3 ms·
> I question how a public utility can be viable where a private one can't. In theory similar market forces should apply to both, and commodity prices should be
by lmm 3y ago
> I question how a public utility can be viable where a private one can't. In theory similar market forces should apply to both, and commodity prices should be close to the cost of production so the prices offered under competition should be close.
Natural monopoly means there is no (or at least insufficient) competition. So either you get accountability by having it be publicly-run, or you end up with very little accountability at all.
> Why can't we let private companies do whatever we were going to let the public one do?
Private companies are very good at coming up with things you never thought of in order to make a profit - that's the whole reason private industry can be more efficient than public ones in the first place. But when most of the creative things they could come up with would be profiting at the expense of the public (because in a monopoly position there's essentially no incentive to treat consumers well), the profit motive does more harm than good and it's better to take it out of the picture.
> Frankly rather than the hack of setting up a public utility I'd perfer straight up price controls, no reason to build out alternative infrastructure at taxpayer expense, but there might be a quicker fix with some modifications to a few regulations.
That's how you get loopholes that then get exploited worse than the problem you were originally trying to fix.