3 ms·
Define 'failed'. If the expectation was that Twitter would uproot, en masse, and move to Mastodon, well, yes, that 'failed', but I'm not sure anyone really expe
by rsynnott 3y ago
Define 'failed'. If the expectation was that Twitter would uproot, en masse, and move to Mastodon, well, yes, that 'failed', but I'm not sure anyone really expected that to happen? That is _not_ typically how social networks die; when Livejournal kicked the bucket, say, some people who really liked Livejournal's mechanics moved to Dreamwidth or similar, but the vast majority just drifted slowly to other social networks with quite different mechanics. Mastodon (and that Jack Dorsey thing, and the others) are basically Dreamwidth here, I think; they'll be of interest for people who specifically liked Twitter because of its mechanics, but less so to others, who are more likely to go to Instagram or TikTok or Facebook or something completely new as Twitter falls apart.
From the point of view of someone who migrated to Mastodon, it certainly hasn't failed; if anything, it's quite refreshing, and reminds me of Twitter in the old days. It's an improvement on pre-2022 Twitter, and certainly a massive improvement on Naughty Old Mr Car Twitter. But I really enjoyed Twitter circa 2010; I am very much the target market.
I do wonder are people over indexing the death of Digg. In that case, people really did move, really rapidly, to Reddit. Reddit probably absorbed _most_ of Digg's user base. But that was a really unusual, possibly unique social media death, with significant special circumstances. We should probably be looking more towards Livejournal, MySpace, Bebo, that lot.
- _hypx 3y agoDigg was already losing a lot of marketshare before the v4 rollout. The v4 rollout was the nail in the coffin. Also, it still took about a year before Reddit finally surpassed Digg in terms of total users after that. But engagement and depth of user activity plunged immediately, something that is happening to Twitter now. Also Reddit right now too, which is having its own Digg v4 type of event. Both Twitter and Reddit are on the short path to irrelevancy, and their numbers are only held up by "late quitters." Probably more so in the case of Twitter, which is likely in a later stage of that decline. Reddit is likely just a year behind, although its decline is accelerating faster. We'll see which one fails first soon.