2 ms·
OK, fine, consider my opinions and impressions wrong. <shrug> I make this final observation. A company recently asked me for my impression and opinion of thei
by ColinWright 15y ago
OK, fine, consider my opinions and impressions wrong. <shrug>
I make this final observation. A company recently asked me for my impression and opinion of their services. I gave a fairly detailed reply of what I found frustrating and annoying. Interestingly, they took the time to address my points. Equally interestingly, when it was all boiled down to its essence they said: you're wrong.
So if you want to argue with my impressions and opinions, if you want to insist that you've done nothing wrong (against the incontrovertible evidence of the hellban) then that's fine, just don't expect me to take any more time trying to help you see someone else's viewpoint.
Added in edit:
Average karma doean't really mean much. Trolls often say several things that are popular, and mix in their trollish behavior. I'm not saying you are a troll, I'm saying that your behavior has some characteristics in common, and you may easily have been caught in a false positive. The anti-troll code here seems to be pretty well-developed and complex. It's also not documented for obvious reasons, so we can only speculate.
Also, your article "What's so special about Apple products?" just feels like a troll. Again, that's how it feels. getting 14 upvotes is no surprise. If it didn't get dozens of flags from people feeling that it's a troll, then I'd be surprised.
So there you are, my personal opinion. Take it or leave it, stay or leave. Your choice.
- andrea2dallera 15y agoI understand that you think I'm wrong. What I don't understand is why, since it doesn't look like what I write goes against the NH guidelines (http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html), I've been banned. A flamewar is different from a debate. In a flamewar, you just hear people saying "you're wrong". In a debate, you hear people saying "you're wrong because". I believe my comments fall into the second case. The majority of people, given the upvotes, think the same. Plus, I'm not spamming and I very seldomly post comments and links here. Why the need of banning me? Am I disrupting the flow of discussion? This sounds like censorship to me, which is shameful for a site that has "hacker" into its name. The incontrovertible evidence of the hellban is not evidence at all - it's a decision made completely arbirarly by a small group of people. I definitely don't want to be a part of this. EDIT: I believe you understand the implications about a system where opinions against count much more than opinions for. If you tell me that if here an article that receives the same amount of up and downvotes goes to the trashbin then this is such a system. Again, I'm disgusted that I've come here looking for intellectually challenging discussions in the first place.
- ColinWright 15y ago> ... the hellban is ... a decision made completely > arbitrarily by a small group of people. You seem to be under the misapprehension that the hellban is a specific action by a specific group of people. My understanding is that it's automatic, and triggered by various voting patterns. Some of your submissions got flagged by people who thought they were inappropriate. Some of your comments got downvoted (and possibly flagged) by people who thought they were inappropriate. Net result is that the software decided you were a troll, hence the hellban. > I definitely don't want to be a part of this. OK.