5 ms·
What I’ve learned from 35 years of wearing computerized eyewear (2013)
- bradknowles 3y agoExcellent article about Augmented Reality, written by Steven Mann, one of the worlds foremost experts on the subject. In 2013. It behooves us to look back at what has been done before, as we look to take this technology forward. I would be very curious to know what Steven Mann thinks of the Apple Vision Pro system.
- zoky 3y agoIt's interesting how he mentions Google Glass having captured the public's interest in such technology… which it did, if only for a hot minute. Now, ten years later, Apple has thrown its hat into the ring, and we'll see where it goes. Could this be another iPod or iPhone moment—where Apple wasn't the first to do it, or arguably even the best, but they somehow, despite being ostensibly late to the party, managed to get it right in a way where it truly changed things? My gut reaction is honestly, no, people still aren't going to want to walk around with digital goggles on their heads, regardless of whether their eyes are visible on the front or not. But then, if I were able to predict which of Apple's products would be unexpectedly and wildly successful, I'd be very wealthy, so…
- activiation 3y ago> people still aren't going to want to walk around with digital goggles on their heads The battery would need to last more than 2 hours
- bradknowles 3y agoThis could also be an AppleTV moment, where it takes a long time to turn into a real product that a lot of people will want. And even then might still not be a new core pillar of the Apple ecosystem. I dunno. I've had problems with every AR/VR system I've ever tried in the past 20+ years, so I don't know that Apple will be able to solve this one. But of all the companies who have at least announced products in this space, I think Apple is best equipped to make it happen. If anyone can do it, I think it's Apple. Just maybe not this decade.
- pmoriarty 3y ago"Could this be another iPod or iPhone moment—where Apple wasn't the first to do it, or arguably even the best, but they somehow, despite being ostensibly late to the party, managed to get it right in a way where it truly changed things?" The iPod and iPhone didn't cost $3500
- JasonFruit 3y agoBut they did cost what we considered unreasonable at the time. Some of us still do.
- plagiarist 3y agoI think it is aimed at professionals and home theater enthusiasts to break into the market. It will be interesting to see the next iterations, if they can slim down the size and price enough that it takes off.
- ghaff 3y agoI guess one question is whether--assuming these can substitute for large screens--people (perhaps specially in smaller urban apartments) would want to dispense with larger monitors and TVs. Living in a house, I'm a bit skeptical I'd have any personal utility.
- RobotToaster 3y agoThe iPod and iPhone tried to look sexy. Only someone with a cyborg fetish could consider that headset sexy.
- ghaff 3y agoI don't really consider the Vision Pro "AR" as most people think of it; Apple was probably smart to just coin another term. I watched the launch keynote and it seems more like an in-home VR+ as opposed to a HUD for people out walking around. Could it change? Sure. But there's a lot of technological distance between where things are now and what idealized outdoor AR looks like.
- d0mine 3y agoAR + AI assistant could be great: - "I see you are about to eat the 3rd donat today. It would put you over 3000 Cal target. The wedding is in 2 months.." - "the sign says you can't park here." - "the car on the left is slowing down. You can cross the street" - "this yogurt cost 10% less in the shop next door"
- fineIllregister 3y agoSeems more likely you would see ads for those donuts, then gym memberships and diet books and weight-loss apps. The goggles would steer you towards the more expensive yogurt because they paid for promotion.
- crooked-v 3y ago> My gut reaction is honestly, no, people still aren't going to want to walk around with digital goggles on their heads, regardless of whether their eyes are visible on the front or not. My interpretation here is that they're expecting it to only get worn in public on planes and at some high-nerd-quotient workplaces, but trying to prime the pump for 5 or 10 years down the road when they have a version that's as light and comfortable as (actual, not exaggerated) ski goggles with a battery that lasts as long as a current phone.
- bmitc 3y agoI am personally not interested in AR or VR whatsoever. None of the use cases have ever been interesting to me. Some AR applications for professional use are about the only ones that seem valid. Sidenote: is he writing equations comically large on the blackboard for a reason?
- zoky 3y ago> Sidenote: is he writing equations comically large on the blackboard for a reason? Well, yeah, he probably can't see them properly otherwise. Remember how grandma always used to tell you you'd ruin your eyesight by sitting too close to the TV?
- rcarmo 3y agoIn a teaching scenario, that is the norm. You err on the size of, well, size, because larger letters, especially written in a hurry, are easier to read by students sitting in the farthest rows of Ian amphitheater.
- bmitc 3y agoNo, it's not. That square root is well over a foot tall, maybe close to two feet, and he's clearly not in an amphitheatre.
- regularfry 3y agoThis might be a "don't knock it until you've tried it" thing. All I really want right now is virtual monitors, but I'm open to the idea that might be a lack of imagination on my part.
- statusfailed 3y agoI'm in the same boat- I just want a simple headset that overlays a big, high-resolution monitor on my normal vision. The closest thing I know of is the [Simula One](https://www.simulavr.com/ https://www.simulavr.com/), which seems to be a VR "virtual monitor". VR instead of AR is a dealbreaker for me though- I want AR virtual monitors that overlay the displays on my actual vision. Even VR which uses a camera to pass through to the display isn't really what I want. My ideal hardware would just be a "dumb" AR display with wide FOV and an HDMI input that just overlays the video data onto my normal vision. From what I understand a big challenge is the wide FOV though, but I don't know enough about optics to really understand why this is the case.
- adwmayer 3y agoNeeds (2013) in the title
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fsckboy 3y agoarticle is from 2013, so when he says "for 35 years" he means he started in 1978 when he was 16 years old-ish (this guy did the math, though I didn't figure out the months)
- ilamont 3y ago“Wearing it in public has, however, often brought me grief—usually from people objecting to what they think is a head-mounted video recorder.” I think there is a shift in the public mindset about public and sometimes private spaces being under constant video surveillance. I am conscious of this every time I walk by one of my neighbors’ homes as many are using doorbell cameras, or other similar security systems facing the street. Practically every store and train station has multiple cameras. In some countries the cameras are even more pervasive. For instance, the PRC government has gone full Big Brother, using cameras and facial recognition to track and control behavior. Moreover, not only does every adult and many children carry a high-quality video camera in their pocket, they are becoming more comfortable using them to take video of what they’re seeing around them. For these reasons, I believe if Google Glass were released today instead of 10 years ago, the reaction would be less hostile. I would be curious to know the author’s recent experience wearing DIY headsets and the public’s reactions/suspicions regarding video recording.
- golergka 3y agoI don't understand why would a person have a right to see something and remember it, but not record it. (Using this recording for various purposes is a while different issue though).
- episteme 3y agoIf there was a way to be sure it would stay only ever being viewed by that person, sure. For now, I think people shouldn't have the risk that it gets seen by others forced upon them.
- cfiggers 3y agoThere's an objective asymmetry to it. The person who has a flawless recording of what happened has options that the person who has a lossy recording of what happened (i.e. the one in their head) does not have. If everyone is on the same playing field (as in, neither have a recording or both have it) then it seems to me the objection is greatly lessened—it's when one party records and the other party doesn't have access to it that there's some sense of unfairness.
- Xen9 3y agoSteve Mann: a definition of genius
- ZiiS 3y ago[flagged]
- growt 3y agoHe describes a hit and run where the driver took of when he approached. Then I saw a picture of him with a homemade helmet thing with two antennas sticking out (second in the slideshow). And I think I can think of at least one reason that driver slammed it in reverse.