4 ms·
Why do we need more maths textbooks in the first place? I agree with the comment by HN participant droithomme above that it would be perfectly possible for sch
by tokenadult 15y ago
Why do we need more maths textbooks in the first place?
I agree with the comment by HN participant droithomme above that it would be perfectly possible for school systems in the United States simply to adopt the Primary Mathematics textbook series from Singapore (which already exists in two editions adapted to the United States in general and adapted to California curriculum standards in particular)
http://www.singaporemath.com/Primary_Mathematics_US_Ed_s/39.htm http://www.singaporemath.com/Primary_Mathematics_US_Ed_s/39....
http://www.singaporemath.com/Primary_Mathematics_Stds_Ed_s/134.htm http://www.singaporemath.com/Primary_Mathematics_Stds_Ed_s/1...
and thereby do much better than most United States schools do with any of the other existing textbook series.
Based on international textbook content analyses and other evidence, gathered and digested with the help of professional mathematicians aware of international K-12 teaching practice, the great majority of states in the United States have voluntarily adopted the Common Core State Standards in Mathematics
http://www.corestandards.org/the-standards/mathematics http://www.corestandards.org/the-standards/mathematics
and the next iteration of textbooks in the United States will CLAIM (with truthfulness of that claim yet to be verified) to follow that set of standards. I like what I have seen of those standards. I have yet to see any new textbook series that fully embody the best practice in mathematics teaching in other countries. The best elementary mathematics textbooks I have seen are in the Chinese language, published either in Taiwan or in China. Among English-language textbooks, the Singapore Primary Mathematics Series has been plainly superior for at least the last twenty years.
I can't imagine there's new branches of maths that we need to teach school kids about. (and same goes for a lot of other subjects)
I can more readily imagine new developments since my childhood in physics than in mathematics that would have to be reflected in elementary textbooks, to be sure. But textbooks would have to be updated in any country that does not yet have the best available textbooks, even if the subject of mathematics has not changed. There has been a growth in understanding during my lifetime about how to teach mathematics to elementary-age pupils. Content analysis of different textbooks used in differing countries has helped develop that growth in pedagogical understanding.
Moreover, at least two aspects of mathematics as encountered by most members of the public have changed in my lifetime:
1) today anyone in a developed country can buy an inexpensive calculating machine that is more generally useful than a dedicated office business machine of a generation ago, and
2) discrete mathematics plays a much bigger role in business and in industry than it did when the march to calculus was the main path in mathematics education for technical careers. Both of those changes would have to be reflected somehow in curriculum design for K-12 mathematics instruction.