4 ms·
> While you have the right to remain silent, I remember reading somewhere that you have to actively invoke that right (by stating something like "I invoke my 5t
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> While you have the right to remain silent, I remember reading somewhere that you have to actively invoke that right (by stating something like "I invoke my 5th amendment right to remain silent") for your silence to be considered an invocation of that right, and not merely suspicious behavior, an implicit admission of guilt, or obstruction of justice.
This is, as I ubderstand it, incorrect on multiple levels. First, all you need to do is shut up to exercise the right. Second, no matter how you frame exercising the right, police can and will treat it as suspicious.
You may be confusing the right to remain silent with the right to have counsel present during questioning, which must be explicilty invoked for questioning without counsel present and its fruits to be excluded. They are separate, but related (as invoking the right to counsel also narrows the ways police can pressure you to waive the rightbto remain silent without legally tainting anything they get out of it.)
- jcranmer 3y ago> First, all you need to do is shut up to exercise the right. Actually, as I understand it, SCOTUS has said that merely being silent is not the same as invoking your Fifth Amendment right to remain silent. I think this jurisprudence is complete bananapants, but the argument is that you have to explicitly and unambiguously invoke your Fifth Amendment right for it to kick in, and being silent isn't an unambiguous invocation.
- ccooffee 3y agoCorrect. You MUST EXPLICITLY invoke your fifth amendment right against self-incrimination. (Okay, there may be some edge cases where invoking the fifth is implied, but SCOTUS has merely acknowledged that these edge cases could exist, but to my knowledge has never given rules for when it applies. Better safe than sorry.) e: see Salinas v Texas[0] for example [0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/12-246#writing-12-246_OPINION_3 https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/12-246#writing...
- PaulHoule 3y agoIn a courtroom, yes. https://www.nytimes.com/1973/07/18/archives/krough-pleads-5th-at-house-inquiry-first-watergate-witness-to.html https://www.nytimes.com/1973/07/18/archives/krough-pleads-5t...
- owenmarshall 3y ago> This is, as I ubderstand it, incorrect on multiple levels. First, all you need to do is shut up to exercise the right. Incorrect. The police can continue interrogation if you sit quietly. Also, it’s possible to revoke your assertion of the 5th after you have invoked it. If the police say you did, and you say you didn’t, who do you think the courts will believe? As such, most legal advice I have heard is to simply say “I am not speaking until I get a lawyer.” It is unambiguous during interrogation, and it’ll stand up well during any suppression hearings. > Second, no matter how you frame exercising the right, police can and will treat it as suspicious. “You can beat the time but you can’t beat the ride.” If you are in a position where you are invoking these rights you are already considered suspicious. You may be arrested. You might be tried. But keep your eye on the prize: your goal is to not get convicted.