3 ms·
> But it turned out that academia doesn’t really do this anymore, it just sells itself as doing these things. What do you mean by 'anymore'. Was there some go
by eru 3y ago
> But it turned out that academia doesn’t really do this anymore, it just sells itself as doing these things.
What do you mean by 'anymore'. Was there some golden age of bygone glory?
- TX81Z 3y agoTo some degree yes. As the world got more globalized and the number of prestigious universities basically stayed the same while the number of people getting PhDs skyrocketed, the competition for jobs at even third-tier schools became outrageous. You either play the game and survive - often at the cost of your integrity. Or you walk. I walked. No regrets.
- hgsgm 3y agoAcademics used to be rich people (entrepreneurs or aristocrats) who funded their own work. Then (late 1800s?) it changed to a profession, and the focus became extracting funding from ignorant patrons.
- kneebonian 3y agoI'd argue there was to some extent. I mean psych has always had issues, but it seems from the late 1800's to the mid 1970's would characterize the golden age. During this time science that produced results and was verifiable and reproducible experienced a huge boom. In part because during this time period almost every nation on earth got involved at some point in a life or death struggle which turns to do a pretty good job at cutting through science that doesn't hold water when it's the difference between your country winning and your countrymen being slaughtered. As proof of this most of the open question in fundamental physics are the same ones that were open at the time of Einstein's death.
- eru 3y agoMy null hypothesis for that golden age from late 1800s til mid-1970s is that they just found all the low hanging fruit? See https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/11/17/the-alzheimer-photo/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/11/17/the-alzheimer-photo/ for background. Compare also how even second rate people could do first rate work in the last fifteen years by applying deep learning to new domains. You mention that war has a certain tendency to cut through bullshit. Ideally, market competition also does some of that. See https://gwern.net/backstop https://gwern.net/backstop for a more general exploration: > I suggest interpreting phenomenon as multi-level nested optimization paradigm: many systems can be usefully described as having two (or more) levels where a slow sample-inefficient but ground-truth ‘outer’ loss such as death, bankruptcy, or reproductive fitness, trains & constrains a fast sample-efficient but possibly misguided ‘inner’ loss which is used by learned mechanisms such as neural networks or linear programming group selection perspective.
- mnw21cam 3y agoI think they meant "any more".
- red-iron-pine 3y agoWorld Wars happened and everyone died. US schools had all the money and took off, and the handful of other institutions in the Old World did alright. Lots of new science to uncover, a lot of which would be basic 100-200 level college courses these days. lotta new things to pioneer. my grandpa did a lot of work with plastics, for example, that are now pretty basic; new stuff then, but now no one thinks about their 0.9 cent plastic lid on their coffee. lots of mobility but the world wasn't hyper connected, so you could do a trip to somewhere more obscure like Indonesia or Zimbabwe and do research. Now you can just email them the questionnaire. Years of high schools pushing college now means there are legions of grads, plenty of whom will chase academia. smaller world + growing demand = ruthless academic posturing.