3 ms·
Nuts Don’t Have as Many Calories as You Thought
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> The less the nut is processed the greater the difference in calories: roasting makes nuts more brittle and slightly easier to digest > Even between people there is a little bit of variation in calories extracted, probably due to chewing differences. > the FDA allows companies to choose between approved methods, including Atwater’s and the newer one. I hope companies are honest about what they are factoring into these calculations.
- potamic 3y ago> “Until we break open that cell wall the things inside the cell aren’t available for digestion,” Why do nuts give off a smell then? If everything is contained within cell walls, the aromatic compounds should not escape?
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoIt doesn't say that everything is contained within the cell walls. Even if they are, a fraction of cell walls will be broken up through chewing and the digestive process. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7015882/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7015882/ > The bioaccessibility of fat has implications for satiety and postprandial lipidaemia. The prevailing view holds that the integrity of plant cell wall structure is the primary determinant of energy and nutrient extraction from plant cells as they pass through the gastrointestinal (GI) tract. However, comparisons across nuts (walnuts, almonds and pistachios) with varying physical properties do not support this view. In the present study, masticated samples of three nuts from healthy adults were exposed to a static model of gastric digestion followed by simulated intestinal digestion. Primary outcomes were particle size and lipid release at each phase of digestion. Walnuts produced a significantly larger particle size post-mastication compared with almonds. Under gastric and intestinal conditions, the particle size was larger for walnuts compared with pistachios and almonds (P < 0·05). However, the masticated and digesta particle sizes were not related to the integrity of cell walls or lipid release. The total lipid release was comparable between nuts after the in vitro intestinal phase (P > 0·05). Microstructural examination showed ruptured and fissured cell walls that would allow digestion of cellular contents, and this may be governed by internal cellular properties such as oil body state. Furthermore, the cell walls of walnuts tend to rupture rather than separate and as walnut tissue passes through the GI tract, lipids tend to coalesce reducing digestion efficiency.
- YellOh 3y agoThis is disappointing. So nuts are actually lower calorie per dollar than it seemed, so a worse deal than previously expected (for those food shopping on a budget). A 21% drop in the expected calories from walnuts will definitely have me buying fewer in the future.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoGrind them up and it's the same calorie content.
- YellOh 3y agoI don't really want to pull out a blender just for a quick snack. Maybe I'll try out nut butters besides peanut butter to see if pre-processed tastes as good as whole. ETA: since roasted nuts are easier to digest, maybe the smart move is bulk-roasting in advance.
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> I don't really want to pull out a blender just for a quick snack. You can batch it. Given the high oil content they will probably stay as well as peanut butter does, and if stored in the refrigerator shouldn't separate.
- prirun 3y agoYou can also use nut flour. I put a heaping tablespoon in oatmeal and protein shakes for an extra 100 calories, and it tastes good too.
- josephcsible 3y agoCalories per dollar seems like a really strange metric to use/care about. Cheaper is better, and lower-calorie is better, but those cancel each other out under it.
- 3y ago
- maerF0x0 3y agoThis is going to mislead many folks. Unless nuts are one of your favorite foods, they're not a "health" food by any means. They're far too calorie dense, even after this recalculation to make sense in a diet. Which means most of the population is well advised to steer clear of them (and other worse foods) in favor of high volume, higher protein foods, and higher fiber foods (all measured in a denominator of _per calorie_). Sure if you love peanut butter and you want to fit it in to your calorie budget, and have the self control to not binge it, and are happy with the volume of food you get on a caloric deficit or maintenance, by all means. But for most (about 75%) of us we should be focusing on the food choices that make a deficit come naturally, because most of us have a few (or more) pounds to lose. Now I'm sure some nay sayer will come back and be like "It's better than pizza, fries, and (american) chips" ... yeah thats true, but we shouldn't fool people into thinking they're making a choice they can live on long term with nuts.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwaway22032 3y agoIn my world, most people who eat nuts do so because they're intentionally trying to eat more calories. They're tiny, it's easy to carry a few hundred grams of cashews on the trail. I don't know of anyone who sees them as being a good food on a cut, they have a high ratio of fat to protein.
- maerF0x0 3y agoSuper agree they have no place on a cut. And 75% of us being overweight means 75% of us should be on a mild cut (or moderate, or severe[1] as is the case). But in many under food-educated circles "Nuts" are associated with "hiking" or "trail mix" and seen as a way to participate in "healthy lifestyle". Tiny people trying to gain (presumably lean) weight is a super small slice of the population, if I had to wager a guess, less than 1%. (just like I recently helped a friend understand that drinking full sugar gatorade was not good for her, she felt like she was participating in "athletic lifestyle" and would receive some benefits from it... nutritionally it's practically identical to drinking a cola) [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angus_Barbieri%27s_fast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angus_Barbieri%27s_fast
- JoeAltmaier 3y ago10% less
- prirun 3y agoTree nuts (not peanuts, which are legumes) are really great for diabetic snacks, though you have to have some control and not eat half a bag.
- sacnoradhq 3y agoPeanut butter is still fattening as fuck and it's omega-6 to -3 ratio approaches 2000, if not more due to processing. Almonds take a great deal of water to grow, are a leading cause of broken teeth, and have an omega ratio 200+. Brazil nuts are also close in hardness and omega 6. Pine nuts are also extremely calorie dense and not particularly healthy; walnut pesto is great btw. Walnuts OTOH have a ratio closer to 4. Pistachios, walnuts, cashews, pecans, and macadamia nuts are healthy in moderation. Walnuts and cashews must never be eaten raw. The outer coating of the cashew apple is also haptenic.