4 ms·
I see all these "Alternative to $FOO" type projects that differ in the implementation but not in the result; IOW to the end-user the product looks and behaves p
by lelanthran 3y ago
I see all these "Alternative to $FOO" type projects that differ in the implementation but not in the result; IOW to the end-user the product looks and behaves practically the same as $FOO.
I understand wanting to produce an alternative, but I can't help but wonder why not produce an alternative that is substantially different?[1]
From the screenshots Linen is almost a clone of Slack, with (I think) the biggest difference being "google-indexable". There's literally, on the landing page, no compelling reason for using this product over Slack.
Looking at the landing page for Linen[2], I don't see anything about why one would choose Linen over Slack other than "google-indexable" and "advanced thread management"[3].
I think the biggest differentiator is pricing, but that is not an issue for companies using Slack, and unprofitable targeting anyone who finds Slack too expensive.
[1] The easy "substantially different" thing to do would be to rearrange the layout. The hard "substantially different" thing to do would be to actually have a performant chat program that starts in <10ms and consumes under 100MB in normal and active daily use.
[2] https://www.linen.dev/ https://www.linen.dev/
[3] Managing conversation threads in IM is not a problem I've heard anyone complain about, TBH.
- keyle 3y agoLinen is significantly cheaper than Slack $10/month for up to 100 users compared to Slack's $7.25/user/month. What it really comes down to is integrations. For a team to consider Linen, they'd have to get their Jira tickets in there, bitbucket/github hooks etc. as well as external integration with Okta/azure SSO etc. That will make or break Linen, more so than being indexable. Because if you want indexed content, you're likely working on an open source project or are open which means without revenues, and so you won't be willing to pay much. I'm glad an alternative to Slack, cheaper, with open search is available.
- lelanthran 3y ago> $10/month for up to 100 users compared to Slack's $7.25/user/month. > For a team to consider Linen, they'd have to get their Jira tickets in there, bitbucket/github hooks etc. as well as external integration with Okta/azure SSO etc. Yeah, but those things cost money, usually per user, and with good reason. Just comprehensive SSO alone is something that costs around $5/user/month. Sure, the Linen team could write it themselves, but it won't work anywhere nearly as nicely or as performant as signing up for an SSO service that works with everything a corporate uses for sign-ins. So, yeah, it can be $1/user/month now, but it's unlikely to remain that way when they need to add in all the Slack functionality. It's also unlikely to remain performant when it matches Slack feature-for-feature.