3 ms·
Options: 1. So you start digging and find huge concrete cylinders with clearly marked "radioactive" warning signs. Hilarity ensues, people sue each other, and
by cyberax 3y ago
Options:
1. So you start digging and find huge concrete cylinders with clearly marked "radioactive" warning signs. Hilarity ensues, people sue each other, and cylinders get moved somewhere else.
2. You just build a house on the ground (without digging). Nothing bad happens.
3. Civilization collapses, nobody cares about the abandoned casks.
- janalsncm 3y agoThere is a fourth option. Nuclear waste can be used in dirty bombs and poisons as well. So waste sites should be somewhat secure. So in the analogy it would be as if we left a stockpile of guns and ammo. I don’t think leaving a bunch of loaded guns around is a responsible way to hand the future to our children, especially since we can’t know what the future political situations will be.
- karlerss 3y agoBut we did leave a stockpile of weapons and ammo. It's a minor inconvenience. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_bomb_disposal_in_Europe https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_bomb_disposal_i...
- janalsncm 3y agoIt’s a minor inconvenience in Europe because of the political stability of the region. However, it has been stable for only a relatively short period of time, with no guarantees for the future. So let me reframe the question. Do you think it would be a good idea to store spent nuclear waste in present day Iraq or Syria?
- HPsquared 3y agoProliferation is the biggest hazard, I think. Proliferation of the fissile material remains a problem for much longer than the radiation from the fission products (which is only a few hundred years). The best way is to burn up these actinides in a suitable reactor.
- Manuel_D 3y agoIt'd be easier to just mine naturally occurring uranium. Are terrorists somehow going to successfully excavate a mile deep into bedrock in Finland, without anyone noticing? Again, we do have big stockpiles of guns and ammo. We have bunkers full of artillery shells, missiles, and weapons. Where's the outrage over the dozens (hundreds?) of munitions stockpiles militaries have strewn across the globe? Again the question is, what risk does nuclear pose that we don't already navigate with other more mundane materials?
- cyberax 3y agoYou can make poisons without nuclear materials just fine. Keep in mind, that regular heavy metals also don't go away. The nuclear material in casks is not _that_ dangerous because of its long half-life. So dirty bombs made from it would not result in a significant loss of life. They'll just result in a very expensive cleanup of the affected areas.
- carlmr 3y ago>1. So you start digging and find huge concrete cylinders with clearly marked "radioactive" warning signs. Hilarity ensues, people sue each other, and cylinders get moved somewhere else. The radioactive symbol (trefoil) was invented in 1946. In 2007 a new supplementary symbol was created. Sure it still includes a trefoil, but it's smaller. Now just imagine the symbols we used today, what we think is obvious might not be obvious in 100 years, 1000 years, 10000 years, much less in 100000 years. These are time spans that aren't imaginable to us. Creating a symbol that's intelligible throughout that time is a task we dont know we can do. Can you decipher the symbols in Göbleki Tepe reliably? There are some hypotheses around these. But if they're warning you about something that warning is hard to decipher, much less obvious. And this is only 10000 years ago.
- HPsquared 3y agoWe can read Egyptian hieroglyphics. Anything written in simple English will be understandable even by an alien species in 100,000 years. Even without that, you could give the information visually in cartoon form.
- peterpost2 3y ago>We can read Egyptian hieroglyphics. Only because we found like one stone hundreds of years ago, if that was not the case we probably could not have done it. >Anything written in simple English will be understandable even by an alien species in 100,000 years. [Citation needed] This seems like quite an assumption. Anyhow, the situation he sketched was that some random guy develops a fields with cylinders 300 years from now, how reasonable is it that he somehow understand the language or goes through the effort to translate it? I would wager pretty slim, I can barely understand text in my own language from 100 years ago.
- YuccaGloriosa 3y agoI think the best thing we can do is bury all the nuclear waste. And to avoid any future generation excavating it, mark it's location, and to stand the test of time, build a massive stone pyramid on top of it. In 5000 years people will be able to figure that out.
- oxfordmale 3y ago1. You start digging, and you find these huge mysterious concrete cylinders with a funny symbols. These must clearly have been gift to their God(s) given the amount of work they put in. We should recover them, open them up and have buses of school kids admire them up close
- cyberax 3y agoIf you have buses, then you also likely know about radioactivity. And the archeological lab will quickly identify the casks. And if it's a pre-historic society, then why would you be digging 30 meters below ground anyway?
- oxfordmale 3y agoWhy would a pre-historic society go to the trouble of dragging large stones 150 miles or more ? (Stonehenge) Mankind has gone to great lengths to admire the death, and digging a 30 meter hole is definitely achievable given other prehistoric monuments.
- cyberax 3y agoSure. And what are the chances that a Stonehenge-like monument would be located exactly on the site of nuclear waste disposal? For this to happen, such monuments have to be commonplace. Which would require a technological civilization. Then see above.