3 ms·
This is one of the most embarrassing reviews I have ever read (for the paper reviewed). AI research needs urgently certain good practices to adhere to, but the
by freehorse 3y ago
This is one of the most embarrassing reviews I have ever read (for the paper reviewed). AI research needs urgently certain good practices to adhere to, but the current status is that it is really hard to take many of the results seriously due to the opaqueness that characterises it in many steps of the process. And such serious mistakes and bad practices certainly do not help the field to achieve any credibility.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThis note from the article is important: > Several of the authors listed on the discussed paper are undergraduate researchers. Consequently, we believe it's inappropriate to hold these individuals accountable for any lapses present in the work. Instead, we believe the responsibility should lie with the supervising authors. They are the ones who are expected to ensure that the work meets the rigorous standards of public scholarship within their field.