3 ms·
They keep bringing up the point that for an E2E encrypted app to be secure the client and network must be fully independent from each other, but I am not able t
by paxys 3y ago
They keep bringing up the point that for an E2E encrypted app to be secure the client and network must be fully independent from each other, but I am not able to understand why. If I trust Signal the client, why does it matter what backend it is talking to? Being able to communicate over an untrustworthy network is in fact a core selling point of such apps. So why does it matter that Signal runs both?
- dijit 3y agoBecause functionally it's not any different than just trusting the network. If telegram says "trust me, we can't read anything" and signal says the same: the only way you know it to be true is if they have never given you any software that has access to the unencrypted content. OR you only use another network to communicate (and, obviously, you ensure that your clients aren't sending any messages out to anywhere that's not that network). If you play around with the EFF's lovely Tor diagram you can get an idea of what I mean: https://www.eff.org/pages/tor-and-https https://www.eff.org/pages/tor-and-https