3 ms·
Off-topic, but it just occurred to me that the "dialog" in this article between the author and the "Haskie" dog is a very traditional way of writing pedagogical
by sudobash1 3y ago
Off-topic, but it just occurred to me that the "dialog" in this article between the author and the "Haskie" dog is a very traditional way of writing pedagogical works.
Some historical examples of books written in this way are Galileo's "Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems" (the one that landed him in hot water), and "The Study of Counterpoint" by Johann Joseph Fux (also in the 17th century).
A small excerpt from "The Study of Counterpoint":
>Joseph.— Why did you leave out B between A and C?
> Aloys.— Because it has no perfect fifth and therefore cannot
be the final of a mode -- which we shall discuss more fully in its proper
place.
Both of these books are written as an entire discussion or argument, as was commonplace in teaching books. I honestly often find myself disliking it, but I think it is a great way to learn for many people.
- samwho 3y agoI didn't know this. I created Haskie during the writing of my Memory Allocation post because I found myself trying to pre-empt reader questions a lot and it was weird to read. Creating a proxy for the reader in Haskie made it flow a lot better. I've noticed in this post that a 2nd character that's a proxy for an "expert" in a topic would also be handy. Taking suggestions for a good dog breed to represent this character.