Exactly what I was thinking. It is important that the original code is vetted - for example during a peer review process - but to say that the entire code sourc

Exactly what I was thinking. It is important that the original code is vetted - for example during a peer review process - but to say that the entire code source is necessary to reproduce the result seems self contradictory. Surely it should be reproducible especially without the original source code. (EDIT: that's not to say that you shouldn't provide source code - it probably depends on the experiment)