4 ms·
In addition, open source projects are generally balancing on a knife-edge between irrelevance and obsolescence. Any bureaucratic tool that draws attention away
by roenxi 3y ago
In addition, open source projects are generally balancing on a knife-edge between irrelevance and obsolescence. Any bureaucratic tool that draws attention away from their core focus carries a risk of derailing them.
The CoC people are relatively transparent that they want to be able to push people like Torvalds and Stallman out of projects. Raising the question; do we have a limitless supply of Stallmans and Torvalds out there to draw on, or are these people actually quite rare? From what I can tell they are quite rare and need to be encouraged in the good they do rather than ostracised for the flaws that all humans have in some way or another.
Stallman is a great example. There is a long queue of people lining up to criticise him, but nobody has successfully cobbled together an alternative to the FSF. It wouldn't be hard. GPL 2.0 hit a better sweet spot than 3.0. Nobody has stepped up to the plate.
- LexiMax 3y ago> There is a long queue of people lining up to criticise him, but nobody has successfully cobbled together an alternative to the FSF. This isn't true. I have actually seen several non-FSF/OSI attempts at licenses in the recent past, most notably License Zero with its Prosperity and Parity licenses, as well as alternative licenses like the Server Side Public License and Business Source License. The trouble is that attempting to learn from the lessons of past licenses tends to draw a lot of dogmatic outrage because said licenses either don't conform to the open source definition or four freedoms - or at least, not in the opinion of the OSI or FSF. If developers are unwilling to think outside those boxes en masse, then we are in effect "stuck" with the existing power structures. And that power structure is what led to things like the wide preference of permissive licenses and promoting and prioritizing the GPLv3 over the AGPLv3.
- dmm 3y ago> The trouble is that attempting to learn from the lessons of past licenses tends to draw a lot of dogmatic outrage because said licenses either don't conform to the open source definition or four freedoms - or at least, not in the opinion of the OSI or FSF. They generate outrage because they are accompanied by people trying to change the definition of open-source, not with the idea of alternative licenses.
- LexiMax 3y ago> They generate outrage because they are accompanied by people trying to change the definition of open-source If the precondition of learning lessons from past licenses is that they must follow the rules set by those past licenses as holy writ, then it follows that organizations like the FSF with leaders like RMS are the best you can hope for. Personally, I think we as a community of developers are capable of better.
- dmm 3y agoOpen Source is a term invented in 1998 a direct alternative to Free Software which is the term used by RMS/FSF. Bringing up RMS is irrelevant. If you want to promote licenses which don't meet the definition of FOSS, that's fine! Just call it something else. Here are some ideas: - Shared Source - Clear Source - Awesome Source - Friendly Source - Just Source
- LexiMax 3y agoThese conversations invariably get hijacked by OS/FS advocates who intentionally pick language designed to put any license that doesn't follow its dogma into one big bucket, despite the sometimes significant material differences between them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Source-available_software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Source-available_software
- LtWorf 3y agoAh so it's everyone's fault if they didn't rush to adopt some nonsensical license?
- Plasmoid 3y agoThe problem is that Open Source / Free Software is a Brand. I don't mean registered trademark, I mean a term that denotes specific things to people. CGP Grey's Pirate [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3YFeE1eDlD0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3YFeE1eDlD0] video actually does a really good job explaining what a brand is the core sense. Open source means things and people are right to complain when your license doesn't mean that. So you can have your Source-available licenses, use them if it's right for your project, but stop trying to freeboot off the OS/FS brand.
- RobotToaster 3y ago>Any bureaucratic tool that draws attention away from their core focus carries a risk of derailing them. Probably why M$ owned github encourages them.
- commandlinefan 3y ago[flagged]
- toast0 3y ago> nobody has successfully cobbled together an alternative to the FSF. It wouldn't be hard. GPL 2.0 hit a better sweet spot than 3.0. Nobody has stepped up to the plate. Is there a current need for the FSF or alternatives? There's a wide variety of licenses already developed and between GPL2 and 3, LGPLs, AGPL, BSD/MIT, Apache, Mozilla, and normal commercial licenses, plus or minus PATENTS files, I'm not sure we need an organization that is developing another license, plus advocacy, plus developing a collection of fairly unrelated software at this point. I guess you could say the Apache foundation almost does the same thing, although I don't think they did much advocacy to use their license. Yes, FSF was important, but when it winds down, it will not be replaced by one organization.
- roenxi 3y agoI suspect we agree that, in all there world, there might be literally a single-digit number of people who would found the FSF. If it doesn't look like a good idea now, it looks like an even worse idea when Stallman did it. Nobody believed there was a possibility of it working, let alone that there could possibly be a need. The issue I have is the people who are confident that cancelling that person is a good idea. It seems like a mistake.