3 ms·
Why would carbon fiber be a suitable material for this application? I get why people want it to be lightweight and resist environmental corrosion, but it just s
by jeffbee 3y ago
Why would carbon fiber be a suitable material for this application? I get why people want it to be lightweight and resist environmental corrosion, but it just seems like the wrong choice under hydrostatic pressure. I found some recent academic articles analyzing composite cylinders for submersible applications and in those papers they buckled at a fraction of the pressure equivalent to 4000m of seawater. The fact that they advertise their suite of strain gauges seems to indicate that they under-designed the thing and intended to just see what happened in practice.
- aredox 3y agoThere were lots of wrong choices and execution in the design of this submarine (no, using a joypad isn't one of them. There are far more worse details).
- bambax 3y agoUsing a joypad isn't a big problem in itself, but using a wireless one is extremely careless. What if the connection is lost? What if batteries die? Or leak? Etc.
- afavour 3y agoI imagine (though with these people who knows) they’d just plug it in as a USB device. Almost all wireless controllers are capable of it.
- egeozcan 3y agoIf the batteries leak, you have toxic material inside the cabin (perhaps you retain control because you surely have replacements!). It's probably one of the last things you need in such environments, especially using a stupid cable with a couple of backups eliminates a big single point of failure.
- ThatPlayer 3y agoThis specific controller does not. The Logitech F710, I've got one on my desk right now. It has zero ports and only works wirelessly. It uses AA batteries so there's no need for a charging port either. For wired use, Logitech have the cheaper F310 that lacks rumble, and the discontinued F510.
- londons_explore 3y agoI'd just want to make the whole thing out of a massive steel pipe with welded end caps. Make the thing 200 mm thick, and a 2m diameter cylinder should be good down to 8 kilometers (so 4 kilometers with a 2x safety margin). Steel is expensive when it's 200 millimeters thick... But when you're done with the sub, you can melt it down and get most of the value back again! A window is probably the hardest part - acrylic would need to be nearly a yard thick! Glass could do it, but casting huge bits of glass is really hard. The craft is super heavy and impossible to transport by land - but it ends up being nearly neutrally buoyant, so you just tow it in the ocean to wherever it is needed.
- euroderf 3y agoThis might be overkill, while failing to take advantage of (very) prior art. FWIW, Finland's biggest (AFAIK) tangle with COCOM export controls (against the USSR) was about deep-diving submersibles. In Finnish: https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mir_(sukellusalus) https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mir_(sukellusalus) English summary: https://www.inventingeurope.eu/story/cold-war-hot-water-the-mir-submarine https://www.inventingeurope.eu/story/cold-war-hot-water-the-...
- theshrike79 3y agoRandom trivia: CIA and Pentagon forced Finland to stop making those because we were selling them to the Soviet Union. The people who did them moved on and retired, we pretty much forgot how to make more.
- perihelions 3y agoAlso pointing in that direction (?), - "Lochridge’s recommendation was that non-destructive testing of the Titan’s hull was necessary to ensure a “solid and safe product.” The filing states that Lochridge was told that such testing was impossible, and that OceanGate would instead rely on its much touted acoustic monitoring system." - "The company claims this technology, developed in-house, uses acoustic sensors to listen for the tell-tale sounds of carbon fibers in the hull deteriorating to provide “early warning detection for the pilot with enough time to arrest the descent and safely return to surface.”" https://techcrunch.com/2023/06/20/a-whistleblower-raised-safety-concerns-about-oceangates-submersible-in-2018-then-he-was-fired/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/06/20/a-whistleblower-raised-saf...
- throw9away6 3y agoI don’t understand how they couldn’t NDT that tiny thing. They could have done it with a 10k tool and a week or less of work. Or the could have done it in a couple weeks with a grid and manual probe. The only reason it would be impossible is if they had so many defects they could never show it good in the first place and expected it to fail, just couldn’t predict when.
- mcpackieh 3y agoFrom this comment in the other thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36394421 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36394421 > OceanGate CEO Stockton Rush says the company had been evaluating the potential of using a carbon fiber composite hull since 2010, primarily because it permits creation of a pressure vessel that is naturally buoyant and, therefore, would enable OceanGate to forgo the use — and the significant expense — of syntactic foam on its exterior. https://www.compositesworld.com/articles/composite-submersibles-under-pressure-in-deep-deep-waters https://www.compositesworld.com/articles/composite-submersib...
- jacurtis 3y agoThat was my immediate reaction when I read "carbon fiber tube". Really? Carbon fiber doesnt seem like the right choice, but I am not a submarine designer. Maybe there's something I don't know. But for me it immediately felt wrong.
- egeozcan 3y agoThe worst thing about it is that it doesn't bend, it just cracks.