3 ms·
You can email PG and ask to be reinstated. As to why, I can offer some insights, if you're willing to listen. I've looked through several of your comments her
by ColinWright 15y ago
You can email PG and ask to be reinstated.
As to why, I can offer some insights, if you're willing to listen. I've looked through several of your comments here:
http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=andreadallera http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=andreadallera
At a quick glance most are pretty much content-free or contain personal attacks, and several have been down-voted into oblivion. You've obviously said things that a lot of people found distasteful, off-topic, unhelpful, or otherwise felt not to be adding value to the site or adhering to the ethos. The net result is that you get banned.
It's easy to express opinions here that are not aligned with everyone else, but it has to be done in such a way that you are felt to be adding value and encouraging engagement. Saying things that are antagonistic, unpopular and largely free of content will get you officially ignored.
- andrea2dallera 15y ago> At a quick glance most are pretty much content-free or contain personal attacks Seriously? I admit that the comments on the thread related to the MCP Pakistani girl that died were controversial at best, but offensive and content-free? If that's the way this community thinks about what I wrote I think we're both better off without each other.
- ColinWright 15y agoDid I say offensive? No, I didn't. The fact that you used the word first suggests that you think it was offensive in this context. I gave you a personal response to try to help you understand the way things work. If you use that to decide that you don't want to be here, that's your choice. My personal assessment for my personal interests is that most of what you've said here is not of interest to me personally. Perhaps others would find it interesting, but I don't. Perhaps others agree, and perhaps that's why you get down-voted, or ignored. These are speculations. The more concrete observation s that getting several comments heavily down-voted gets you a hellban. As I said, you can express controversial opinions here, you jsut need to do it the right way. If you're not willing to learn that, then perhaps you don't belong here. I for one think that people with contrary opinions are valuable, but those opinions need to encourage engagement and not confrontation. It can be done, although it requires effort. Are you willing to try?
- andrea2dallera 15y agoLet's see some data: My comment average is 3.42. I have 3 (three) comments below 0 points, all in that thread. If you look closely you'll see that I've backed up my statements, in a way I believe to be coherent and well-put, for every single case I've been downvoted. Those replies have been heavily upvoted. In that same thread, there are many users that have been also downvoted to hell, much more than I've been. I don't see them banned. Just to add, I've submitted a blog post of mine (What's so special about Apple products?, http://usingimho.wordpress.com/2011/05/08/whats-so-special-about-apple-products/ http://usingimho.wordpress.com/2011/05/08/whats-so-special-a... ) that reached 14 points in a little more than one hour and subsequently removed. Why was that? Did people find it interesting? The votes said so. Why was it removed? Again, if the way this community is run is "I don't like it, I remove it", then I'm happy to take my bags and leave for better places. But please don't tell me that I've been removed because what I post is offensive or not interesting, because that's blatantly false.
- ColinWright 15y agoOK, fine, consider my opinions and impressions wrong. <shrug> I make this final observation. A company recently asked me for my impression and opinion of their services. I gave a fairly detailed reply of what I found frustrating and annoying. Interestingly, they took the time to address my points. Equally interestingly, when it was all boiled down to its essence they said: you're wrong. So if you want to argue with my impressions and opinions, if you want to insist that you've done nothing wrong (against the incontrovertible evidence of the hellban) then that's fine, just don't expect me to take any more time trying to help you see someone else's viewpoint. Added in edit: Average karma doean't really mean much. Trolls often say several things that are popular, and mix in their trollish behavior. I'm not saying you are a troll, I'm saying that your behavior has some characteristics in common, and you may easily have been caught in a false positive. The anti-troll code here seems to be pretty well-developed and complex. It's also not documented for obvious reasons, so we can only speculate. Also, your article "What's so special about Apple products?" just feels like a troll. Again, that's how it feels. getting 14 upvotes is no surprise. If it didn't get dozens of flags from people feeling that it's a troll, then I'd be surprised. So there you are, my personal opinion. Take it or leave it, stay or leave. Your choice.