4 ms·
What is the practical effect on the user of an instance being "defederated?" People compare these federated social platforms to email, as there are many email
by SoftTalker 3y ago
What is the practical effect on the user of an instance being "defederated?"
People compare these federated social platforms to email, as there are many email providers and they can all exchange mail with each other. But there's no concept of being "defederated" in email. Or is there? I just don't understand the term.
- 0xffff2 3y agoThere is, it's just not talked about much. It is incredibly hard to run your own email server today because even if you follow all of the rules the big players will often refuse to accept your emails (i.e. defederate your email server).
- School-Cotton 3y agoThat’s a very persistent myth. I run my own email server and my mail gets delivered fine. There are a few things you need to do, yes, but it’s not “incredibly hard”.
- josephcsible 3y agoIt's not that doing the list of things is hard. It's that even if you do everything correctly, sometimes your mail will get dropped anyway for no explicable reason.
- jefftk 3y agoDefederation in email would be a.example putting in a block where you can't receive email from users on b.example. With email this pretty much only happens because of spamming, so it would be very surprising for, say, Hotmail to block Gmail.
- hombre_fatal 3y agoWhat I don't get is that this seems like something you would want to do for yourself as a user, not something you'd want your instance/server admin doing due to whatever drama of the week is going on.
- zimpenfish 3y ago> What I don't get is that this seems like something you would want to do for yourself as a user Speaking as an admin, if a server starts sending me hundreds of spams an hour, it's going to get blocked because I don't want to spend (my limited) resources on spams, much less push the handling of that down to my users.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y ago> What is the practical effect on the user of an instance being "defederated?" The entire instance is sort of "shadow banned". Everyone on it can post, but no one will ever read it (except for the few dozen people on that instance). Since forums have some minimum number of users/readers that if the number falls below this people just give up and go away, it will be dead within a month. Not only is it like being shadow-banned, but you get to be shadow-banned for what the other people on the instance are posting. The Fediverse might be a good model for a Twitter-alike (it's debatable), but I don't think it's a good model at all for a reddit-alike. Conversations aren't meant to always be civil. If you enforce that harshly, it turns into a place to post cat pictures.
- SoftTalker 3y agoSo the likely fallout of that would seem to me be that if a "federated Reddit" ever got off the ground: - Over time, a few instances will grow to dominate and nobody will defederate them because they are too big and you'd lose too much/make too many people mad. These will be the Gmail, iCloud, Hotmail, etc. instances. - As they become larger, instances will be motivated to follow established politics of the big instances so they don't get cut off. - Small instances will exist as echo chambers for certain unpopular points of view and mostly none of the big instances will federate them. Porn, Nazis, KKK, Anarchists, religious extremists, etc. - Possible large bifurcations may develop, e.g. "Fox News/Breitbart" vs. "CNN/Huffington"; each has large followings but they would probably not federate each other. - New users who just want a place to do normal Reddit-like stuff will be confused by all of this.
- Vvector 3y agoDefederation would be like if GMail stopped working with Outlook.com. Millions of users with no way to contact each other.
- josephcsible 3y agoThe email equivalent of being "defederated" would be if Microsoft and Google both decided to start dropping all mail from your domain sent to any mailboxes they run.