3 ms·
I've genuinely never understood why competition for workers hasn't resulted in giving programmers their own offices. Places like Google and Meta pay $$$$$ for
by crazygringo 3y ago
I've genuinely never understood why competition for workers hasn't resulted in giving programmers their own offices.
Places like Google and Meta pay $$$$$ for their office space, hiring fancy architects and installing all sorts of perks. So I don't think it's simply a financial question.
I think there must be something that's actually appealing about it to most of the employees. Is it that it feels like studying in the library in college, everybody occupying a single seat at a long table? Does it make people feel high-paid information wizards, mimicking the long rows of traders at traditional Wall St. financial firms? Is it meant to feel like a "group project" where everybody's working shoulder-to-shoulder? Is it meant to feel "flat" and non-hierarchical, because offices are for fuddy-duddies from the 1950's? Is it so lots of the space can be dedicated to ping-pong tables and video-game areas and a fancy café area instead, because that's what influences prospective employees more?
If private offices really were deeply desired by employees, lots of companies would use them as perks in order to attract talent in the war for programming talent. Yet they don't.
So what's going on here?
- lolinder 3y agoThese days it's probably because there's a lot of overlap between the people who really want a private office and the people who really want to work from home. It's far cheaper for a company to offer the latter, and for many employees it's preferable, even compared to a private office (no commute!).
- somewhereoutth 3y agoA good question. I had a private office once, however it did not have a window or other source of natural light, which was a big problem. Maybe that's one advantage of open plan - it brings natural light to everyone.
- rootsudo 3y agoHow do you distinguish a private office with no window from a closet?
- Paul-Craft 3y agoThe nameplate on the door. Seriously, my office in grad school was a glorified closet. I never used it and rarely visited it.
- closeparen 3y agoSoftware engineers are valuable, but square feet in the Bay Area are more valuable. Consider that a median home costs around $144k/yr to carry. That’s about half of Google L4 TC. Offices are smaller than homes but office space is also more expensive per square foot. The cost of a 200-300sqft private office is similar. Sometime around 2017-18 I was told that our (extremely high density) open office cost $25k/head per year. At that time I was only making $110k so that was mind blowing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- opportune 3y agoFrom the company perspective they care about the all-in employee cost so including all the perks, health insurance, payroll tax, and personnel overhead (hr, recruiting) the cost per-head doesn’t look so bad. If you consider that the all-in cost of an L4 is more like $400-500k/year it becomes a little baffling that they don’t just get 2x the space they currently do if it will only cost $25k/y and make it so they get their own cubicle or mini office.
- closeparen 3y ago$25k/yr is for a shoulder-to-shoulder workstation at a shared bench, private office would be 4-5x that.
- solardev 3y agoIf they forced me into a private office I'd just quit. That sounds like the worst of both worlds... a tiny cramped cube with no social interaction or impromptu collaboration, just like home, but with the added commute. The open layout is nice for giving that team feeling. But yeah it can be distracting for sure. I tend to be much more productive at home, ironically, but I prefer the office because there are other people there and it doesn't feel like such a lonely rat race. That feeling goes away when everyone is in their own little office though.
- crazygringo 3y agoThank you, this was exactly the perspective I was looking for. It seems rarely expressed here.
- Paul-Craft 3y ago> That sounds like the worst of both worlds... a tiny cramped cube with no social interaction or impromptu collaboration.... But, that's why they have doors, which can be opened or closed, or left slightly ajar, all of which can be used to indicate your willingness to receive visitors. And why must "private office" mean "tiny cramped cube?" Do you not imagine there being any common areas where people can sit and work? Sure, if your idea of "private offices" is "tiny, cramped cubes," I get it. I had an office in grad school I almost never visited, much less used, because it was the size of a walk-in closet and was assigned to me and two other students. But I'm thinking more like the professors' offices, where you can have a couch in there, and a desk, and a window, and some bookshelves, and go down the hall to get some coffee or sit in the commons room, etc.
- solardev 3y agoIt's a totally different feeling to sit at a communal table vs visiting someone in their private office, even with the doors open. It's the difference between studying with your friends together at the library and visiting your professor during office hours. Not saying either is better or worse, just different. I'd prefer the open collaboration model and would never want a private office, no matter how spacious it is. It's just lonely. On the other hand, I also wouldn't force people to sit at the big table (or come into the office at all) if they work better alone. People are just different and their workspace needs should be respected as much as possible. Even when fully WFH, I paid for a coworking space membership without a private desk, specifically for the collaborative feel and social chit chat. Many others did the same. And others still paid for private offices with their doors closed. There's no one size fit all approach to this, and IMO there shouldn't be because people aren't the same. Companies that try to lump everyone together under one policy just ends up with a bunch of desks that sit empty most of the week, grumpy WFHers who reluctantly come in because they have to (getting nothing done that day), and sad extroverts like me who are surrounded by people who don't really want to be there. Why not just let people choose, as long as they can still do the work? The control freak mentality is the problem, not private offices vs open layouts.