3 ms·

Interesting that you mention TorchScript, but not TorchDynamo+TorchInductor from PT2.

by voz_ 3y ago

tekknolagi 3y ago
Not intentional. I'm not familiar with the latter two. I'll take a look- thanks
- voz_ 3y ago
  Yeah, no malice or any such thing assumed :P Let me know if you have questions!
  - tekknolagi 3y ago
    Well your bio indicates I shouldn't ask ;) but how would you differentiate them? I'm very unfamiliar with the ML tooling space
    - voz_ 3y ago
      Emailed
      - mathisfun123 3y ago
        It's funny I was thinking aren't both these guys at FB - couldn't they just chat over WP. But I will say that despite your enthusiasm for inductor/dynamo, I think it's an extremely poor substitute for TS where whole graph compilation is concerned. But hey I get it jansel has spoken and the bright blue future is compiling one stack frame at a time and the graph breaks will continue until morale has improved ;)
        tekknolagi 3y ago
        Ah, I left FB in February. Now I am in grad school
        mathisfun123 3y ago
        congrats! enjoy :)
        tekknolagi 3y ago
        Thanks! We'll see what weird things it brings
        voz_ 3y ago
        > where whole graph compilation is concerned. Just put nopython=True on it? I don't think snark from anon accounts are cute btw. Identity or politeness or gtfo.
        mathisfun123 3y ago
        >Just put nopython=True on it? umm that just percolates up the errors? you're still not guaranteed to successfully get a whole-program graph (only that if you get any graph at all then it is whole-program). >I don't think snark from anon accounts are cute btw. Identity or politeness or gtfo. the lady doth protest a little too much, me thinks - i was just making a joke about the transition being top-down rather than bottom-up. also it's not like you have your home address listed here so not sure i should post mine either.
        voz_ 3y ago
        > the lady doth protest a little too much, me thinks You quoted it wrong > also it's not like you have your home address listed here so not sure i should post mine either. tisk tisk you and I both know thats not what I mean

Interesting that you mention TorchScript, but not TorchDynamo+TorchInductor from PT2.

by voz_ 3y ago

Interesting that you mention TorchScript, but not TorchDynamo+TorchInductor from PT2.

tekknolagi 3y ago

Not intentional. I'm not familiar with the latter two. I'll take a look- thanks

voz_ 3y ago
Yeah, no malice or any such thing assumed :P Let me know if you have questions!
- tekknolagi 3y ago
  Well your bio indicates I shouldn't ask ;) but how would you differentiate them? I'm very unfamiliar with the ML tooling space
  - voz_ 3y ago
    Emailed
    - mathisfun123 3y ago
      It's funny I was thinking aren't both these guys at FB - couldn't they just chat over WP. But I will say that despite your enthusiasm for inductor/dynamo, I think it's an extremely poor substitute for TS where whole graph compilation is concerned. But hey I get it jansel has spoken and the bright blue future is compiling one stack frame at a time and the graph breaks will continue until morale has improved ;)
      - tekknolagi 3y ago
        Ah, I left FB in February. Now I am in grad school
        mathisfun123 3y ago
        congrats! enjoy :)
        tekknolagi 3y ago
        Thanks! We'll see what weird things it brings
      - voz_ 3y ago
        > where whole graph compilation is concerned. Just put nopython=True on it? I don't think snark from anon accounts are cute btw. Identity or politeness or gtfo.
        mathisfun123 3y ago
        >Just put nopython=True on it? umm that just percolates up the errors? you're still not guaranteed to successfully get a whole-program graph (only that if you get any graph at all then it is whole-program). >I don't think snark from anon accounts are cute btw. Identity or politeness or gtfo. the lady doth protest a little too much, me thinks - i was just making a joke about the transition being top-down rather than bottom-up. also it's not like you have your home address listed here so not sure i should post mine either.
        voz_ 3y ago
        > the lady doth protest a little too much, me thinks You quoted it wrong > also it's not like you have your home address listed here so not sure i should post mine either. tisk tisk you and I both know thats not what I mean