8 ms·
KC archbishop clarifies wine validity norms
- tiahura 3y ago[flagged]
- rendang 3y agoVery strange that we don't have ingredient labels for alcoholic beverages, even though pretty much every other substance you ingest has them, and even many things you don't, e.g. soap and shampoo.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoThis is a fairly tough nut to crack, because the FDA in these United States does not have any requirement for winemakers to put ingredients on their label. So you have the situation where you really have no idea what's in the wine, or how it was made, beyond a few disclaimers such as "contains sulfites". So, like this archbishop has mandated, you can choose only wine that is especially certified for sacramental use, which means that the makers pledge they're following Canon Law in making the wine. But, again, this is a self-certification, and it means you're trusting the makers when they say what the ingredients are. They're still not regulated, they're still not mandated to have a label. I also learned, from commenters, that some wines are specifically made to be invalid matter, such as Kosher wines, which are boiled, and cane sugar is added, and so they deliberately invalidate the wine so that Catholics cannot use it for the Eucharist, which I suppose would be sacrilegious in the opinion of many Jews. This also relates to the makers of altar bread, which of course can't really be purchased in a grocery store and so it's always made especially for sacramental use. There has been a marked rise in the use of "low-gluten hosts" for those with Celiac disease or gluten allergies. The Catholic Church has weighed in on this, and has specifically said that there must be gluten in the host in order to be valid matter. So there are altar bread manufacturers who make host out of potato, or rice flour, and while Episcopalians and Lutherans may be OK with this, Catholics are not, and so pastors must be careful that their "low-gluten hosts" are not "gluten-free". Just to confuse the matter, an extremely low-gluten product can be marketed as "gluten-free" according to FDA rules, so enjoy the confusion. I have seen Catholic parish bulletins advertising "gluten-free hosts" and I just cringe, because they're basically saying "we use invalid matter for our Eucharist!" even if they really are using that approved, low-gluten altar bread. And there are nuns who proudly make the stuff just for that reason.
- anamexis 3y agoYour comment made me curious so I did a bit of research - kosher wines are not boiled or adulterated for the purpose of making it unsuitable for Eucharist. Rather, according to ancient Jewish tradition, if kosher wine is boiled (which is called Mevushal wine), it remains kosher even if handled by non-Jews. This is in contrast to uncooked kosher wine, which loses its kosher status if handled by non-Jews.
- kodah 3y agoI'd love to hear from someone that knows but afaik most things Kosher derive from ancient food safety where provenance was also part of safety.
- tubs 3y agoTwo reasons. There were some alleged cultist/idolatry practices involving wine that would cause it to become non kosher so it’s easier to just blanket ban anything handled by a goy. I think boiling makes it unusable for those same rituals. It’s also to discourage fraternising (especially romantically) with goyim.
- mavhc 3y agoThis should be an indie puzzle video game
- mistrial9 3y agothis is interesting, but it seems like a cover for old feuds over commercial food services to pious people. In the USA there was a specific, constructed and lawful means to end "pious people captured by commercial efforts masked as piety" and secondly, a constructed reform within religious communities, to move past this sort of obvious, power and profit motivated supply chain control. Not all places or people have been motivated to include themselves in these reforms, of course.
- cwzwarich 3y agoActually, you're both right. One of the explanations (albeit, not the only one) given for why boiled wine remains kosher if handled by non-Jews is that it's considered unacceptable for non-Jews to use in idolatrous rituals.
- bediger4000 3y agoGreat article! I was unaware of he existence of "valid matter", "dubious or doubtful matter", and "invalid matter" until now. I was similarly unaware of organizations like Dicastery for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, and Society of the Divine Word. Heck, I was unaware of the word and concept "dicastery". This has been very illuminating.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoThere are actually many more Dicasteries than there were a year ago, since Pope Francis reorganized the Roman Curia. Previously, many of them were called Congregations. So far, it is basically a name change for the same sort of orgs, but it represents a sort of change in orientation.
- readthenotes1 3y agoIn addition, it made me wonder how Jesus felt when all the sudden his blood is full of sulfates!
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoI don't think that you meant to use that word. But you're very busy being cute and clever and insulting, what could it matter?
- readthenotes1 3y agoCopper sulfate is sometimes added to wine. What word do you think I didn't mean to use? In the Eucharist the words are "this is my blood".
- Bud 3y ago[dead]
- mavhc 3y agoThe MS Office 2003 toolbar version of religion. You got some people to write some code/rules, and then didn't fire them, so they just kept making the code/rules more complicated to keep their job. I'm super sure that God really really cares about the kind of wine, and not the intentions of the humans asking for help
- wwarner 3y agoI totally agree, but I don't think the reason has anything to do with what god would think, actually. It's about trying to put yourself in the mindset of christians throughout history. That something of the original last supper is preserved in the celebration of mass today.
- pianoben 3y agoOh, what I'd give for a good old toolbar again. I've still never adjusted properly to the Ribbon and its comparative waste of space. Give me density, dammit!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jawns 3y agoThis is a common criticism: "Why would God care about this seemingly minute detail?" We hear it, as well, with things like, "Does God really care if I eat meat on Friday?" But actually, the whole point is that if we can't expend the effort to make trivial sacrifices, or to follow seemingly trivial rules about valid matter for the Eucharist, then why on earth would we expect ourselves to get more important things right? Catholicism is not as persnickety as you might think, but there is a "When you know better, do better" mentality. Now that the bishop has realized the problem, he's taking steps to do better and rectify the issue. Yes, we trust that God knows what's in our hearts, but that doesn't mean we should just shrug our shoulders and say, "Not a big deal" when we have the opportunity to do better.
- leephillips 3y ago
- metaphor 3y agoMarket price: $75+ a bottle[1]...of course. I'm somehow reminded of corporate McDonald's grift of contractually forcing Taylor ice cream machines on franchisees. EDIT: cbfrench below correctly points out that that price is per case...the devil was hiding in the details and I stand corrected. [1] https://www.zieglers.com/church-goods/sacramental/sacramental-wine/ https://www.zieglers.com/church-goods/sacramental/sacramenta...
- cbfrench 3y agoFor one thing, that’s the case price, not the price per bottle. And that’s not really a sound analogy, as Cribari isn’t the only sacramental vintner, nor is Ziegler’s the only supplier of said wine. And there are general canonical provisions (varying by diocese, of course) for using wine that isn’t approved as sacramental; it just saves a few headaches (and, obviously, concerns about validity) to go ahead and procure the sacramental stuff, especially when it’s not exorbitantly expensive per case. Here’s a longer, more punctilious discussion of the variety of wines that may qualify for sacramental use in the Roman Catholic Church: https://wdtprs.com/2013/04/quaeritur-is-sherry-valid-matter-for-the-consecration-during-mass/ https://wdtprs.com/2013/04/quaeritur-is-sherry-valid-matter-...
- metaphor 3y ago> For one thing, that’s the case price, not the price per bottle. Thanks for the clarification; the devil certainly was in the details on that one.
- cbfrench 3y agoYeah, it’s really not clear unless you click through and see that the weight per unit is 37 lbs. Unsurprisingly, purveyors of church goods almost invariably have terrible websites. Ziegler’s is comparatively decent, lol.
- verall 3y agoAre there any other manufacturers of commercial scale soft serve machines? No matter where I go it's always a Taylor.
- dmurray 3y agoTime for a schism in the Church, where both sides agree on every matter of doctrine and practice, except that one side takes this Cansacastran view on the eucharist and the other follows the Dogma of St Petersburg, also detailed in the article: > Any good house wine is fine... Bottom line: the finer quality of wine, the better it is. This is an important consideration since the wine selected will become the Body and Blood of Christ.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mbg721 3y agoCatholics see what you say, and unfortunately, the right thing to do is to say "no", if we are to be consistent. We live measured by centuries, not years, so maybe we'll be okay.
- mbg721 3y agoThis is a lose-lose situation for the few Catholics who know or care about the difference between valid and licit Masses (and probably went to more traditional parishes anyway) and everyone else will be oblivious to the whole thing.
- AlbertCory 3y agoHonest question, no trolling: for Jews and Muslims, the "kosher" and "halal" labels are heavily regulated, and AFAIK there isn't any great controversy about shady operators self-labeling their ordinary foods in order to sell more (or is there?). So as a (former) Catholic: why can't the Church do something similar? Is it only because the market for sacramental wine is so much smaller than the market for halal foods?
- cratermoon 3y agoAt least for kosher I'm aware that rabbis inspect and approve the manufacturing facility and process directly. This is doubly true for items labeled "Kosher for Passover". https://oukosher.org/passover/articles/what-is-kosher-for-passover/ https://oukosher.org/passover/articles/what-is-kosher-for-pa...
- bradleyjg 3y agoThe kashrut authorities have found an interesting loophole. It’s a violation of the first amendment for a state to directly ban the labeling of unkosher food as kosher. Too much entanglement with religion. However the various authorities have registered trademarks like ou and k. Enforcing ordinary trademark law runs into no constitutional issues.
- mbg721 3y agoI see the kashrut trademarks as a good workaround that lets legitimate religious objections work well with American law.
- no-reply 3y agoAs far as "halal", there have been shady operators doing self-labeling. [1] There are also companies that do not follow the halal process completely/properly but still label themselves as halal. For example, the animal (cow/cattle/lamb/camel/...) has to be slaughtered from below the neck by a Muslim man by hand while making the animal face a certain direction and also reciting prayer. What do these companies do ? They have the prayers on speaker and a robot/machine that slaughters the animals. Is it halal ? No. But there are some agencies who would gladly give you a "halal" certification for some money, and now you are certified halal. "Halal" word in Arabic just means permissible. In the food context, we look for halal (permissible stuff, not logo) in not just meat, but also any product that contains animal by products/byproducts, like cheese for example. Microbial rennet is okay, animal rennet not so much. We usually avoid eating factory made food that contain animal products/byproducts. If it is something that can has vegetable and animal sources, then we check the ingredients/labels to see if something is specified. Sometimes they clearly specify vegetable source. Otherwise if source is not clear, or if not sure about the certification agency, we either look for a kosher label on that (if it contains some animal products/byproducts) or manually call the company and ask away any questions. If both of those are not possible, we look for something else. [1]. https://www.google.com/search?q=fake+halal+meat https://www.google.com/search?q=fake+halal+meat
- ttepasse 3y agoCanon law itself is rather laconic on the ingredients to be transsubstantiated: > Can. 924 > §1. The most holy eucharistic sacrifice must be offered with bread and with wine in which a little water must be mixed. > §2. The bread must be only wheat and recently made so that there is no danger of spoiling. > §3. The wine must be natural from the fruit of the vine and not spoiled. https://www.vatican.va/archive/cod-iuris-canonici/eng/documents/cic_lib4-cann879-958_en.html#Art._3 https://www.vatican.va/archive/cod-iuris-canonici/eng/docume....
- tenpies 3y agoAn interesting point regarding Catholic Canon Law is that there is a distinction between validity and liceity: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Validity_and_liceity_(Catholic_Church) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Validity_and_liceity_(Catholic... To a casual reader, it may seem the "valid" and "licit" are nearly interchangeably in this article, but they are two different things and there are cases where an action is valid and illicit, or invalid, but licit. Canon 126 is also relevant for this particular case: > Can. 126 An act placed out of ignorance or out of error concerning something which constitutes its substance or which amounts to a condition sine qua non[1] is invalid. Otherwise it is valid unless the law makes other provision. An act entered into out of ignorance or error, however, can give rise to a rescissory action according to the norm of law. This is part of why Catholicism does not view itself as legalistic despite having a well-developed code of law. In minor things, it is assumed that God gives the benefit of the doubt so mistakes made out of ignorance/error do not affect the validity of the action. This also helps with scrupulosity and splintering over minor things. --- [1] Latin for "an essential condition" or "something absolutely indispensable"
- 2023throwawayy 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoNo doubt because the submitter thought it was intellectually interesting and enough upvoters agreed: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. Religious practices are often quite interesting if one can relate to them out of curiosity (the intended spirit of this site). The challenge is that intense emotions, identities, etc. can also get activated and those can easily drown out the interesting aspects. Curiosity isn't a high-intensity phenomenon - it requires a light touch. Quite a few commenters in this thread have been managing to discuss the OP in the curious spirit, which is good - probably better than median for this type of topic!
- 2023throwawayy 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y ago"Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mistrial9 3y agothis seems like a topic mainly of interest to people who are interested in making divisions between communities larger
- tptacek 3y agoIs this a traditionalist ("tradcath") thing? I feel like there was no such scrupulousness about the wine at masses when I was growing up. I don't mean this as a dismissal. If you're not Catholic you might not have noticed that there is a weird cultural moment happening right now, with a very small but noisy (or prominent, if you like) faction of traditionalists, many of them young hipsters. It's oddly centered on New York City and Kansas/Nebraska. So I see things like this, almost unrecognizable from the church I grew up in, and I wonder if this is just another tendril of that movement.
- probably_wrong 3y agoSpeaking from my personal experience, I feel my (South American) priest would have rolled his eyes at this, the same way I would feel about (say) the Rust foundation releasing a clarification document on tabs vs spaces. I understand the need for a baseline to keep churches from holding mass with Fanta, and I agree that good wine is better than bad wine. But I easily imagine a Last Crusade moment where we learn that Jesus actually drank poor people's wine and, in an ironic twist (as suggested by a dead comment), it turns out that his wine was diluted and wouldn't fit the definition here.
- tptacek 3y agoRight! I mean: there's nothing wrong with this stuff; Jewish people have kashrut, Muslims have haram and halal, Hindus (or at least a big chunk of them) have ovo-lacto vegetarianism. But: this seems like something new. I doubt many people in my parish would care at all about the specific wine used at mass. For that matter: most people don't even take wine at mass.
- madars 3y agon=1 data point -- as a practicing Catholic who cares about the discipline of sacraments, this is the first time I hear about concerns regarding sacramental wine. At the same time, the story of using invalid baptismal formula ("we baptize" instead of "I baptize"; discussed on HN here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30348624 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30348624) definitely made rounds in my circles (attending Ordinary Form Mass but also leaning traditional). In general, what I see gives me a lot of hope: people care (and that they care about the right stuff; worrying about sulfites is likely misguided). Overall, it can't be that a confession line is always empty but line to receive the Eucharist is 100% of parishioners. (Shoutout to Boston HNers - check out OMV churches like St. Clements or St. Francis; historically, St. Clements was the first church in the Boston area to offer public Masses and sacrament of penance during the early days of COVID, including special-made arrangements like https://www.facebook.com/StClementShrine/posts/pfbid0zmWzyKaV3KXNPAfWLPPzr17f9aZarrtVtWUiapNXB56k3VBhq5EaXb5moPJ7PUV8l https://www.facebook.com/StClementShrine/posts/pfbid0zmWzyKa... They also have ample Eucharistic Adoration. IYKYK.)
- Simon_O_Rourke 3y ago[flagged]
- itnAAnti 3y ago[flagged]
- foogazi 3y ago> As a result, he wrote, in those parishes, “for any number of years all Masses were invalid and therefore the intentions for which those Masses were offered were not satisfied What about all the weddings? How can a lay person know if the Mass they are attending “counts” ?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alexmolas 3y agoYou don't need a Mass to get married. Actually it's a different sacrament, and the only things you need are the two spouses and a qualified witness (aka the Priest)
- anon291 3y agoYou don't need a priest for a wedding. In the Latin rite, a couple marries themselves. In the medieval times, the church allowed couples to marry in secret without a priest (and without any witnesses). The only sacramental requirement for a marriage is a man and woman make a solemn commitment to live together as husband and wife with full understanding and full freedom to enter into the agreement. However as you can imagine this became an administrative nightmare as couples sought to divorce after such a secret marriage and no one could say whether the marriage was valid. So the church required marriage vows to be made public and in front of witnesses in order to be legal. However, the couple is the minister not the priest. During a Catholic marriage, the couple is seated on the sanctuary along with the priest . One of the few times laypeople can do that.
- saghm 3y agoAs someone who grew up Catholic but isn't now, it's always very bizarre to see stuff like this. Catholic teaching explicitly claims that the wine is miraculously transformed into the "blood of Christ", but I guess it only works if the wine doesn't have additives? It's hard enough for me to imagine a god that wants to bless his followers by letting them drink his blood; I can't take seriously a claim that he will do this _only_ if the wine doesn't have extra sugar or elderberries added to it.
- alexmolas 3y agoThe point is that Catholics believe the words that Jesus said during the last supper, and He used wine without additives. The Mass is the repetition of that last supper and the death of Jesus in the cross. So to be faithful to what Jesus did it's important to use the same type of wine He used.
- mplanchard 3y agoI would imagine that most modern wine is not necessarily the same type as the wine that would have been used as (presumably) table wine at the last supper. Indeed it seems likely based on archaeological evidence that common wines drunk in the region and at the time contained additives for flavor! See https://www.vivino.com/wine-news/searching-for-the-wine-from-the-last-supper https://www.vivino.com/wine-news/searching-for-the-wine-from... Furthermore, how far should one take this silly adherence to imagined fact? If we discover that in Jerusalem they drank predominantly wine from some now extinct local varietal, does that make all masses since invalid? I, like the poster you’re replying to, grew up Catholic, and this sort of slavish adherence to stuff some church person made up at some point in the past has always struck me as one of the more ridiculous parts of the religion.
- tialaramex 3y agoCatholicism is a mass religion, which means you need to be able to have a functioning society of Catholics (whereas if you're just making a religion to get a few dozen people into your cult so you can exploit them however you please, it isn't important whether an entire working society with this religion is even possible) so the rules can't just be complete nonsense. But on the other hand it's important for your religion to stand out. Unless it's going to result in mass persecution or genocide, you want your believers to stand out, the requirements of your religion to impact on everybody else. So you get silly rules - not really that tricky to obey but seemingly pointless because hey, if nobody is grousing about your silly rules, nobody is noticing your religion exists. This sort of thing is only a big problem once it tilts the whole society. People will probably vary in their tolerance but somewhere between "The weird logo on my groceries apparently signifies that a specific religious group may consume this product" and "Your existence is prohibited by the established religion in this country and so you'll be executed" there's a line crossed.
- blincoln 3y agoI'm atheist-leaning agnostic, but having grown up with Christian parents, I have to imagine that Jesus (the historical figure) would be annoyed at the idea of people two millennia in the future arguing about whether or not a particular grape juice product[1] was suitable for commemorating the ceremony he put on for his disciples. Furthermore, I'm pretty sure he'd be angry enough to start tipping over tables in the square that anyone would claim that using a slightly different grape juice product invalidated anything about the events where it was consumed. Of course, I'm sure this philosophical difference is exactly why there are so many splinter factions of Christianity, but it's hard for me to imagine making a religion a central part of one's life and then completely ignoring so much of the message that the core figure of that religion tried to get across. [1] or even any dark red beverage, really.
- ttepasse 3y agoOn the other hand Jesus was born and grew up jewish and would have been familiar with jewish dietary laws and the sacrifices in the temple and the complicated conditions for those.
- mbg721 3y agoA lot of the complications came later. The destruction of the Temple caused a huge mess with how the Law was handled.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoThe expansion of ritual purity into everyday mundane life was an active area of dispute in the judaism of christ's time & place. He certainly would have been aware of the general concept and most likely had a take on it. In fact there's a historically grounded secular interpretation of the good samaritan parable indicating it's at least partially about exactly this. According to contemporaneous jewish moral norms, the priest in the parable has valid reason to avoid what he thinks is a dead body but only if he has a ritual duty to perform in temple in the near future. In the parable he is traveling "down from jersusalem" eg his duty is complete for now. Jesus is coming down against him maintaining ritual purity without a specific liturgical duty to.
- michaelsbradley 3y agocf. The Blessed Eucharist as a Sacrament https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05584a.htm https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05584a.htm
- vrish88 3y agoI don’t see how this is Pharisaic in nature. The way I read it, the issue is: what is wine? The definition of a thing and debate around the definition is something that everybody does. Just remember the hot dog/sandwich war which took the lives of so many… Pharisaic concerns would be about nonessential things like the color of the bottle the wine is in, the cork or bottle cap, etc. What materialists and some scientists forget is that matter matters. What materialists, some scientists, gnostics, and some Protestants forget is that matter has spiritual matters. God became man so that man could become God - Athanasius [1] Jews (and thus Jesus) followed particular instructions by to obtain material effects (think Passover or Jericho). Similar to preparing a meal, particular ingredients and particular processes yield a particular result. Change some of the ingredients and you get a different result. What Jesus did in the Last Supper was to elevate material behaviors to produce spiritual effects. He takes the Passover meal and uses it to share his divinity. If wine and bread is needed to share his divinity, then the questions of what is wine and what is bread are of the utmost importance for a Catholic. [1] - https://www.catholic.com/qa/what-so-that-we-might-become-god-means https://www.catholic.com/qa/what-so-that-we-might-become-god...
- dctoedt 3y agoY'shua of Nazareth seemed not to have cared much, if at all, for formalities or strict definitions — see his answer, in Luke 10:25-37 [0], to the lawyer's question, what must I do to inherit eternal life? (TL;DR: Love God, love your neighbor — and your neighbor is everyone, even your enemy.) [0] https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Luke+10%3A25-37&version=NIV https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Luke+10%3A25-37...
- vrish88 3y agoYou are right, Jesus hated those Pharisaic formalities that prevented people from actual loving others. However Jesus did participate in other Jewish “formalities”. He celebrated the Passover, the festival of tents, he was presented at the temple, and so on. To say Jesus believes all formalities are bad is not true. For this partially question, what is wine, I don’t think it is preventing us from loving God and neighbor. I do think it is important because of the centrality of wine in the Gospels. T he miracle of the wedding feast at Cana, image of the vine and branches, and with the culmination of the last supper.
- adolph 3y agoHow Catholics Saved California Wine: https://www.tastingtable.com/1232442/church-loopholes-during-prohibition-saved-californias-wine-industry/ https://www.tastingtable.com/1232442/church-loopholes-during...
- lukeholder 3y agoThe LDS church uses water but if you don’t have water you can use whatever you have available. It’s just a symbol of the blood.
- thesimpleone 3y agoSounds like the modern Pharisees.