4 ms·
> How would you propose we differentiate between students "playing along" and students really having false memories? Remove the incentive for the student to fa
by anonymouskimmer 3y ago
> How would you propose we differentiate between students "playing along" and students really having false memories?
Remove the incentive for the student to fabulate.
Have another, supposedly (to the students) 'independent' researcher ask them questions about it days or weeks later. A potential way of doing this would be to have a member of the Institutional Review Board (or supposed member of said board) following up with the students as a matter of 'quality control' and verification that the study followed IRB guidelines. Phrase the reason for the questioning as looking for non-punitive, but developmental, feedback for the researcher.
For ethical reasons this would probably require blinding the original researcher to the identities of the students, but this could be done by having people other than the PI actually ask the questions.
For a particular study on whether or not the student did something criminal, have the questioner truthfully assert to the student binding confidentiality as to their identity by dint of being a psychologist or someone like that who has the legal duty to not divulge.
- Timon3 3y agoThank you for an actual proposal! It makes a lot of sense to me, but there is one reason it probably wouldn't be allowed: the study "implanted" false memories (in the sense that participants stated they believed false memories). I don't think the study would pass ethical review if you were only to follow up days or weeks later (after the supposed end of the study), since that would also be the earliest point you would be able to clear up the lie.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoIt could probably be tailored to a shorter time period. A possible great way to do it is have the students originally questioned by grad students, and then the professor themself 'follow up' shortly afterward as a 'check' on their grad student's process. The problem with that is that some of the students may feel incentivized to make the grad student look good.