8 ms·
Working a 8/9-5/6 job is historically an aberration, and never in human history has the majority of workers been employed that way. Even now, as (a small minori
by scarmig 15y ago
Working a 8/9-5/6 job is historically an aberration, and never in human history has the majority of workers been employed that way. Even now, as (a small minority of) people in the Global South are moving to that kind of labor, we see that very same system breaking down in the West. People usually work piecemeal and irregular hours, in exchange for locally-valid credit.
It's a pipe dream to believe that the height of human happiness and social justice is everyone sitting down at a 9-5 job five days a week so you can pay down the mortgage on housing you overpaid for because everyone else also bought into the same myth. Which is what mainstream political parties in all countries that I know of seem to buy into, just with variations on the theme.
I like Chesterton's vision and see it as more emancipatory than the industrial-corporate socialism/capitalism that we have, despite me being a left wing crazy.
Will have to check out Belloc.
- tjr 15y agoMy grandfather worked in carpentry and construction, ultimately working his way up to overseeing construction of bridges. There was a time when you could hardly drive anywhere in St. Louis without crossing over a bridge that he worked on. And doing construction work, he paid for his family's house over the course of about five years. It wasn't a palace, but it was a nice house in a (then) nice neighborhood with a good-sized lawn. Today, people routinely spend twenty or thirty years to buy a decent house. Even dumpy houses in poor locations would likely take well over five years for many people to pay for. Something seems very wrong.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ars 15y agoIt's because we are building so many other things. The price of a house depends on how many people there are to build it (like your grandfather). These days people build all sorts of other things, so the price of a house goes up. But on the other hand you now have so many other cool things that weren't available back then.
- jpdoctor 15y ago> Working a 8/9-5/6 job is historically an aberration Very much so. It used to be from dawn until dusk. When hours were first instituted, it was always compared to farm work, since that was understood to be the hardest work possible. EDIT: I see there's a lot of academicians with opinions. Anyone here grow up on a farm? Would you like to tell us about how easy the work is?
- _delirium 15y agoThere's considerable variation in estimates, but most historians don't consider dawn-to-dusk to have been typical agrarian working hours, apart from peak weeks at planting and harvest. Data is really spotty, though, and before formalized hourly employment, it's not even really clear that people distinguished systematically between "working hours" and "leisure hours", so reconstructing it is difficult. To take one minor example, is "knitting by the fire while chatting with a neighbor" 100% work, 50% work, or something else? Perhaps it depends on whether it was a relaxed, half-working, half-chatting sort of knitting, or more industrious, but can we plausibly estimate how much of each was done in the 19th century? Even the distribution of how much of their day people typically took off for meals isn't well established (though it probably also varied by season).
- scarmig 15y agoWork wasn't considered something apart from social life. Basically, if something needed to be done, you did it. Things weren't nearly as compartmentalized as they are now. Agricultural lifestyles mean that life and work are much more integrated than they are now, because they had to be. Which has pros and cons: people lived much more on the brink of survival, but a local area was also more self-sufficient. The trade we've made is to take risk of dying from starvation during a bad year where we are not self-sufficient enough for risks related to specialization, meaning we now have the equally uncontrollable risk of being screwed by a NYC financier or a DC bureaucrat. It's also important to distinguish between different cultures and different time periods. A peasant in 15th century England lived a very different lifestyle than a peasant in 2nd century China. Edited to clarify.