3 ms·
> Someone who is running a leaderboard server is doing so on their computer and not yours. And yet they're enforcing little rules and policies on my machine. I
by matheusmoreira 3y ago
> Someone who is running a leaderboard server is doing so on their computer and not yours.
And yet they're enforcing little rules and policies on my machine. I'll let them have that freedom the day they give me SSH root access to their servers.
> That is not what remote attestation is about. Remote attestation lets the "corporation" ensure that a client using their servers is running the software that the corporation intends to have connect to the server.
Their "intent" doesn't matter. Their servers should accept accept any connection from any software that talks their network protocol. We should be able to run whatever software we want to interact with remote servers, including third party apps, not just the "intended" app. This is what adversarial interoperability is all about.
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/10/adversarial-interoperability https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/10/adversarial-interopera...
The network is the perfect boundary for this. If that results in some bot being able to cheat at games, doesn't matter. Small price to pay for freedom. The truth is people should not even be playing with untrusted internet randoms anyway. They should be playing with trusted friends who they know will play fairly.
> Allowing for modifications to remove "surveillance" also will allow mods that add backdoors for people to steal your credentials and make actions on your behalf.
No problem.
> This is complicated because bad actors can install malicious software if there is a way to change anything or bad actors can social engineer people into installing the malicious software.
No, it's extremely simple. I don't trade freedom for security, because that trade gets me neither. To make that trade you'd have to trust these trillion dollar corporations will act in your best interests and that's just idiotic. I hope I don't have to list the numerous ways that corporate surveillance capitalism harms people. What good is protection against "malicious software" when their apps are essentially spyware anyway?
If I have to risk dealing with malicious software in order to have control, so be it.
- charcircuit 3y ago>And yet they're enforcing little rules and policies on my machine. They aren't. You still have the freedom to modify rules and policies that are on your machine. >I'll let them have that freedom the day they give me SSH root access to their servers. So leaderboard servers should give everyone root access? That too will result in cheated times making it in. >Their servers should accept accept any connection from any software that talks their network protocol. Okay, but that has nothing to do with attestation. You can still write your own client to talk to the service. You just will not be able to attest that you are using an official client. It is up to the service to choose what to do with that information. >If that results in some bot being able to cheat at games, doesn't matter. Small price to pay for freedom. 99% of consumers do not care about having that much freedom and they do care about people cheating in the games they play. >The truth is people should not even be playing with untrusted internet randoms anyway. They should be playing with trusted friends who they know will play fairly. This doesn't scale. Also some people do not have friends to play with and would like a matchmaking system to find people to play with. >you'd have to trust these trillion dollar corporations will act in your best interests and that's just idiotic Then don't use their software. Most people prefer the trade off. >What good is protection against "malicious software" when their apps are essentially spyware anyway? Analytics and telemetry are not spyware. Understanding how user's are using your product is not spying.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> You still have the freedom to modify rules and policies that are on your machine. We don't. The OS is owned by Apple, they too use cryptography and remote attestation to not let us "tamper" with your app. > So leaderboard servers should give everyone root access? That too will result in cheated times making it in. Absurd, isn't it? That's what it feels like to have some corporation dictating what you can and can't do with your computer. > You just will not be able to attest that you are using an official client. It is up to the service to choose what to do with that information. As if services will ever use that information to do anything but screw us over by refusing to interoperate. They should not be able to tell at all that we aren't using an "official" client. > Then don't use their software. Most people prefer the trade off. Yeah sure. I'll just stop using my bank's software and lock myself out of my accounts and investments. I'll totally cut myself off from my entire social circle by refusing to use WhatsApp. > Analytics and telemetry are not spyware. Understanding how user's are using your product is not spying. Well I don't want them to "understand" anything about me. I don't consent to it. Since I can't trust corporations to respect consent, I will absolutely do everything in my power to ensure they can't track anything. I don't need remote attestation getting in the way.