2 ms·
"academicians with opinions"? Really? Have we reverted to name calling? Few people here have grown up on a farm. But even if you have, it's not representative
by scarmig 15y ago
"academicians with opinions"? Really? Have we reverted to name calling?
Few people here have grown up on a farm. But even if you have, it's not representative of what historians and anthropologists study when they study peasant societies. Agriculture is thoroughly embedded in the market nowadays. You can't compare the experience of a struggling family farmer in Iowa, under siege by corporate interests and the demands of the market, with the experiences of the average pre-industrial peasant. A businessman running a gas station in Dallas has more in common with the Iowa farmer than the pre-industrial peasant does.
There are very few places in the world nowadays that are comparable to even the recent (several centuries) past. There is, however, a lot of evidence about how people lived back in the day. Enough evidence, actually, that tens of thousands of people study it.