5 ms·
Reforming the free software message
- mistercheph 3y agoA centrist corporate-friendly reform that no one asked for to one of the last principled institutions in an industry incapable of reflecting on how much it has become the most hideous monster in the world.
- ebiester 3y agoI think it's worth actually looking at the link. The four freedoms and copyleft are explicitly in there and the copyleft licenses are at the top. He's arguing that the messaging is messy, not the message.
- lucasgonze 3y agoThis is a valuable project, executed well. A suggested edit: the term "copyleft" at https://writefreesoftware.org/learn/licenses https://writefreesoftware.org/learn/licenses is confusing and is falling into disuse. "Reciprocal licensing" is easier to understand and is growing. Does Drew Devault have a HN handle we can @?
- ddevault 3y agoNot sure that "copyleft" is confusing or falling into disuse, I hear people talking about it without confusion pretty often. First time I've heard "reciprocal licensing".
- gravypod 3y agoI think "copyleft" is ubiquitous within the tech crowd but the first time I heard the term I was confused. Might be worth asking a few people you know in the real world who are not tech people to see if they knew what either means.
- lucasgonze 3y agoThe only people who know the term "copyleft" are already familiar with GNU, the FSF, and the free software movement. That is a tiny pool.
- occamrazor 3y ago“Reciprocal licensing” is not precise. I think ShareAlike is more descriptive (and consistent with CC licenses).
- lucasgonze 3y agoShareAlike is also effective. What we know for sure is that Copyleft is never going to work.
- suby 3y agoDoes @ on HN actually work though? I didn't think that was a thing here.
- msla 3y agoNo.
- rekado 3y agoThere is also a reformed project for a subset of the GNU project: https://gnu.tools/ https://gnu.tools/ A good match, perhaps.
- okwhateverdude 3y agoIANAL, etc. The Copyleft (both the short blurb and the longer detailed) explanation needs to make more explicit about the "distribution" aspect. GPL-v2/v3's copyleft requirement in particular only apply if you distribute the software. If you make changes/incorporate GPL-v2/v3 code but then never distribute that software, you are under no obligation to make those changes or the total incorporated project available. This is exactly why the Affero GPL came about, to close this "loophole", especially for network services (famous case is Amazon building a managed elasticsearch service).
- steviedotboston 3y agoMany of the points in your original post follow from your first point (Reform the leadership, remove RMS) So much of the FSF's myopic vision and ineffectiveness that you accurately point out stem directly from RMS playing a leading role in the FSF. Why does the FSF spend so much time browbeating people for saying "Linux" instead of "GNU/Linux"? That's entirely because 30 years ago RMS's ego wouldn't let him admit that something he had no part of was becoming popular so he had to make sure he got credit for it. Why does the FSF spend so much energy insisting on stuff like free BIOS? Because RMS thinks anything other than a 100% free ecosystem is unacceptable, so significant resources must be invested into endeavors like that. Enjoy your 12 year old ThinkPad with external Wifi dongle! If you remove RMS and his cronies, theres a chance the organization could reform into something with reasonable goals. But until then it's just going to be a vehicle for his personal bugbears, which as time goes on become increasingly out of touch with reality.
- gumby 3y ago> That's entirely because 30 years ago RMS's ego wouldn't let him admit that something he had no part of was becoming popular Just a reminder that Linus was inspired by the existence of Minix and by the GPL. So RMS had an important influence on Linux's success. "Influence" =/= "role", but is generally (and in this case) a "part". None of this justifies the dogged pursuit of the "GNU/Linux" nonsense , but I do think this is an important clarification. BTW apart from RMS himself I've never heard a single person refer to "GNU/Linux" except in a joking fashion, and I hang out with a bunch of people you'd think would, if anyone took it seriously.
- steviedotboston 3y agoI just meant that RMS was not a code contributor to Linux, and that his primary motivation for insisting on "GNU/Linux" was ego and jealousy. Some people do call it GNU/Linux officially, such as the Debian Project, but casually yeah it's not really used so much because its weird and awkward to say. 99% of the world just calls it Linux and that's fine.
- 3y ago
- runningmike 3y agoGreat example of do not complain, but just do it better. Really like this! Of course made possible with Foss and cc-by-sa work. Quote heard from stalman ‘we should have called it freedom software instead of open source software’
- mistrial9 3y agofully agree there is work to do -- I believe that the word "FREE" is problematic in English, and is destructive to the ends espoused thereby.. There is no perfect fit, but "Libre" causes the English-reader to pause, while removing very loaded language available to critics. Secondly, there is no secret that some cloud-environments are teaching paying customers that "GPL does not apply here"
- star-glider 3y agoThis is another huge problem with RMS: the nitpicky obsession with language. Although, in fairness, this seems to be an issue with a lot of technically-minded people. Words are not like code; a word can be imperfect but work well enough in context. Code isn't like this, of course. Even if it's obvious from context that you're writing a conditional, using "=" instead of "==" won't work. But language isn't like that; "close enough" can be just fine, and over time, meanings can evolve. "Open-source" is a term that a lot of people know and use. It's fine. It's not perfect, and its meaning does not perfectly encompass everything that FSF stands for. Who cares. It's good enough. These arcane, pedantic debates about "libre" (not an English word) versus "FOSS" (an acronym that must be learned) versus "free" (a word with a confusing valence of connotative meanings) are off-putting and distracting. A lot of activists get distracted by this kind of nerd-bait. Somehow, smart people get convinced that if only we can get people using the right words "I call them used not users" then we'll win the argument via some linguistic cheat code or something. It just doesn't work like that. Here's a good discussion of how climate activists can't get out of their own way on natural gas terminology and some evidence for why the entire debate is pointless: https://strongmessagehere.substack.com/p/words-arent-magic https://strongmessagehere.substack.com/p/words-arent-magic
- mistrial9 3y agoI get what you are saying, but .. this is not "nerd bait" I really mean it.. what is your suggestion then?
- star-glider 3y ago