3 ms·
First the Ouya, which turned out to be a total flop, and then the Wii U, which Nintendo marketed so badly many people thought it was an extension for their Wii.
by jeroenhd 3y ago
First the Ouya, which turned out to be a total flop, and then the Wii U, which Nintendo marketed so badly many people thought it was an extension for their Wii. This company sure made some unlucky bets!
Throughout the article I kept coming back to how generic the name sounds. It conjured pictures if the digital slot machines that are free mobile games, with gameplay loops mostly consisting of waiting or paying money to skip wait timers. The name "Toto" being associated with gambling sure doesn't help either. I would've never clicked a link with that name no matter how good you make your game look.
A lot of genuine effort and care went into this but with an uninviting name and, by their own admission, a complicated control screen, no amount of art or advertising would've convinced me as a consumer to buy it.
This would've been a smash hit on a flash games site, and it would've probably sold well if Ouya had succeeded.
One thing I find interesting is that online multi-player wasn't added as a feature during development. I understand how overworked the lone dev must've been, but adding an easy way to play with friends would've surely boosted sales.
I also wonder if the game would've gotten more sales on a handheld. I think the 3DS might've made this a great little party game, especially if you follow the "stream a limited version of the game to your friends" model that made DS local multi-player so interesting. Now, with the Switch out, with its built-in local multi-player features, the game might've gotten a popularity boost as well.
It's sad to see a game made with so much love fail, but with problems in do many key areas I'm surprised it took them this long to admit defeat.
- ido 3y agoWe kept improving the game afterwards and released the final version of Toto Temple Deluxe on PS4, Xbox One, Wii U and Steam on September 29th 2015. They've released on all the at-the-time mainstream platforms, I don't think the choice of consoles is what I'd blame anything on.
- dehrmann 3y ago> Wii U, which Nintendo marketed so badly many people thought it was an extension for their Wii I can't decide if that's better or worse than Xbox. Xbox One isn't the original Xbox? And do I want Series S or X?
- zirgs 3y agoMicrosoft decided to name their consoles that way, because they didn't want their console to be one number behind the PlayStation.
- fomine3 3y agoThey solved it on 360. Its successor should be 361.
- happymellon 3y agoXBox 365.
- chihuahua 3y agoXbox N Enterprise Edition
- sbm_au 3y agoThey could have used increasing rotational degrees - Xbox 360, 540, 720, 900 and so on. Just like action sports, very extreme.
- falcor84 3y agoOf course, and then, when they're ready to go all-in, they'll backfill Xbox 180 /s
- ginko 3y agoThey also could have gone with Super Xbox or Xbox⁶⁴.
- alpaca128 3y agoSo instead they chose three numbers behind the PlayStation, and 359 numbers behind its predecessor? Not sure I follow that reasoning. Not to mention they could just jump to the same number as PlayStation used, just like MS also skipped Windows 9. That said all the jokes at the time likely helped make it clear to everyone that the Xbox One was the new model. And Series S/X is just two letters, nobody seems too confused by that.
- magic_hamster 3y ago> I understand how overworked the lone dev must've been Not sure that you do, especially when offering "just add multiplayer". Clear sign that you are not a solo game developer.
- coder_san 3y agoI agree. Anyone developer who has had to work on multi-player games will never say "just add multi-player". The whole way you approach the game changes massively.
- ilyt 3y agoIt was a massive mistake in game like this tho, the mistake many other games like that died by. Appeal of buying essentially party game where you need other people in same room to get the most of it (games like that are rarely good singleplayer) is very low, even worse in pandemic. Not saying it would make game succeed, as that's still 90% marketing in oversaturated indie market, but it is a thing that would make me go "nope" if I saw what I like then read that it is local-only, hell, it did in many cases.
- raincole 3y agoI'm still quite surprised by the fact that Overcooked succeeded without an online multiplayer mode. *I don't know how successful Overcooked was, but it was successful enough for them to make Overcooked 2
- Shaanie 3y agoI think overcooked has a quite different audience, being cooperative rather than competitive. I won't buy a competitive local multiplayer game nowadays, whereas I've bought a lot of cooperative ones to play with my SO, and that's probably fairly common?
- jeroenhd 3y agoOf course online multi-player is difficult to pull off but with console sale numbers for the Wii U I think the time spent on porting the game to the Wii U could've been used to get online multi-player to work. They spent an estimated 50% of their two years development time on a console that was pretty much a failure at the time the game came out. The PS4 was well ahead of any other console in sales long before the game was released onto the Wii U. I don't know their exact sales distribution, but I think a better game on PS4 and maybe Xbox One would've sold a lot more copies.
- mike_hock 3y ago> Wii U Wii U Wii U Wii U DAE this sounds like somebody mocking a siren?
- wodenokoto 3y ago> First the Ouya, which turned out to be a total flop, They still paid for the initial development, so it is hard to argue that was a bad place to start.
- jeroenhd 3y agoIt's a good deal for sure, but it didn't do the creative work that is the game any favors. It basically killed off the exclusivity deal that indie studios can often get for on-platform advertising.
- koromak 3y agoThey only have a single programmer...