4 ms·
I was struck by how many boats were found at the bottom of the black sea. It's deep: 2000m deep at some point(s). Deep, cold, de-oxygenated water. It preserves
by ggm 3y ago
I was struck by how many boats were found at the bottom of the black sea. It's deep: 2000m deep at some point(s).
Deep, cold, de-oxygenated water. It preserves some things.
Its northern shores also represent the limit of the Roman Empire, so are the marginal space where trading with other cultures probably happened. Since so much of history is related to trade, the amount of pre-, Roman and post-Roman stuff down there is fascinating, and informative. Boats are wonderful for shipping goods which are too bulky or heavy to fit on pack horses (or camels) -And economically sailing is probably the way to get goods to and from buyer and seller. Not that the silk road didn't work, but if you could stop having to hassle with recalcitrant camels and move to a boat, you could ship goods to Byzantium and it's successor states on the shores of the Black sea very easily.
I wonder how many pre-coal wrecks on the atlantic run are now covered in the trail of ash out of the coal era boats plying the same trade.
- npunt 3y agoMakes me wonder if there may be newer shipwrecks atop older shipwrecks, and we may miss these older interesting finds because the newer ships atop them are considered not worth exploring. Extremely unlikely in the vast ocean but I imagine some very high-traffic areas like near black sea ports or common areas like rock formations this may have happened with some regularity.
- ponector 3y agoThere are almost every year accidents with small old bulker ships (dead weight of 3000-5000 tons) in Black sea. I'm sure their remains stay at the bottom for future generations
- Etrnl_President 3y agohttps://www.imcbrokers.com/marine-salvage-companies-around-the-world/ https://www.imcbrokers.com/marine-salvage-companies-around-t...
- biztos 3y agoA list of salvage companies from Jan 2009, and it’s a shorter list than I would have expected, from a brokerage company that clearly doesn’t care much about the list, and it’s relevant because…?
- prawn 3y agoOr because they don't want to disturb the newer ships too much when exploring them and never realise there's something even better underneath.
- yakshaving_jgt 3y agoThere is now rather a lot of detritus on the floor (and surface) of the Black Sea thanks to russian terrorism.
- mschuster91 3y agoThe Black Sea is giant. A couple dozen ships [1] don't really matter pollution-wise. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ship_losses_during_the_Russo-Ukrainian_War#2022_Russian_invasion_of_Ukraine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ship_losses_during_the...
- Denvercoder9 3y agoI think GP is refering to everything swept away in the wake of the Kakhovka dam collapse.
- jmyeet 3y agoWe generally have a lot of misconceptions about how extensive trade was in the ancient world. As time goes on we learn it started earlier than we thought and was way more extensive. Consider the Uluburun wreck [1]. This dates from over 3000 years ago and nearly 1000 years earlier than the rise of the Roman Republic. Goods on this ship come from like 7 different places. One of them, lapis lazuli, had one (known) source in the ancient world: what is now modern day Afghanistan. We in the West often have this view that Rome was really the start of civilization in many ways. You specifically mention the borders of Rome as a factor. Large empires had risen, lasted centuries and fallen long before Rome existed. The founding of Rome is closer to our time than to the kingdoms and empires of the Tigris-Euphrates region (eg Sumeria, Mesopotamia). The Hittites of Anatolia had extensive writing, libraries and trade. Thanks to the fires in Hattusa firing the clay tablets, we have personal correspondence between the king and the Egyptian pharoah (Ramses II IIRC). Going even further back and we have evidence of trade 10,000 years earlier (eg obsidian from Turkey popped up all over the place and wheat products were traded in Britain 2,000 years before they farmed it [2]). Fast forward to the Roman era, and the Republic then Empire and ancient China were known to each other [3] although there's no evidence of direct contact or trade. [1]: https://www.worldhistory.org/Uluburun_Shipwreck/ https://www.worldhistory.org/Uluburun_Shipwreck/ [2]: https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/02/27/388822209/stone-age-britons-were-eating-wheat-2-000-years-before-they-farmed-it https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/02/27/388822209/st... [3]: https://www.thecollector.com/rome-and-china/ https://www.thecollector.com/rome-and-china/
- golergka 3y ago> We in the West often have this view that Rome was really the start of civilization in many ways. I find this opinion surprising. Do you think people genuinely not know about Bronze age civilisations? Do they not know about pyramids, which were just as ancient to Caesar as he is to us?
- ggm 3y agoI used Rome as a focal point. Most Archeology european english speaking people will encounter outside of the long barrows and dolmen of Western Europe is immediate pre-Roman, Roman, or post Roman. Sure, we have long barrows and other pre-roman "stuff" but the vast bulk of excavations now in the UK (for instance) tends to be roman or post-roman, along the route of the HS2 and similar city bound brownfield site development. I would be surprised if the digs in mainstream Europe routinely turn up a lot of earlier culture: I would expect the opportunistic emergency archeology associated with building and civil engineering is the predominant source of finds, and they tend to be .. well .. roman or post roman. But your point is well made. History of trade didn't start with Roman conquests or failures, and people sailed the Black sea long long before the Romans got there. Sure: Euro-centric, western culture centric PoV. I wrote from personal interest. I am sure there is a a shitload of great non-roman Archeology going on outside of the places I know. I bet Neanderthal and Denosivan's traded. It's natural for humans to swap what they have for what they want.