2 ms·
No, I'm not taking a stance on drugs. I'm not saying him losing $18k as a fine would be a problem. I'm saying that the police requisitioning his $18k and that
by lolinder 3y ago
No, I'm not taking a stance on drugs. I'm not saying him losing $18k as a fine would be a problem.
I'm saying that the police requisitioning his $18k and that money going towards the department budget creates perverse incentives for the police. If that money went to funding schools the problem would be much less severe. But when the head of the police department gets CAF money added to the top line of his budget, it will shape the way he directs his force, and the incentives it gives him are wrong.
- tptacek 3y ago(a) The money does go to funding schools (roughly half of it). (b) I still don't understand the conflict you're talking about. In your hypothetical, this money is exactly what civil asset forfeiture was designed to capture: the proceeds and instrumentalities of a crime. If you want to argue that he wasn't guilty of any crime, and therefore the money should have been returned, that makes perfect sense! But the hypo you've provided here doesn't make sense.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> this money is exactly what civil asset forfeiture was designed to capture: the proceeds and instrumentalities of a crime. No, you've confused criminal asset forfeiture (which exists for that purpose, and hinges on an actual conviction of an actual crime) with civil asset forfeiture (a product of admiralty law meant, in theory to make ship owners exert tighter control of their crews without extending criminal liability to them for the crews crimes, by making ships themselves forfeit for those crimes even though crews weren’t owners, that mostly hung around as a disused appendage in American law until it got seized on as an end run around criminal process in Prohibition, and later exploded in the War on Drugs.)