3 ms·
> You're right, FLOSS phones currently aren't good. But they finally exist, and that's enough for me to be excited about Also people forget that android is sti
by CuriousCosmic 3y ago
> You're right, FLOSS phones currently aren't good. But they finally exist, and that's enough for me to be excited about
Also people forget that android is still FLOSS. You don't need to be running upstream/mainline linux to be FLOSS. It's mentioned kinda off hand as "oh well running android without google sucks" in the article but graphene OS has proven that you can get a very pleasant, well ironed, and secure/hardened user oriented phone while using FLOSS for basically everything except some firmware level blobs for high end phones. And FDroid proves that we can have 90-95% of all the quality apps we could need without even installing anything google dependent (even FCM push notifications which were historically limiting can be replaced with unifiedpush) That experience contrasts with the "FLOSS phones" like the librem or pine phone which show that you can get most if not all of the hardware working without firmware blobs even if the software up the stack sucks.
So what is stopping us from just starting with one of the generic AOSP targets for graphene os and focusing it for one of these FLOSS targets?
Do we just not have the specs in the hardware with decent FLOSS support? If that's the case, doesn't that mean we are quite literally steps from the finish line?
- ttarr 3y agoYou raise a good question, unfortunately I asked the same and no one seems to know the answer. My other question was, why the first iPhone is significantly faster than a recent PinePhone.
- CuriousCosmic 3y agoHonestly it depends. The PinePhone Pro (which I've only briefly interacted with and do not own) seems like it works well, if a bit buggy, and with a fairly unoptimised UX derived mostly from desktop linux. Given that there's a handful of supported OSes/images (between android and linux) and just as many unofficial ones, it could be that we have only interacted with less polished SW. Also FOSS GPU support depending on what device/SOC you have really varies. So weak GPU support can end up handicapping the experience. Personally I'd like to mess with an android pinephone pro (not the stock "linux with android containers") but I'm not willing to foot the bill to set one up to play with.