4 ms·

This whole blog is just a regurgitation of surface-level wikipedia knowledge. All of these issues are very well known in the industry. Asking to solve all of th

This whole blog is just a regurgitation of surface-level wikipedia knowledge. All of these issues are very well known in the industry. Asking to solve all of them, perfectly, at once, is clear indication of someone who's never done product development.

fomine3 3y ago
As who don't work in industry (99.999%), it's quite informative blog.
raesene9 3y ago
Out of curiosity, did you look at the About section of the website that the article is from? https://kguttag.com/about-karl-guttag/ https://kguttag.com/about-karl-guttag/
- eutropia 3y ago
  Work Summary Date: 2018-06 to present Organization: RAVN Title: Cheif Science Officer Summary: RAVN is working on augmented reality headsets for military and first responder applications ... Not the GP, but it looks like they work for someone who makes a competing product. A competing product not backed by Apple's absurd R&D budget.
  - raesene9 3y ago
    I believe the author has an extensive background in product development in the area, which is why I was surprised that GGP thought they'd never done it before.
ddalex 3y ago
The guy (Karl Guttag) also writes the wikipedia on these subjects
whynotminot 3y ago
Yeah, these kind of people are the worst in any kind of product ideation session. Nothing is ever worth doing to them because all they do is point out minute flaws the whole time. Contrarianism taken to a level beyond useful devils advocate. The other obnoxious thing here is that he thinks he’s being novel? Like Apple hasn’t considered any of these points over this headset’s near decade-long gestation period? Ultimately though I’ll at least give him credit for putting himself out here so publicly. Plenty of people are harboring private doubts, but he’s setting himself up here for potential posterity, up there with all the people who said the original iPhone would be a failure.

fomine3 3y ago

As who don't work in industry (99.999%), it's quite informative blog.

raesene9 3y ago

Out of curiosity, did you look at the About section of the website that the article is from? https://kguttag.com/about-karl-guttag/ https://kguttag.com/about-karl-guttag/

eutropia 3y ago
Work Summary Date: 2018-06 to present Organization: RAVN Title: Cheif Science Officer Summary: RAVN is working on augmented reality headsets for military and first responder applications ... Not the GP, but it looks like they work for someone who makes a competing product. A competing product not backed by Apple's absurd R&D budget.
- raesene9 3y ago
  I believe the author has an extensive background in product development in the area, which is why I was surprised that GGP thought they'd never done it before.

ddalex 3y ago

The guy (Karl Guttag) also writes the wikipedia on these subjects

whynotminot 3y ago

Yeah, these kind of people are the worst in any kind of product ideation session. Nothing is ever worth doing to them because all they do is point out minute flaws the whole time. Contrarianism taken to a level beyond useful devils advocate. The other obnoxious thing here is that he thinks he’s being novel? Like Apple hasn’t considered any of these points over this headset’s near decade-long gestation period? Ultimately though I’ll at least give him credit for putting himself out here so publicly. Plenty of people are harboring private doubts, but he’s setting himself up here for potential posterity, up there with all the people who said the original iPhone would be a failure.