3 ms·
Legally, the distinction is totally arbitrary. None of this is being decided on any kind of broader principles, because you're exactly right -- there's zero goo
by crazygringo 3y ago
Legally, the distinction is totally arbitrary. None of this is being decided on any kind of broader principles, because you're exactly right -- there's zero good answer as to why iPhones should be forced to allow sideloading but not PS5's. In fact, I'd go so far as to say there's something quite unfair about it all, precisely because there's no consistent moral or legal principle whatsoever being applied here.
But in practice, it's simply because for whatever reason, restricting apps on a phone bothers people more than restricting games on a console. We live in democracies, and laws get passed because people want them, not because they're consistent or make sense. Maybe because people think of phones as deriving from computers and you can install whatever you want on a computer, while game consoles have been locked down since basically the beginning, so it's just a question of what people are used to.
People sometimes use the argument that game consoles are sold at a loss and therefore require being locked down, but that's irrelevant. In the same way Europe (and now Japan) are forcing Apple to change its business model, they could easily force Sony to change its business model as well, so it would be forced to sell consoles at full price.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoTo be fair, consoles could be forced to open app stores too. Console make money on the sdk, from my understanding. Opening app the store would not force them to give access to the sdk, isn't that the case?
- EMIRELADERO 3y agoThe EU's Digital Markets Act could, in theory, allow for consoles to be unlocked and used freely. There's nothing in the Act that specifically leaves them out (or puts smartphones in, for that matter). It's device-agnostic, the only thing that matters are the usage numbers.
- crazygringo 3y agoIt may be device-agnostic by the letter, but not in spirit -- it's widely understood that the usage numbers were specifically chosen as a mechanism to cover phones but not consoles. This happens regularly in laws and regulations, where you can't write a law singling out one or more companies by name, so certain thresholds are chosen to achieve the same end.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 3y agoNot long ago there was a clear distinction between general computing devices and specialized devices. These concepts still exist in our minds, but while it used to be binary, it's now a spectrum: servers and desktops are at one end, things like smartwatches and e-readers and the touchscreens in our cars are at the other end. Most people feel that video game consoles are clearly specialized devices even though they're quite computationally powerful. The question is where phones should fall on this spectrum. Steve Jobs strongly felt they should be treated as specialized devices, but as they're now powerful enough to be many people's primary device, attitudes are shifting toward treating them more like the laptops of yore.
- kyleee 3y agoWe’ll said. For me, if I am buying a $1,000 phone the default should be that there is a way to write native apps for it without requiring a dev account/fee and ways for other consenting users to get and install such software. The lion’s share of users are free to keep their devices locked down (and they may be well served to do so for their own safety). Comparison to a PS5 is deeply flawed as you noted