4 ms·
Similar applies train - limits you to the network obviously, but crucially you don't need to pay attention during the commute. That moves potentially hours of
by Havoc 3y ago
Similar applies train - limits you to the network obviously, but crucially you don't need to pay attention during the commute.
That moves potentially hours of dead time interspersed with occasional looking away from lane to time you can actually use. Stare out window uninterupted or watch a movie on tablet or sleep or read or whatever.
Loads of excellent reasons for preferring a car (big family, limited rail net, equipment etc) but for solo experience it seems inferior to me
- naz 3y agoSure, you can optimize for different things. You could argue that the best way to travel alone is by private jet. You get there quickly and in luxury, with a birds-eye view, and have food and drinks served the whole way by your chef. It's all subjective.
- Nullabillity 3y agoNot being able to "use" the time is the point.
- systemtest 3y agoThe reason I love road-trips in foreign countries is being able to stop wherever I want, whenever I want. Talk to locals, visit small shops, visit a historical site, a museum. If I see a nice waterfall on my map I can just route my GPS to get there. With a train you have to plan ahead for this. Get out at the right station, figure out how the bus system works and how to get to your destination. And hoping that I can even get there, as an example many countries don't have functioning local public transit on a Sunday. Or because the closest bus stop to where you want to go is a couple kilometers out. It feels very restraining to me.
- Dalewyn 3y agoIt's essentially a trade off of responsibility and freedom. With public transport, you aren't responsible for the logistics of moving yourself. However, you also aren't free to move as you please. With private transport, you are responsible for the logistics of moving yourself. However, you also are free to move as you please.
- Lammy 3y agoMy favorite HN-friendly analogy: Public transport is circuit-switched like the Bell System (i.e. trains must physically "switch the road" to change track). Private transport is packet-switched like the Internet. Not a big truck, not a series of tubes, but a series of small trucks :)
- coldtea 3y agoOn the plus side, with trains, locals in the areas of between stops are spared of tourists!
- sidm83 3y agoCompletely agree, did it in a few countries and truly enjoyed the freedom of stopping anywhere I wanted, wherever I encountered beautiful surroundings, and staying as long as I wanted, not to forget enjoying the place on my own rather than among a busload of fellow travelers. Must say though that the Swiss certainly make this much easier to do with their excellent public transport and the Swiss Pass, which is your single ticket to go almost anywhere in the country including trains, buses, subway, boats and even cable cars! In the few cases its not included, you get a discounted rate. However parts of the country are so lovely that hiking through them is the only way to truly appreciate their beauty!
- SenHeng 3y agoThat's why I used to do when living in Tokyo. I would look on Google maps and find any interesting looking water feature (I like looking at large bodies of water) and then just drive in that general direction. Sometimes it ends up being a dud[0], and sometimes you find something amazingly beautiful [1][2][3][4] [0]: https://goo.gl/maps/FoE51Cc8KzJVCocn7 https://goo.gl/maps/FoE51Cc8KzJVCocn7 [1]: https://goo.gl/maps/z5CMS4NpTAukgNct9 https://goo.gl/maps/z5CMS4NpTAukgNct9 [2]: https://goo.gl/maps/ZEBCbw6d1h1YWFAYA https://goo.gl/maps/ZEBCbw6d1h1YWFAYA [3]: https://goo.gl/maps/A6ZHCT97z2kdrxas9 https://goo.gl/maps/A6ZHCT97z2kdrxas9 [4]: https://goo.gl/maps/SxLk2S4D1jFkDhU69 https://goo.gl/maps/SxLk2S4D1jFkDhU69
- samtho 3y agoFor me, traveling by train vs solo road trip are completely incomparable. I don’t feel as engaged on the train and much of my time is spent trying to pass by the time faster rather than just taking in the scenery. By contrast, driving solo by car is almost magical. You can go detour where you’d like, drive around to find the best vantage point, stop when and for how long you want. The engagement and focus I have when driving a car or piloting an airplane is totally different than being a passive participant in someone else’s adventure. I would say that taking a train, flying in as plane as a passenger, or any other form of mass transport is always going to be destination oriented, driving yourself lets you make it about the journey as much or as little as you want.
- 0_____0 3y agoYou should try bike touring if you can! If you love the immersion of driving, cycling, especially in wild environments, is 10x more intense in that regard. Every smell, the feeling of fog or drizzle or sun, the feel of the dirt or road under your wheels and feet, the wind on your face. It's trivial to stop and inspect things near you in a way that the momentum of a car prevents.
- samtho 3y agoThat is my goal as I return to better physical fitness! I live in a place with excellent bicycle infrastructure and I’m working on building my stamina again with shorter, 10-ish mile per day stints.
- CapricornNoble 3y ago>>crucially you don't need to pay attention during the commute 1. This isn't about "commuting". 2. I'd say "paying attention" is part of the point. I had a phenomenal experience driving more-or-less this route ( https://goo.gl/maps/iuYPD2oRLwdvZsS36 https://goo.gl/maps/iuYPD2oRLwdvZsS36 ) solo very early on a Monday morning while listening to the audio book of Cal Newport's Deep Work. It's a demanding drive if done even a little aggressively (narrow road and a TON of corners). In anything sporty it's an absolute blast, and a great way to enjoy some personal time with no human along to distract you.