3 ms·
mmmm not quite > SVB Cayman Islands … which had deposits from the bank’s clients in China, Singapore and other parts of Asia, including venture-capital and pri
by yieldcrv 3y ago
mmmm not quite
> SVB Cayman Islands … which had deposits from the bank’s clients in China, Singapore and other parts of Asia, including venture-capital and private-equity firms
A) non-Americans should never bank directly in the US given the option of the Cayman Islands because the US not a competitive jurisdiction in comparison to more competitive jurisdictions such as the Caymen Islands, its way more than just the tax rate. It requires complete indoctrination and hubris to assume the US is the most right and claims to the title to all capital. In this case, the US has onerous requirements levied on non-US persons in an effort to create a “tax person” that had no reason to be created, but its not about avoiding that status because there may be no tax event regardless, it’s about the mountain of paperwork. Its not based on an intention of Congress its just fallout from a nebulous regulatory environment.
B) The FDIC placed this subsidiary into receivership and made them unsecured creditors. In order to harbor your opinion, the FDIC most likely shouldnt have done that. It doesnt pay into FDIC insurance so FDIC shouldnt have taken it over. So its more like the US took funds it shouldnt have and the investors/depositors were correct to rely on the advances of the Cayman Islands but the US, once again due to nebulous regulatory quirks, chose to seize the parent organization and everything under it in a hurried mess, which maybe a more developed nation could do better.
C) The FDIC did pick winners in coordination with the Treasury and Federal Reserve, which undermines your stance on the people you denigrate under poor assumptions. There was actually no way to make everyone whole immediately, without the credit facility from the Federal Reserve to give a 100% LTV loan on treasuries, marked UP to a price nobody would pay on the market.
If any VC and PE funds were US based General Partners, then I would mostly agree with you, partially because even their offshore feeders can bank directly in the US. But the FDIC also probably should have just ignored that subsidiary either way, or not called them unsecured creditors.
- HWR_14 3y ago> A) non-Americans should never bank directly in the US given the option of the Cayman Islands because the US not a competitive jurisdiction It's pretty competitive when your couterparty goes bankrupt. If you opt out of US protections, congrats, you've opted out of US protections.
- yieldcrv 3y agoSo the FDIC shouldn’t have made it riskier than it was then They opted out of US protection and got US receivership of the worst kind