4 ms·
There’s a corollary to this which is you need to prioritize design to not take you out of your way more the higher up you are. A pedestrian path that goes a bl
by bombcar 3y ago
There’s a corollary to this which is you need to prioritize design to not take you out of your way more the higher up you are.
A pedestrian path that goes a block out of your way is discouraging in a way that a half mile dogleg in a car is not.
Sidewalks need to connect directly to destinations; not wander blocks out of the way to circuit parking lots.
The best “pathing” should be for pedestrians, followed by that for bikes. Cars and busses can go far out of their way, and trains can stay on their tracks.
- digdugdirk 3y agoThere is also the "enjoyment factor" that doesn't necessarily need to match up with pure efficiency. Separate bike paths that cut through parks or use their own cordoned off streets can make a trip so much more relaxing that it moves up the personal choice hierarchy, even if the time it takes to get somewhere increases. Not having to dodge F150s or breathe in exhaust fumes can go a long way to upping the desire to ride your bike to work in the morning.
- ilyt 3y agoFrom my experience that only goes from "bad to neutral". I'll gladly waste extra 5 minutes if my work commute cycling path doesn't have to share road with cars or otherwise car-congested area but if it is "just a cycling road" vs "a cycling road near nice forest", most times I go the shorter one.
- digdugdirk 3y agoVery true, my comment was more directed towards what you're discussing. The difference between "sharing a lane with SUVs on a regular street" and "physically separated bike path" is massive, and the lack of bike infrastructure makes cycling a complete non-starter for many.
- bombcar 3y agoAlmost by definition if you are not using a private vehicle you have already given up on the time factor (because while it is possible to find cases where bike/transit/walking beat a car they are rare or less than a block). And on a bike it feels different than on foot - I like walking the nice trail but it is 10 minutes longer than the silly sidewalk, and it just kind of dumps you in nowhere three blocks from anywhere you would like to be.
- kodah 3y ago> A pedestrian path that goes a block out of your way is discouraging in a way that a half mile dogleg in a car is not. In Portland it's actually worse than this. The areas that have built or maintained sidewalks are generally rich areas. The city puts sidewalk construction and maintenance on home builders and has an exhorbitant permitting scheme.
- _aleph2c_ 3y agoYou don't need to change the city, you can change yourself instead. I was stuck in a traffic jam once and decided to change my behavior. I bought an electric long board that can go off-road, that I could also carry on my back, so I can take the train and the bus. I'm a big guy so I had to buy a bruiser of a board (50 pounds) and a pack that could carry it. The board has an 80km (50 mile) range and it can go as fast as you want, but it speed wobbles at 50 km/hour (31 mile/hour), which requires you to put your weight onto the front and accelerate through the resonance. It's illegal to ride in my city, so now I'm an outlaw, I get great exercise when I pack it, and an incredible sense of freedom when I rip past the traffic, or politely navigate the bike lanes. The board is dangerous, so I can get out of my head: if I don't pay attention, I die; so it forces a flow state and clears all of my life worries -- something my motorcycle friends talk about a lot. I have crashed, and though painful, I usually go at a speed that I can run-out-of if something bad happens. You don't get sweaty like you do from riding a bike, so you can wear a suit under the safety gear. No need to change the city, you can get the revolution you want by deploying your own technology. If you live in a dirt-bag city, like I do, you don't have to worry about your windows being smashed or whatever, because you are carrying your car on your back.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dublinben 3y agoIt turns out that most people are not willing to risk their lives in this manner to get where they're going, so building proper infrastructure is necessary.