3 ms·
I was pointing out that the case where the network produces exact copies of copyrighted code (or very very close to exact copies, such as changing a variable na
by tsimionescu 3y ago
I was pointing out that the case where the network produces exact copies of copyrighted code (or very very close to exact copies, such as changing a variable name or removing a comment) is clear, and requires no new litigation.
While I also think there is a good chance that what you are claiming (that any output is a derived work of the training set), this is definitely not settled, and will require someone going to court over it. I expect the proceedings over something like this to take a long time, and very likely reach to the supreme court. So, we won't know if you're right or not for quite a while.
A good argument against the idea that any output is a derived work of (all) data in the training set is exactly that verbatim copies of snippets from the Linux kernel can't be a derived work of snippets from GCC, even if GCC was also in the training set. So it is arguable that someone intending to claim copyright infringement for a piece of code generated by an LLM has to identify which particular work of theirs from the training set it infringes on, it can't be a blanket finding.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoWorse: The US Supreme Court will reach a verdict. The European equivalent will also reach a verdict, which may be different. And the Australians. And the British. And the Chinese. And... It won't be over when the first top-level court decides.
- JoshTriplett 3y agoHopefully it'll over when the first top-level court of any country too big to ignore says "no", at which point anyone trying to be safe will stop allowing LLM-generated code in their codebase.