undersea objects such as aircraft or small vessels.” https://abcnews.go.com/amp/US/missing-titanic-tour-sub-rescue-options/story?id=100212808 https://abcnews.go.com/amp/US/missing-titanic-tour-sub-rescu... And the Sixth Fleet operates out of the Mediterranean, so, sure, there’s no political valence to any of this: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Sixth_Fleet https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Sixth_Fleet
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dfadsadsf 3y ago[flagged]
- taco_emoji 3y agoThere are finite resources out there for sea rescues. The argument is that they're being applied to 5 people on a pleasure trip instead of 500 migrants who presumably have much better reasons to risk their lives.
- EA-3167 3y agoThe resources intended to locate a deep sea submersible probably don't overlap with the resources needed to search for survivors in the Med. By the same token you could just argue that since both cases involved people who were certainly already dead, the pageantry of a search serves purposes other than efficient use of resources.
- dingusdew 3y ago[dead]
- kylehotchkiss 3y agoI imagine part of the government's involvement here is trying to test their own submarine detection and rescue tooling. There aren't otherwise many other real-world places to attempt them. I'm sure they've gained confidential valuable insights so far.
- kylehotchkiss 3y agohttps://archive.is/pSpem https://archive.is/pSpem The Navy heard it as it happened. Apparently they were aware of the loss of communications nearly in real time.
- mhb 3y agoThere are finite resources for everything. Why are these five people more worthy to be saved than the thousands of people who will die today from hunger?
- taco_emoji 3y ago
- Simon_O_Rourke 3y agoClassic "whataboutism".
- somedude895 3y agoThose wrecks usually get some coverage in Europe, but it happens almost on a weekly basis now, so obviously it's not gonna be frontpage every time.
- 3327 3y ago[dead]
- joncrane 3y ago[flagged]
- aaronbrethorst 3y agoNo, not even in an Alanis Morissette way.
- DANmode 3y agoCoincidence, not irony.
- trallnag 3y agoQuite ironic to me
- mcpackieh 3y agoThe discrepancy in coverage is due to a discrepancy in novelty. If it were 5 rich guys going missing on a small sailboat, we wouldn't be hearing about it. It's because they went missing in a submarine, and also because of the Titanic connection. You've probably heard of Kim Wall. She wasn't rich, but she was murdered on a submarine so that became international news too.
- nathan_compton 3y agoPlus, many people can feel a certain frisson of delight or at least schadenfreude about 5 rich guys dying in a comically "move fast and break stuff" built submarine and the fact that it happened doesn't really reflect any kind of deep, hard to solve, social problem. Thinking about refugees, on the other hand, is depressing and there is also almost nothing anyone can do about it. As macabre as it is, the "startup sub kills rich guys" story is just more fun.
- EA-3167 3y agoNot to nitpick, but people paying $8k to head across to Europe were not refugees, they were migrants. They weren't fleeing anything except adverse economic conditions.
- nathan_compton 3y agoIf they were willing to risk death for it, I'm happy to call them refugees. Even if the conditions were "merely" economic.
- EA-3167 3y agoI don't see how degrading the definitions of these words helps anyone.
- hef19898 3y agoIf you really believe they have the 8k in cash, I have a deep sea rated submersible to sell you.
- jjtheblunt 3y agoThat's been in the news in the US too. Also very sad, obviously. I get the impression that this submersible situation has been continuously in the news for days because the status has been unresolved for days.
- mrtksn 3y agoMedia interest is not the same thing as value given. A sub full of rich people visiting Titanic going missing is much more interesting story than yet another ship full of immigrants sinking. The later is unfortunately a story about instance of something happening since years and has wide social implications, unlike the billionaire sub. It’s a politically charged topic, these people did not choose the sketchy boat because all the flights were booked. They were on these boats because large number of Europeans don’t want them there for this reason or another.
- pengaru 3y agoLast paragraph of TFA: > Some expeditions were delayed after OceanGate was forced to rebuild > the Titan’s hull because it showed “cyclic fatigue” and wouldn’t be > able to travel deep enough to reach the Titanic’s wreckage, > according to a 2020 article by GeekWire, which interviewed the > company’s CEO. If you simply rebuild it, but don't redesign and/or change its material composition, won't the rebuilt hull possess similar cyclic fatigue limits to what it replaced?
- 3327 3y ago[dead]
- ender341341 3y agoyes. Sometimes that can be OK, if the cyclic fatigue was from high levels of testing. If on the other hand it happens quickly and you haven't even tested it at anywhere near the depth you expect to take it and don't have tons of testing yeah, it's really bad idea. (which seems to be the case here)
- tappaseater 3y agoIt reminds of the story of the de Havilland Comet, which had a bad habit of breaking up in mid-air. Engineers submerged the fuselage of the plane in and out of deep water to simulate pressure changes and it finally failed. leading to the diagnosis of metal fatigue. I mean that was 70 years ago. You'd think it might have crossed his mind.
- pengaru 3y agoI think aluminum is much better understood as having effectively no endurance fatigue limit [0] in that its threshold keeps dropping as the cycles progress. It's expected for cracks to form in aluminum parts of such planes, IIRC they're X-Ray'd on a schedule to discover cracks and replace the relevant parts. I don't know if CF is expected to behave similarly. You certainly don't see it as an obvious quality of CF bicycle frames, as is visible with aluminum frames. The aluminum bikes have such thick beefy tubes and harsh/rigid ride quality to eliminate crack-forming cyclic stresses. CF bikes are considered more comfortable since they don't have to prevent all the flex, as well as being lighter. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:S-N_curves.PNG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:S-N_curves.PNG
- rdtsc 3y ago> At least two former OceanGate employees years ago expressed safety concerns about the vessel’s hull, including the thickness of the material used and testing procedures, > Some expeditions were delayed after OceanGate was forced to rebuild the Titan’s hull because it showed "cyclic fatigue" This looks bad for their safety track record. Employees raised concerns before and they had failed cyclic fatigues tests but they soldered on. There is something to be said about the CEO going onboard themselves, so at least he's a believer in his own technology, but dismissing their own employee's safety concerns is not a great look. Listening to "Sub Brief" video by an 20 year US Navy submariner veteran about this case, there is a bit there that just sounds embarrassing: the CEO is on a call boasting he doesn't like to hire those "50 year old white guys" and instead hired young college graduates who are "inspirational" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4dka29FSZac&t=315 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4dka29FSZac&t=315.
- calyth2018 3y agoAaron Amick called it. An engineering student said that in the video of OceanGate wrapping carbon fibre, they were making a 2nd year engineering mistake of not doing a cross weave. It's basically unidirectional and likely to fail when force is applied to the right angle. Front glass is only rated for 1300m, not 4000m. CEO seems to think the way to test something like this is to take the thing down to 4000m, hear horrible creaking noise. Came back up, and did it again, only to discard the null when it was creaking on the second time. https://www.ctvnews.ca/sci-tech/lawsuit-insufficient-prototype-testing-could-put-titanic-sub-passengers-in-extreme-danger-1.6449907 https://www.ctvnews.ca/sci-tech/lawsuit-insufficient-prototy... I bet the CBS reporter that went down with them in a previous trip is thanking his lucky stars...
- ke88y 3y ago> There is something to be said about the CEO going onboard themselves... We should be allowed to take personal risk. But taking any form of consideration from others -- particularly $250K -- introduces at least moral responsibility for being competent and truthful. This is not just my opinion -- it's how most guiding professions work. Ski guides, mountain guides, rock guides, etc. all have professional cultures and codes of conduct which make it very clear that a guide's risk tolerance in recreational settings has absolutely nothing to do with appropriate risk management in paid settings with clients. Take all the recreational risks you want. The moment you take cash from someone in exchange for guiding services, the moral and legal responsibilities change drastically. If a mountain guide took a client off-route to put up a new line with ratty gear and no beacon -- at the client's request, even -- and they both died? Our response would be "that guide is an irresponsible asshole", not "at least he had skin in the game". > Listening to "Sub Brief" video by an 20 year US Navy submariner veteran about this case, there is a bit there that just sounds embarrassing: the CEO is on a call boasting he doesn't like to hire those "50 year old white guys" and instead hired young college graduates who are "inspirational" Indeed. Using DEI as an excuse to justify paying bottom-dollar and not investing in a real competent safety team is pretty deplorable.
- ineedasername 3y ago>"I firmly believe that the time window available for their rescue is longer than what most people think" This assumes a level of rational, clear-headed thinking in the face of an unanticipated lethal situation. I am not convinced that most people would arrive at that state of reasoning. Especially because, as time goes by without rescue, a somewhat reasonable line of thinking will increasingly become: "The more time they have, the more likely search & rescue is to find the vessel. I can maximize that time by minimizing the # of people using up limited resources. Let me calculate the approximate speed at which a wireless Logitech game controller must be swung in order to induce a lethal head injury to the other resource consumers..."
- jcadam 3y agoReminds me of that old Hitchcock film about the lifeboat...
- webstrand 3y agoNow you get to share a cramped space with a decomposing body. I wonder if a decomposing body uses more oxygen than a living one?
- brandonscott 3y agoat that temp decomp will slow drastically, so it would for sure be consuming less
- pengaru 3y ago> This assumes a level of rational, clear-headed thinking in face of an unanticipated lethal situation. What I wonder is how long before someone realizes they've passed the point of resurfacing alive and happen to have the man responsible for this, trapped in what's now a deep-sea cage-match to the death. If it's lights out either way with high confidence, one of these paths is far more interesting.
- calyth2018 3y agoIt's very doubtful they actually were stuck long enough to even consider that scenario. Most likely it was lost, i.e. imploded, long ago when they initially lost comms. They wouldn't have time to even register the event.
- PerilousD 3y agoI've been following the news on this but from day one. You have one or more rich guys who presumably have some brains and can do some research but they fork over money to an operation that wouldn't have passed safety inspections to look at the bottom of the Hudson river forget about 2.5 miles down in open water. The OceanGate/whatever company deserves the Karma that is rapidly coming their money-grubbing way. The passengers? Hope this ends well for you as I write this but using the brains you were born with is NOT an optional exercise so tears right now are for a cat who died yesterday (put to sleep) because her exploration resulted in a broken back - she died on-the-edge as she lived - dont know what to say about you guys if you dont make it.
- housemusicfan 3y agoStill a more dignified death than if your cat built an ocean-going vessel out of its own litter box using two cans of cat food as ballast, and convinced everyone that safety wasn't an issue. That's what made this story notable.
- encoderer 3y agoDoes anybody know what depth they were expected to be at 1h45m in when comms stopped?
- EA-3167 3y agoIt takes about 2 hours for the full descent to around 12,500' so... around 10k' or thereabouts.