3 ms·
…never possible… I disagree. Consider a computer like the Apple ][. I didn't 'completely understand' it at the time, but with what I've learned since (includin
by gojomo 15y ago
…never possible…
I disagree. Consider a computer like the Apple ][. I didn't 'completely understand' it at the time, but with what I've learned since (including a CS degree), it is now very plausible to me that it could be exhaustively understood, down to every wire and line of OS/firmware code. I can see the boundaries of the areas I don't know clearly, and know that a bounded amount of extra effort could get me down through every 6502 opcode, or all relevant functional physical/electrical properties of all the subsystems.
(While I'm still not strong in the electrical engineering parts, the exercise in my undergrad EECS class where we built a 4-bit CPU from TTL components was the key for me in connecting the electrical world of circuits and logic gates to the abstractions of executable software.)
Maybe, nowadays, the typical systems (like the article's MacBook Air example) are too big, drawing from too many specialties and involving too many details, for any one person to decompose 'all the black boxes' with comprehensive understanding. But just a few decades ago, that wasn't yet the case.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoWhat I think was possible was understanding down to the level that you could reliably know what caused the Apple II to act in any given way. Was it possible all the way down to the transistor level? Maybe not, but it didn't have to be in order to understand the behavior. It was certainly possible down through the IC level, and there were any number of people who achieved that sort of mastery. I don't believe that's still possible with any consumer general purpose computer. I think there are people out there with that level of understanding of specialized devices, probably up to and including things like Xbox and PS3. I don't know if there are people that understand an airbook to that level, or a desktop PC, or their webserver. Maybe, but it seems unlikely.