4 ms·
Not being advertised for or primarily used for copyright infringement.
by pjc50 3y ago
Not being advertised for or primarily used for copyright infringement.
- jeroenhd 3y agoIn what way is uploading the music you bought to private cloud storage illegal? Google Music asked me to upload songs and I did. Is Google really going to get sued to oblivion? I doubt it.
- bcx5k15 3y agoDepends where you live In the UK its technically illegal to rip a CD to your own PC to back it up, for example, see the recent high court case(s) about it where the government won against Brennan (who make hifi gear which can do this) - no different to this app.
- mnw21cam 3y agoI was under the impression that this had been changed in the last few years. Do you have a link for that case?
- masfuerte 3y agoIn 2014 the government passed a law making ripping explicitly legal. In 2015 the music industry sued and the High Court ruled that the law was contrary to some EU directive and thus invalid. But I don't know if that law was annulled by the court decision, or if it was merely dormant until we left the EU. The Brennan ripping devices are still on sale. Do you have a link to this case?
- pja 3y agoI’m still getting adverts for Brennan thingies online, did they find a way around the court judgement?
- evandale 3y agoTo be fair, the music industry knows they couldn't beat Google in court on this. The same can't be said for OP who probably doesn't have the time or money to fight it as evidenced by this post.
- pjc50 3y agoGoogle Music (fka Google Play Music) have license agreements! e.g. https://www.cmrra.ca/socan-csi-strike-licensing-deal-with-google-play-for-canadas-music-creators/ https://www.cmrra.ca/socan-csi-strike-licensing-deal-with-go... Part of the reason google/youtube are quasi-monopolistic is that they've already been through all of this, they've had the arguments and the lawsuits in various different territories, and they've reached agreements and paid money to deal with the copyright issues.
- lloeki 3y agoThey had matching though, so if you had a lousy quality mp3 that matches through audio fingerprinting it would be upgraded.
- josephcsible 3y agoDid you miss this sentence, or are you disagreeing with it? > According to Capitol Records, Inc. v. MP3Tunes, LLC, this is absolutely OK in the eyes of the law
- pjc50 3y agoWhat precisely does "this" refer to in that sentence? https://casetext.com/case/capitol-records-inc-v-mp3tunes-llc https://casetext.com/case/capitol-records-inc-v-mp3tunes-llc From a quick read of that, it appears that Mp3tunes lost the case, had a huge damages award made against them, as happens a lot, and the overall damages were deemed excessive and reduced to $750k.
- tzs 3y agoI haven't actually read the case, but from the summaries I've seen it sounds like MP3Tunes won on the parts that matter when it comes to whether or not one can legally run a music locker service without permission from the copyright owners. In particular is said that the DMCA safe harbor is available to such services, and that deduplication is not a problem. MP3Tunes did not adequately deal with DMCA takedown requests so didn't get full safe harbor protection leaving them liable for some user's uploads. Also MP3Tunes' founder had infringing songs stored and they got nailed for those.
- joshmanders 3y agoThis is straight up victim blaming.