3 ms·
I'm very pro-WFH, but I don't understand/agree with a lot of the dialogue in support of WFH, including much of this article. For example, some software develop
by neilv 3y ago
I'm very pro-WFH, but I don't understand/agree with a lot of the dialogue in support of WFH, including much of this article.
For example, some software developers in these discussions will say things like "What do you care, if I only work 1 hour a day, so long as I get my work done?!?!?! :emoji: :emoji:"
My answer is not "There should be butts-in-seats for 40 hours a week, because that's what we pay you for!!! :emoji: :emoji:"
My answer is that (for the kind of things I'd like to be working on) the kind of work we do requires creativity, thinking holistically, diligence, effort, perseverance, team focus, etc.
It's not hitting metrics of number of sprint tasks you can plausibly claim you completed satisfactorily. The hiring and compensation should be guided by the idea that people are neither fungible commodities nor simple automatons. We're looking for a large chunk of some of this particular person's best work, while they're also having a non-work life.
If they're outsourcing their work, phoning it in, thrashing their mental swap space with their side gig, taking on a second job that leaves them fatigued, etc.... the team isn't getting much of their best work.
We will be flexible and supportive when life takes more time&energy than usual, as it sometimes will, for anyone. And there's daily ebb&flow for how available a person's best work can be.
But something like a second "full-time" job is harder to accept.
Also hard to accept is someone who treats software engineering like a factory job, thinking all that matters is the metric for how many fungible widgets they assemble over the course of a week. In software, that usually means: piles of half-butted unthinking new tech debt liability grunted out.
Also hard to accept is this article attempting to deconstruct and critique societal structures, with the author's particular perspective and theories... when it's unclear how that informs an organization where people just want to do great work as a team, benefit financially from that, and have lives besides.
Want to end WFH? Don a revolutionary beret, and gift-wrap a bunch strawperson-argument blog posts that help discredit WFH in the minds of some of those you most need to persuade.
Please, for the sake of WFH, don't make ostensibly pro-WFH arguments that go full anti-corporate in ten different ways.
- 8note 3y ago> the kind of work we do requires creativity, thinking holistically But those are also good with WFH? I get the one task point done, then I can go for a walk in the park where I can keep thinking about the problem, then go grab a coffee or a beer and write down a bit of thoughts on the topic. People are perfectly capable of phoning it in from the office, and taking a second job that's at night. Working from home or from office are orthogonal to how much attention somebody is paying, except that WFH has a major advantage: you and your coworkers don't arrive irritated and fatigued after 2 hour commutes through traffic, and then not getting as much time to maintain their life because it's another irritating and fatiguing commute back after work
- neilv 3y agoThat's my answer to the argument of "What do you care, if I only work 1 hour a day, so long as I get my work done?!?!?! :emoji: :emoji:". Which is a stereotypical argument made by some fringe who are ostensibly pro-WFH and responding to an argument of (also not the best idea) "How do I know you're working the full 8 hours?" So this is an example of discussions getting derailed by a lot of arguments that ideally we'd already be past. But we keep churning them out, in self-sabotaging ways. (Or, maybe not self-sabotaging, if the writer's goal is actually engagement or thought-leader self-promotion. Or if we've sunken so far on the WFH question that we're starting to get dialogue sabotage intentionally, like we do on some topics involving political power or big money.)
- xg15 3y ago> thrashing their mental swap space with their side gig Sorry to tell you, but people will trash their mental swap space with all kinds of non-work things, whether they are in the office or not. That kind of demand fits the "bosses want to own your soul" hypothesis from the OP pretty well.