6 ms·
I’m not a doctor but my personal belief is that hypertension is over diagnosed. A lot of people have “white coat” syndrome, and pharma companies love to get peo
by SoftTalker 3y ago
I’m not a doctor but my personal belief is that hypertension is over diagnosed. A lot of people have “white coat” syndrome, and pharma companies love to get people on never-ending prescriptions.
- car 3y agoI’m not a doctor but my personal belief is that hypertension is over diagnosed. A lot of people have “white coat” syndrome, and pharma companies love to get people on never-ending prescriptions. Thanks for letting us know that you are in fact not a doctor. Because your belief is patently wrong. Source: I am a doctor. https://baptisthealth.net/baptist-health-news/high-blood-pressure-commonly-underdiagnosed-but-easy-to-monitor-and-control https://baptisthealth.net/baptist-health-news/high-blood-pre...
- voidfunc 3y agoI have high BP, I sort of see where OP is coming from... you need a lot of BP numbers to gain confidence about how bad the situation is. A one-off doctor visit once a year is not enough but it is often how the diagnosis is made. My best recommendation for people is to get a BP cuff and just get comfortable with taking samplings periodically through the day. I take anywhere from 3 to 10 readings a day and over a month or two the data paints a good picture of your situation plus it makes you more comfortable with BP reads.
- pkaye 3y agoMy MIL get white coat syndrome and every time she is at the hospital here numbers are much higher than at home. Her GP would not agree with this and continued to treat her with blood pressure pills aggressively. She would get dizzy and low pressure at home. Eventually switched to another doctor who trusted her and adjusted the prescription accordingly and those problems stopped and she managed to a reasonable BP range.
- stinos 3y agoA one-off doctor visit once a year is not enough but it is often how the diagnosis is made Is that actually so? Around here, the very first thing which each doctor I know off is going to say after a high reading in such one-off visit is exactly your second paragraph, because they are well aware one-off readings cannot be trusted for a diagnosis and are typically higher because of white coat stress and whatnot.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoI can't really speak for other doctors, only for myself. White coat syndrome is extremely common in my experience. The existence of false positives does not make hypertension "overdiagnosed" though, it's still underdiagnosed. There's a legion of people out there with high blood pressure who don't feel a thing. This is why doctors employ high sensitivity testing for every single patient: office blood pressure measurements. If you get a normal result, OK. If you get high blood pressure, it could be hypertension so the doctor monitors more closely. Screening works by testing everyone with simple, cheap, fast tests and selecting those with anything that even remotely looks like a positive result for more elaborate and expensive specific tests.
- wmidwestranger 3y agoWell doctor, your staff prefers to take my blood pressure while talking to me and putting a thermometer in my mouth which I'm certain violates the protocol and the target numbers were lowered by a significant amount a few years ago to boot and most people would resent pharma companies even in the best of times, so may I just accept my miniscule stroke risk in peace please and maybe focus on the underlying issues? I already have to piss all the time from the chlorthalidone which costs more than Netflix, though it was developed a half-century ago and is made by the ton. You missed the dehydration signal in my metabolic results and your renal imaging req came up clear but cost $2k. Can you do anything to help me live because the medical industry is doing a lot to make not living look good, or not being a patient.
- LeafItAlone 3y agoSounds like you either need to communicate with your doctor better or find a new one. Doctors are human and not all-knowing (no matter how some may come across) and the patient needs to be part of their care.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- matheusmoreira 3y agoActively talking during blood pressure measurements can cause false positives. Listening and sampling of temperature in parallel shouldn't. Target systolic blood pressure in hypertensive adults is still 120-130 mmHg. The stroke risk is certainly not "minuscule", people die a lot less when they take the medicine. Underlying issues are likely to be exacerbated by hypertension since it causes continuous damage to major organs. Chlorthalidone is not the only anti-hypertensive medication available, there are other effective drugs with no diuretic effect, I suggest you talk to your doctor about the risks and benefits of each class of drug so you can make an informed decision. They are certainly not risk free. Costs of testing and medicines are a matter of private and public policy, your doctor has zero influence on that, it's not their fault.
- midnightauro 3y ago
- cromulent 3y agoI’m not a doctor but I do read articles and studies about how doctors can be wrong about hypertension. https://newsroom.heart.org/news/some-health-care-professionals-use-outdated-guidelines-to-screen-and-diagnose-hypertension https://newsroom.heart.org/news/some-health-care-professiona... https://www.bmj.com/content/365/bmj.l1657 https://www.bmj.com/content/365/bmj.l1657
- hello_computer 3y agoI had one doctor do a lipid test, then tell me how horrible my numbers are and that I needed to get on meds, stat. Took the lipid test again with a different doctor, and the numbers were fine. How come? First "doctor" forgot that it was supposed to be a fasting test, took my blood shortly after a fried fish dinner, and charged me $400+ for a pointless scare. And this is just a recent example. I could go on and on with personal examples of drive-by medicine. The overwhelming majority of "doctors" all have a favorite hammer, and the rest of us end up getting nailed with it.
- epcoa 3y agohttps://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/farewell-fasting-cholesterol-test-201606169784 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/farewell-fasting-cholest... I don't know the exact details of your case so not responding to that, but routine lipid testing does not need to be fasting even though the test is often marked as a "fasting" test. The only number that is acutely affected is triglycerides. Some labs still call it a fasting test - but we do not routinely advise patients to fast before a lipid screen since the main screening numbers are LDL and HDL. It gets more complicated with triglycerides. A general sensible approach is that if triglycerides are over 400 on a non-fasting test to repeat with a fasting test. > The overwhelming majority of "doctors" all have a favorite hammer, In this case the diagnostic and management algorithm is pretty straightforward, unfortunately not all doctors are that good. Not sure if "overwhelming majority." is the case.
- hello_computer 3y agoThe triglycerides were the concern, and it is infuriating. Any other business would at least express come contrition and issue a refund, or at least an apology, but not doctors. If anything, she was upset that I wouldn't make her next appointment. We have so many olds and self-abusers in this country that medicine has become the new religion--with doctors as the new priests; pharmaceuticals and procedures as the new sacraments. How can we hold the priest responsible for the parishioner's sin? After all, the parishioner did not eat the right things, or did not exercise enough, or was tainted with the original sin of his own genetics. edit: The mentality is boldly duplicitous. When you challenge their diagnoses on their own turf, they are men and women "of science", and you are a fool to yourself to question them, but when the mistakes are laid bare; being discussed inside of a courtroom--see how fast the appellation changes: from "man of science" to "humble practitioner".
- vxNsr 3y ago> Source: I am a doctor. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof. Especially if you’re linking to a pop-health website to support your opinions.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 3y agoI fainted and nearly died on several occasions from low blood pressure caused by overdose on blood pressure medications or its interactions with other medications/substances. With high blood pressure, I feel uncomfortable but never so severe. So there is definitely danger here.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoThere absolutely is. Especially in patients with orthostatic hypotension. Especially elderly patients with fall risk. Geriatric care is often a balancing act, managing the risk of complications from side effects of medications and the risk of the complications from the diseases they treat. No treatment is risk free. Treatment is warranted when the risk/benefit analysis is favorable.
- francisofascii 3y agoI got a new doctor recently and he agrees. He also told me to take by BP multiple times a day several days a week, for several weeks. To base high blood pressure on one reading at the doctors office every few months is won’t get you the statistical significance you need. And also to record if you drink coffee that day, if you exercised before a reading, slept well the night before, etc. BP can vary greatly from all those daily factors.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> To base high blood pressure on one reading at the doctors office every few months is won’t get you the statistical significance you need. Depends. If it's high enough and there's other risk factors, it's pretty safe to immediately diagnose it as hypertension.
- lurking_swe 3y agoexcept blood pressure is ALWAYS measured incorrectly at a doctors office. So what’s the point? Have you ever had a health professional follow these steps? “Don't drink a caffeinated beverage or smoke during the 30 minutes before the test. Sit quietly for five minutes before the test begins. During the measurement, sit in a chair with your feet on the floor and your arm supported so your elbow is at about heart level. The inflatable part of the cuff should completely cover at least 80% of your upper arm, and the cuff should be placed on bare skin, not over a shirt. Don't talk during the measurement.” source: https://www.health.harvard.edu/heart-health/tips-to-measure-your-blood-pressure-correctly https://www.health.harvard.edu/heart-health/tips-to-measure-... Very elevated readings at the doctors office are probably a sign you should get your own BP Machine and do readings at home, to see if it’s actually an issue when measured correctly.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Have you ever had a health professional follow these steps? 100% of the time I’ve had initially (mildly) high reading as an adult, I've had a second reading in the office assuring that those are followed (usually, only the “sit quietly for five minutes preceding” is skipped initially), and that's been over a period of 30+ years.
- irjustin 3y agoDown voting Once you're diagnosed with high BP you can and should self monitor. That'll show the white coat if it is there. Also BP meds are insanely cheap because.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoHypertension is NOT overdiagnosed. If anything people aren't taking it seriously enough. It's true that white coat syndrome must be accounted for just like all the other factors. Best way to do that is to regularly measure and keep track of your blood pressure throughout the day with your own sphygmomanometer. Sometimes 24 hour sampling may be warranted.
- thelastgallon 3y agoThe recommendation for bp reading is: Sit in a comfortable chair with your back supported for at least 5 minutes before your reading - https://www.cdc.gov/bloodpressure/measure.htm https://www.cdc.gov/bloodpressure/measure.htm However, this doesn't happen. In US, you check in, sit in the waiting area, then a nurse takes you in, checks weight on the way to the room, then takes bp as soon as you sit. All done in 90 seconds to 2 mins. I thought I had high BP, but was confused by the range of 20+/-, luckily my primary doctor explained the procedure and took my measurement. Now I don't get concerned, I know they are doing it wrong.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoHuh, I had no idea it was like that in the US. Where I live doctors measure blood pressure during the consults. There is no nurse.
- epcoa 3y agoIn many clinics in the US it won’t even be a nurse it will be an MA. The quality is highly variable but I don’t think it matters the staff members, taking a BP with a machine is not hard and can be trained, this is an overall issue with clinic management and quality - which is unfortunately highly variable.
- mhb 3y agoSometimes there's harmful cost-cutting and sometimes there's comparative advantage...
- davikr 3y agoI disagree, but I voted your comment up because I think it brings interesting discussion. I find it imperative to treat hypertension whenever possible to avoid long-term complications such as chronic kidney disease which will inevitably lead to costly treatments like hemodialysis or transplant, without even going into heart affections caused by long left untreated hypertension.
- Broken_Hippo 3y agoA lot of people have “white coat” syndrome I mean, go to a different doctor if yours somehow doesn't know about it. Mine all have. They help account for it by sending folks home with a blood pressure machine hooked up, which you wear for 24 hours. It regularly measures blood pressure - every 15 mintues, IIRC, including at night. In the US, I had a doctor suggest I take it outside of the office regularly so that we could compare. I worked at a pharmacy, so just took it there. "Pharma companies" aren't there to get on never-ending prescriptions: Curing things gets them fame too. Plus, the "big pharma wants you sick" conspiracies seriously leave out all of the pressure to not have folks on medications for life. Single payer health care plans, governments that administer them, private individuals, and for-profit health insurance companies all would rather not pay for it. I'm not pro big pharma, but I'm also too prudent to believe this.
- acumenical 3y ago> for-profit health insurance companies all would rather not pay for it Do you really believe a for-profit company doesn't want profit?
- zdragnar 3y agoThey don't profit from doctors charging them, they profit by getting premiums and paying out less than they take in.
- itairall 3y agoI just don't see what rational reason there is to say this when we have an epidemic of overweight people who don't exercise at all. This is only going to get worse too as people who grew up overweight and not exercising get older.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoI agree, there is no reason to believe hypertension is overdiagnosed. If anything it's underdiagnosed. Even without the obesity risk factor, there would still be legions of people out there with hypertension who feel literally nothing. The existence of false positives does not change that, it's an expected phenomenon in any kind of testing, diagnostic or not. It does get worse with age: pretty much all the chronic diseases become more common as people get older.