4 ms·
As I said in another conversation about deleting stuff on HN: Let's say you make a comment or a post. Let's say I reply. Then you want to delete your comment
by AnimalMuppet 3y ago
As I said in another conversation about deleting stuff on HN:
Let's say you make a comment or a post. Let's say I reply. Then you want to delete your comment/post. What happens to my reply? There are no good options.
You could delete it, but I didn't ask for my comment to be deleted, so that seems kind of unfair.
You could remove the parent and leave the child. But that doesn't work if the parent is a post, because HN doesn't have a place for comments that are not under some top-level post. You could make the orphaned comment its own top-level post, but if the post had several top-level comments in reply, that would be kind of an avalanche of new posts-that-had-been-top-level-comments.
Even in the case of removing a comment, though, it still damages replies in another way - they lose context. I'm replying to something, but nobody can see what, so my reply is just floating out there, disconnected from what prompted it. It doesn't make sense any more.
So I think HN is right in not allowing deletes, at least of things that have been replied to.
- pestatije 3y agoso you think things shouldnt be done just because they are complicated?
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoThat is not what I said, and not what I meant. Person A writes a comment. Person B responds. A's desire to remove their comment does not give them the right to delete or damage B's comment. "Difficult" has nothing to do with it. The problem is that you have to consider B's rights here, not just A's.