3 ms·
Ok, I just have to resign myself to the fact that none of the explanations here make any sense to me whatsoever. It all sounds extremely shady. I guess this is
by JohnFen 3y ago
Ok, I just have to resign myself to the fact that none of the explanations here make any sense to me whatsoever. It all sounds extremely shady. I guess this is why I didn't go into finance as a career.
- phil21 3y agoI have a one man SaaS that nets me $100k/yr in revenue. It's button-click simple to setup and requires zero maintenance aside from collecting the money each month. The net assets are basically $15,000 worth of IT gear like a laptop and some servers. There is current month to month contracted revenue spread across a diverse base of users paying $5-100/mo each. How much would you offer me for this company? How much would you take for this company if you currently owned it? Something is worth what someone else is willing to pay for it. Obviously whatever the company sells for is worth exactly that amount at that moment in time. Valuing such a business at $15k would be absurd, just as valuing it at $15m would be. Thus, the difference in asset value vs. what you paid is just called "goodwill" - perhaps the name hangs people up a lot. If you then turn around and sell the same company later for a loss, you take a write down on that goodwill. Certainly not perfect, but there aren't too many other ways you can express the present value of a company other than what it sells for.
- JohnFen 3y ago> have a one man SaaS that nets me $100k/yr in revenue. That 100k/yr, though, is tangible and pricing it is straightforward. That's a very different situation that doesn't require making numbers up. > Thus, the difference in asset value vs. what you paid is just called "goodwill" - perhaps the name hangs people up a lot. The name absolutely doesn't help, but I don't think that's what I'm hung up on. I'm hung up on the idea of making up a monetary figure out of whole cloth and pretending it's real in some way. This disconnect confuses me greatly, and the only way I can make it make sense in my head is in the sense of "creative accounting". Which just explains why I didn't choose a career in finance, and highlights why I view the financial world generally with tremendous skepticism.
- ruds 3y agoThe monetary number is not made up out of whole cloth. It's the difference between the book value of the tangible assets of a company as an accountant understands them, and the amount paid for the company. An income stream arising from the operations of a business doesn't count as a tangible asset. You can absolutely assign a value to that stream. That's how you arrived at the purchase price in the first place! But that income hasn't been realized yet and it's not written in stone. The income could be higher or lower depending on what happens in the future.
- rodgerd 3y agoI suspect the name "goodwill" doesn't really help, either. It's just that accounting wants both sides of the ledger to balance, and this is the bucket that was chosen a long time ago to balance the difference between traditional assets and intangibles. I will say that while I don't think goodwill is sus in and of itself, your intuition that people doing things with the goodwill value can be sus. If I buy a company with $10m in assets and $5m in goodwill, and a year later announce I'm writing down the goodwill to $1m, something is definitely up! I may have mis-managed the company into the ground. It may be that the premium I paid was based on fraudulent assessment of the intangibles (e.g. a bunch of future sales that never existed), things like that.
- JohnFen 3y ago> I suspect the name "goodwill" doesn't really help, either I said in an earlier comment that I didn't think I was getting hung up on the name, but I had a thought that hints that maybe I am. If it were called "slop" instead of "goodwill", I think I would be less bothered by it. don't get me wrong, it would still bother me -- and I wouldn't understand it any better -- but it would feel less like a term someone would use when trying to pull a fast one. > It's just that accounting wants both sides of the ledger to balance Yeah, you and a couple of other people keep saying that, but I don't really understand what that means. I mean, I know what having both sides of the ledger balance means, but this sort of example seems bizarre and extremely suspect to me. It just looks for all the world like people making stuff up. That's OK. I can't understand everything, and this isn't something that's actually important for me to understand.
- ruds 3y agoHere's what's balancing: I've traded assets worth X dollars for a company with Y dollars of tangible assets plus G, the fudge factor that makes both sides equal. I've traded X dollars of assets for X dollars of assets, where Y dollars is like real estate and cash in the bank and financial instruments and tools and stuff, and G = X - Y is some intangible/uncertain/something that caused me to pay $X for $Y of stuff. Before the purchase, I had some pile of assets worth $A. After the purchase, I still have some pile of assets worth $A. The purchase balances.