9 ms·
> The very idea that, once work hours were over, no one could get hold of you—via email, text, Slack, whatever—is completely alien to contemporary young people,
by ryandrake 3y ago
> The very idea that, once work hours were over, no one could get hold of you—via email, text, Slack, whatever—is completely alien to contemporary young people, who never let their cellphones leave their hands.
If your work requires a phone or computer, they should be providing a dedicated device. Then, turn off your work devices when you are done with work for the day. I know I didn’t invent this solution just now. Who are these people carrying around their work phone when they are not working or on call? If you are working at a place where this is the norm (I did, briefly) leave. It’s not worth it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Hermel 3y agoDepends on your position and motivation. I myself am always reachable and read my emails day and night. I enjoy being involved with my company just as others enjoy checking their personal emails every hour.
- sledgehammers 3y agoYou are welcome to do as you please. As a collective, we need to acknowledge the burnout epidemic. People need to have the honest freedom to be offline, without any social or business pressure. There's more to life than emails and a corporation that is free to fire you at any point.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoNot to mention that, this can translate into neglect of one's duties, such as one's duties toward family, duties that, broadly, have higher priority than the wants or even needs of an employer.
- soupfordummies 3y ago>>You are welcome to do as you please. Personally, I wouldn't even go that far. Some choosing to give up their personal life in exchange for always-on work life push the needle into normalization for the rest of us that DON'T choose that.
- smabie 3y agoYou're suggesting that some people shouldn't be allowed to work harder than others?
- soupfordummies 3y agoGood question. Not necessarily, but I think the crux of your question w/r/t my statement is the distinction between "workaholic" type behavior and "working harder". Would I suggest that a company shouldn't ALLOW it's FT/exempt employees to work over, say, 45hrs/week? Hell yes! Mandated work-life balance sounds great.
- MandieD 3y agoKind of like how social mores and corporate policies against supervisors having romantic relationships with their underlings protect not only employees who do not want to be pressured to date their managers, but also the colleagues of an employee who otherwise would try to get an edge by sleeping with the boss.
- le-mark 3y agoThat’s fine you do you and all. But I hope everyone is aware that normalizing this behavior is toxic af. This article did make me realize how chill my current boss and team are, I don’t give work a thought during off hours which is really nice.
- d0gsg0w00f 3y agoIt's not really "normalization". It's just I want to do better than everyone else so I make it a point to do more.
- le-mark 3y agoDoing more is rarely “doing better”. In fact it’s often worse.
- maerF0x0 3y ago> I enjoy being involved with my company... And you're probably subconsciously aware that it's a dopamine trap[1]. Probably the greatest fallacy of our time is that just because you enjoy something equates with it's good for you (or "if it feels good do it"). I super enjoy a taco bell run at 11PM even after I've hit my TDEE. Notice how that sentence is almost identical in structure, underlying point, and absurdity, to the sentence "I enjoy checking my email at 11PM even after I've logged 8 hours that day". [1]: https://blog.superhuman.com/how-to-stop-checking-your-email/#:~:text=Your%20brain%20rewards%20you%20with,that%20same%20rush%20of%20dopamine https://blog.superhuman.com/how-to-stop-checking-your-email/....
- LatteLazy 3y agoGreat, now I have to carry around, manage, charge and use 2 different devices. If you don't want to use your personal device for work, don't. But let's not pretend this is some great social, moral struggle against evil.
- antoinealb 3y agoI use Android with work profile and just turn it off at the end of the day (actually have it automatically scheduled). Definitely took some discipline at first but now I'm really disconnected on days off.
- Detrytus 3y agoDifferent profiles do you no good. Under US law, if there's an investigation against your employer, you might be required to hand over any device that you used to access your work email, or other data. That's why your work phone should be a separate device, not just a profile.
- HWR_14 3y agoThe point is with two devices, you don't actually have to carry both around at the same time. You can leave your work device at work or in a drawer.
- hinkley 3y agoOr on the charger, killing two birds with one stone.
- abwizz 3y agoime ppl do the trade of beeing available most of the time in exchange for not having to be present all the time. but yes, this trade is not respected in a lot of places
- ghaff 3y agoAs someone who lived and worked in the pre-cell phone era (and certainly well before the phone was always on you era), yes. You maybe weren't casually reachable off-hours but the trade was that you basically had to be by your landline and terminal during work hours without much interruption.
- hotpotamus 3y ago> Who are these people carrying around their work phone when they are not working or on call? I assume people who want to get promoted. I can't say I really count myself among them; I thought the whole point of automation was that I wouldn't have to work unendingly, but that doesn't seem to be way things have worked out.
- doubled112 3y agoCarrying the work device? That’s the expectation where I work. The norm. What if something happens? Mine still gets put down and ignored when I’m done my day. People hate this. People hate that I’ve disabled my notifications too, but when I ask “do I respond in a reasonable amount of time?” the answer is always “yes”. Be the change you want to see, and all that, I guess.
- isykt 3y agoI’ve had this discussion before, many times, but less directly. I’ve usually pointed to the 3 or 4 people in our team who have left over the past few years due to burnout, and mention that all of us are so well paid that any one of us could afford to take years off to find something less stressful if we wanted. My point being: I need a break. You can have some of me for a long time or most of me for a short time, and the more of me you ask for now the less you’ll have later. Hiring is expensive.
- pavlov 3y agoIt's starting to feel like the point of automation was to turn a small group of people into anointed 24-hour career slaves who can dream of joining the 1% if they can keep up with the machine, and leave everybody else to scrape by with unstable, meaningless and often inhuman work but tons of media to consume.
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoExcept I am willing to bet these sorts of people aren't promoted at a rate that is commensurate with their expectations. This is a variation of what I might call the sycophant or nice guy paradox. The sycophant and the nice guy are desperate to be liked. They believe that if they prioritize pleasing people over the truth and what is morally right, they will be liked in return. Of course, that isn't what happens. No one respects the nice guy, and rightly so, because the nice guy is contemptible. He has essentially been shouting from the rooftops his lack of dignity and worth, his willingness to violate all true principles, and his readiness to comprise morally, for the sake of being liked (how lowly a person like that must be). The only people who are respected are the people who have staked themselves to the true and the good, not the Willy Lomans of the world. This, too, is similar to the hedonist: when pleasure becomes the purpose of one's actions and the things sought, they cease to be pleasurable. When an employer sees that they can squeeze more work out of an employee for less money, then why bother paying them more? Do good work within the bounds of the contract. In general, if the employer wants more, he has got to pay more.
- keithalewis 3y agoPeople also used to have lawns that they could tell the damn kids to get off of. At least we still have clouds to yell at.
- pyrale 3y agoWith heatwaves, clouds aren't what they used to be, though. Clouds were much better back then, I tell you.
- smcleod 3y agoWhile I agree that workplaces should /offer/ a work phone if required - I would rather just have one. I don’t want to carry and manage two phones. I just set anything work related to not alert me after 5pm which works well.
- distances 3y agoI think many people would do fine without anything work related in their phones. I know I do. My phone has no work email, teams, or slack. I haven't received a work related phone call in probably about ten years now (except when interviewing), if I'm not online people will just wait until I'm back. I can be reached during work hours when I'm in front of the computer. I can't be reached during a lunch break. This has worked fine for me.
- soupfordummies 3y agoIn that case the workplace should just give a stipend. Honestly I think there may be legal reasons for doing so-- the last place I had that offered that was because HR REQUIRED it.
- msla 3y ago> The very idea that, once work hours were over, no one could get hold of you—via email, text, Slack, whatever—is completely alien to contemporary young people, who never let their cellphones leave their hands. It would have been alien to my dad, who not only had a cell phone well before 2002, but also had pagers prior to that because being an anesthetist means you take call. The cell phone was better because it meant he didn't have to find a payphone when the pager alerted, especially if the cell phone was small enough to carry around as opposed to being a bag phone.
- soupfordummies 3y ago>>If your work requires a phone or computer, they should be providing a dedicated device My old job offered a choice between work phone or $60/mo stipend (work laptop provided of course). My current job just assumes everyone use personal phone for free. Really not a fan of that policy for MANY reasons. I've also refused to join it to our domain as that ALLOWS REMOTE DEVICE WIPE OF MY PERSONAL PHONE. Amazes me that so many consent to that. However, in my current role, it's sort of a pick-your-battles thing right now.
- tonfreed 3y agoI claim part of my phone bill on tax because I have slack installed on it. It's a legitimate work expense here in Australia
- soupfordummies 3y agoYeah, I'm in US and I probably could also. I should look at that and I wonder if home internet is deductible for us with WFH.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoThat's what burner phones are for.
- soupfordummies 3y agoThat's a good idea, I do have a couple old Androids. I was using a google voice number for a while but that just got to be a hassle.
- hiatus 3y ago> Really not a fan of that policy for MANY reasons. I've also refused to join it to our domain as that ALLOWS REMOTE DEVICE WIPE OF MY PERSONAL PHONE. Amazes me that so many consent to that. What MDM are they using? AFAIK Android and Apple both offer work-profile functionality and the MDM solution could be limited to the work profile.
- swah 3y agoWhile I'll glance at my work Slack after hours, the feature to mute notifications until tomorrow also works fine... That said I'd agree with missing the feeling of being unreachable - it was a different feeling that you can't have anymore IMO. Its not the same as turning off your phone - people didn't expect or have a way to reach you. Just wait until you came back home. So if you mom was mad that you broke that window, you could effectively avoid the punishment for a few hours just by not showing up. (Of course, if you wait too much you could get the double punishment for this second offense)