7 ms·
What were the chances? I installed Planescape Torment last night, to play around a bit with it. It's been sitting in my "to-try" list for at least 15 years! I'
by j1elo 3y ago
What were the chances? I installed Planescape Torment last night, to play around a bit with it. It's been sitting in my "to-try" list for at least 15 years!
I'm however not very fond of having to sit down on my desk to play games with keyboard and mouse, though... I already spend enough of my life sitting in the exact same position for work. That alone discourages me from playing several old games I own (and not so old, like the newer X-Com) and even the newer Monkey Island game (which of course is sitting in the same list for some years now too)
- jaggederest 3y agoWell, if there's one game worth your time, PS:T is probably it. Arguably one of the best cRPGs of all time.
- WastingMyTime89 3y agoPeople have rose tinted glasses when they talk about old games. PS:T was a cut above the other cRPGs of its time mainly because it had adequate writing and an engaging story when most other cRPGs were trite. Still everything after Raven’s maze is just average until the ending where it gets good again and the gameplay outside of dialogue is frankly uninteresting. It’s in a lot of way like the original Dark Soul whose last half is so aweful I’m not sure the awesome first one is enough to redeem the game. PS:T has now been bested by plenty of modern cRPGs. I’m not sure it’s worth revisiting considering how long it is.
- xanathar 3y agoI am a Planescape Torment extreme fanboy and... I have to agree. But it's still worth playing, it is still better than the median cRPG almost 25 years later, and it remains a milestone in cRPGs history: i.e. just like Sgt Peppers or Dark Side of the Moon are still worth listening today.
- fbdab103 3y agoYou do not get to lay down such criticism without offering alternative suggestions. What is your top-tier classic or modern cRPG? Edit: Not a fanboy defensiveness or anything. Just rare to see the contrarian opinion on this, and genuinely curious. Other than the trash combat, I really enjoyed my time with PST.
- xanathar 3y agoI think all things considered BG2 aged better - it had less exciting plot, but it balanced better all the aspects. That said, I would nudge Pillars of Eternity and Pathfinder: Kingmaker above PST as they have an equally good amount of story, NPC interaction, they balance combat better. Pillars II, Wrath of the Righteous and Tides of Numenera, otoh, are below the PST bar in my opinion but ymmv depending on tastes. On the Divinity side, DOS:2 is also a good competitor in the list, although I find it the story tends to be too diluted by combat. Notably many of the titles I listed above have had Avellone involved at some point (I think he had been involved with Numenera, DOS:2, Pillars I and Kingmaker, maybe more). I was very skeptical about BG3, especially because even if I listed DOS:2 above, I didn't really like it too much, I'm no Larian fan. But I played the early access and it seems to be golden good so far. Otoh I replayed (for the billionth time?) all IE games recently and while I still consider PST to be the best IE game ever (only BG2 comes close) it's definitely not uniform. The plot weakens after leaving Sigil, and so do side quests and non-linearity (it's actually pretty linear overall, but after Sigil it doesn't even maintain the illusion). Even the interactions with NPCs are sometimes lackluster (e.g. I would have "pushed" Morte more on the "don't trust the skull" bit) I felt (but it's personal opinion I'd say) that many interactions in PoE went deeper than that. Anyway, these are opinions and I know of at least one PST fan who would trash the PoEs, Numenera and the Pathfinders (but loved DOS:2), so YMMV.
- pmoriarty 3y agoI found the first Pillars of Eternity game incredibly boring, and actually liked the 2nd one more... though I also grew bored of it before too long. BG2 was ok, but I don't think any of these games can hold a candle to PS:T in terms of writing. I haven't tried Pathfinder: Kingmaker, because it has an enormous number of very negative reviews, so I'm surprised you'd put it in the same league as PS:T.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- valvar 3y ago>It’s in a lot of way like the original Dark Soul whose last half is so aweful I’m not sure the awesome first one is enough to redeem the game. What are you talking about? I've never heard this take before. I found it fantastic all the way through. Maybe introducing the lord vessel was a poor design choice, but it's a minor fault.
- WastingMyTime89 3y agoIt’s a fairly common opinion even amongst fans of the Soul games. Basically everything after Anor Londo was rushed through as the budget dwindled and the game had to be released. The catacombs are just a smudgy mess with a couple of uninteresting ennemies and a mid-boss without any worthwhile patterns. The depth is just reskinned old ennemies you have to plod through one after the other before what’s probably the worst boss in the soul games. Even the better areas like Duke’s Archive, Crystal Cave or New Londo are inferiorly designed retread of previous ideas. The true genius of the game - the looping-on-itself level design - is over and you spend your time in this very bland linear areas wishing it was over already. Honestly if the game stopped after fighting Orstein and Smough, it would be a better game overall. The DLC is good again however. You can tell FromSoft got additional budget for it.
- iamacyborg 3y agoIf you want to see what rushed looks like, compare Revenant[1] before and after the major underground section. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revenant_(video_game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revenant_(video_game)
- tmtvl 3y agoYeah, East Ahkuilon is pretty decent, the caves kinda outstay their welcome, West Ahkuilon tries to hang in there, but after you defeat Teleporty McFireball things really take a nosedive.
- iamacyborg 3y ago
- Certhas 3y agoTalking about the gameplay outside the dialogue is a bit silly though. Why people still love it are writing and plot. The mechanics were simply the bog standard mechanics of the day and don't matter much. Which games would you say have bested it in terms of writing/plot? I see a few but not very many really. Disco Elysium would be the first but that also stands alone in terms of quality. (That said, don't get to game much anymore so could very well have missed a lot...).
- Arainach 3y agoDialog doesn't make it "one of the best cRPGs of all time" or even necessarily worth playing in 2023. That's the rose tinted glasses. The gameplay is absolutely an important part of "should I play this now". Plenty of games that were good when they came out aren't worth investing hours in today. Bioshock Infinite comes to mind.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoI disagree, I want a game to have either passable gameplay or for its gameplay to just get out of the way. If a game is relatively linear (think Last of Us, To the Moon, Alan Wake), I'm actually inclined to just watch a lets play because I can skip the "gameplay" parts. Maybe that makes me the minority, but I don't think it invalidates the opinions of people saying PS:T was a phenomenal game even if the gameplay was nothing special
- WastingMyTime89 3y agoHow is it silly? PS:T is a cRPGs not a visual novel. There is an actual game you have to play around the dialogues and this game is not particularly complex, engaging or even that fun as demonstrated by the rest of my comment lamenting the part of the game after Raven’s maze which is notorious for having lots of boring combats and less dialogue than the rest of the game. People excuse the mechanics both because the plot was original and because they have forgotten as this part of the game is unremarkable. It still make for a less than stellar experience when you play it today.
- arp242 3y agoThe "game" part isn't very good and arguably it's more "interactive fiction" than "game", but I don't think this has anything to do with the age of it – this is the case for quite a few RPGs that focus more on the story, including newer ones. These kind of games trailing off a bit towards the end is also somewhat common. There are also very few cRPGs of the same type; maybe about 20 in total? Note I don't consider all these first-person action-RPGs the same "type"; it's cool if you're in to that, but I'm not really. At any rate, I don't think it's a perfect game, but IMHO it holds up very well.
- pmoriarty 3y ago"People have rose tinted glasses when they talk about old games. PS:T was a cut above the other cRPGs of its time mainly because it had adequate writing and an engaging story when most other cRPGs were trite." Adequate writing? The writing of 99.9% of games is simply atrocious, and PS:T was and still is miles above them. "PS:T has now been bested by plenty of modern cRPGs" It's been bested on the gameplay and graphics level, but I've yet to find a game with better writing.
- danq_ 3y ago>PS:T has now been bested by plenty of modern cRPGs. I’m not sure it’s worth revisiting considering how long it is. I disagree. The story of PS:T is still superior in terms of depth, writing, plot and setting. The entire package is better than most fantasy or sci-fi novels. modern CRGPS are better in presentation and gameplay. But setting and story is what sets Torment apart. It still hasn't been bested. I'm not looking at this through rose colored glasses either. Like there are games I loved back then that I will willingly admit are pretty bad nowadays. Zelda OOT, for example. That game was revolutionary but it doesn't hold it up, it's crap nowadays. Planescape torment is not like that. There is literally nothing else like it in the gaming world even today.
- jaggederest 3y agoI disagree. I'd be interested to hear which games you think are comparable or superior - I'd like to play them, if I haven't! I think the only comparable games recently have been mostly outside what I would consider the cRPG genre, taken strictly: Elden ring, horizon zero dawn / forbidden west, recent Zelda franchise entries, RDR/RDR2, I was a Teenage Exocolonist Witcher 3 is probably the strongest challenger, I think. I haven't played Disco Elysium but I hear good things. I don't think the Mass Effect series fully measures up, though it's definitely in the ballpark. Same for the Elder Scrolls series - suffers the opposite problem from PS:T, that the gameplay is solid but the plot fails.
- modeless 3y agoSeems like this is the problem Steam Deck solves.
- hutzlibu 3y agoHow do you replace a mouse with it? Is it with a touchscreen or knobs on the side? I think I would still miss a mouse for precision and speed with that ..
- mateuszf 3y agoIt has a touchscreen, two joysticks and two touchpad likes surfaces, you can configure them how you like. However the screen is 7 inches and text in games like this or early Fallouts is too small for me, so I planned to use SD for them but resigned.
- WillAdams 3y agoMost of the Infinity Engine games play very well on a Windows tablet with an active stylus. Unfortunately, PST is an early iteration of the engine and I had problems with inventory manipulation --- not sure if that was ever addressed.
- IggleSniggle 3y agoThere are capacitive touchpads on both sides of the deck, but calling them that really sells them short. It has an extensive controller mapping system. I play a lot of strategy and RTS games, and they can be set up with a wide variety of customizable overlays and haptics, that you can mix with button-chording as desired
- NamTaf 3y agoIt's worth also emphasising that they can be combined, so that you can combine the touchpads with the gyro such that the touchpads do coarse mouse movement and the gyro does the fine tweaking. This is apparently surprisingly effective, though I've not tried it myself. Similarly, for FPS the gyro can be used for additional aiming and even set such that it's only enabled when one of the joysticks is touched (via the capacitive receiver).
- tmoravec 3y agoIf it helps, I've played PS:T on an ipad and it was playable.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoWhat are your other methods of playing besides keyboard and mouse? The newest monkey Island is steam Deck verified and also works with gamepad on your tv computer etc :) I think new x-com games are steam deck playable. And original xcom game is eminently playable on any old laptop :)
- NamTaf 3y agoOne of the steam deck's really underappreciated features is the trackpads. You can use them to play a whole heap of KB+M games that were otherwise off bounds for a handheld. I've been playing through the Sam & Max episodic games this way: trackpad for pointer, and buttons for clicks. It doesn't need fast-paced interactions so it's very forgiving there. When more speed is needed, I've heard others combine the trackpad with some minor gyro mouse input such that the touchpad does the coarse pointer manipulation and then gyro does the fine detail. Apparently you can get quite fast with this approach.
- VHRanger 3y agoP:T is available on android as a beamdog port. It plays very nicely for that format.
- pluijzer 3y agoPS:T is also available for iOS, Android and Switch. The controls have been adapted for the platforms and play great. And ofcourse like others have pointed out the Steam Deck is amazing also older games. The new Monkey Island is also available for atleast the Switch btw.
- j1elo 3y agoSadly the deprecation of 32-bit Android apps has done a lot of damage to backwards compatibility... Wonder what would have happened if Android was a Microsoft platform :-) https://forums.beamdog.com/discussion/87197/pst-ee-on-android-13 https://forums.beamdog.com/discussion/87197/pst-ee-on-androi... Basically, the game doesn't work any more on my Android 13 device, because devs need to go back to it and recompile the sources for 64-bit ARM. Naturally with a change like that with no compatibility layer available, there will be tons of apps and games left behind as abandonware, because their devs have better things to do (if they are even still around, at all!) than going back and recompiling all their source code. We'll see if BeamDog ever gets to it for PS:T!
- hombre_fatal 3y agoWhen I lived in a house with a treadmill, I hooked my Macbook up to a TV and used a gamepad mapped to mouse (move, click, scroll) input to play a lot of older games while walking. It’s what inspired me to build my own remap software. Because yeah I can’t sit at a computer to play games.
- cmcmcm 3y agoCan you tell me more about the gamepad and software you used? I've been looking for a decent solution like this for ages.
- User23 3y agoThe Torment enhanced edition plays great on the iPad. I assume there is an Android release too.
- axus 3y agoI purchased "Planescape: Torment: Enhanced" in Google Play on my Amazon Fire tablet a couple years ago. Probably missed out on a few keyboard shortcuts, but like you I don't sit at the computer for gaming much anymore.
- channel_t 3y agoI definitely feel this ever since switching primarily to remote work. I buy PC games periodically that are often amazing but I struggle to find myself able to dedicate much time to them because I already spend way too much time in the room taking care of work stuff. Console games are more doable because I can play them on the couch. Does this make me want to go back into the office full time? Not sure. The quick commute from my bed to my desk might be worth the sacrifice, but part of me definitely longs for the work of the before times.
- caseysoftware 3y agoX-Com 1 & 2 on ipad are good too. Sure, you don't have the same flexibility as on the computer but it's nice NOT to be tied to the same device in the same place.
- daishi424 3y agoXCOM (2012) is super convenient with a gamepad, I finished both new games (with Long War mod on top) with a 360 controller. Give it a try, its control scheme is designed very well.