3 ms·
If all the wealth of the US billionaires was confiscated (all of it) it would fund the government for 9 months. And then what? Where are you going to get the mo
by WalterBright 3y ago
If all the wealth of the US billionaires was confiscated (all of it) it would fund the government for 9 months. And then what? Where are you going to get the money to fund the government? Countries that have tried confiscating all the wealth from their wealthy have made things worse for the rest of the country, not better.
As for Musk, if he didn't make a lot of money, SpaceX never would have been possible. His wealth is all invested in his companies, and he uses it to create more companies.
- aaomidi 3y agoThere’s a lot of actions that’s not just “confiscating their wealth”. For example, requiring employers over a certain revenue to have a workers council, and a seat at the board. Creating stronger union protections. Not weakening them. Requiring sick pay, paid time off, etc etc. Limiting the abuse of using contract workers to avoid doing benefits.
- WalterBright 3y agoOther countries do that, which is why they have anemic economies compared to the US.
- aaomidi 3y agoWhile doing better on nearly every other social aspect. Also, the U.S. economy can’t be compared with anywhere else because we are the reserve currency. The control we have over our economy is literally not possible anywhere else. When we didn’t have this control, our economic policies led to the great fucking depression.
- WalterBright 3y ago> our economic policies led to the great fucking depression That policy was, specifically, tying the exchange rate of the dollar to gold while inflating the hell out of the dollar - Fed policy enacted in the 1914 Federal Reserve Act. This disconnect between the dollar's value and gold's value eventually caused a run on the banks which collapsed them, as you could buy gold for half price. The depression did not start to recover until the government halted gold purchases. > While doing better on nearly every other social aspect. Debatable. I've lived in foreign countries.
- andrepd 3y agoTens of millions of people in the US live in such a devastating level poverty which is virtually unheard of in Western Europe or Japan. Social mobility is weaker in the "land of opportunity" than in Europe, indicating that your wealth and income as an adult is highly correlated on your parent's wealth and income (so much for the meritocratic fairytale). I'll take optimising for well-being (with a "strong economy" as a mere tool for that, not an end in itself) over "muh gdp" any day now.
- WalterBright 3y ago> devastating level poverty It is not a "devastating" level of poverty. The US is not a 3rd world country and the 3rd world poor are desperately trying to get into the US, literally by the millions. The US poverty rate stopped declining in 1968 when the government began subsidizing it.
- titzer 3y agoWe could have had reasonable tax policies and reasonable spending policies for a few decades instead of running huge deficits to keep financing tax cuts for the ultra wealthy, but we didn't do that. Mostly because of the reality distortion field coming out of certain schools of economics that tell us it's gonna trickle down any moment now. For the record, I don't advocate confiscating 99% of their wealth as some scheme to fund the government. (Did I mention the government? no). And I don't advocate confiscating the money out of spite or a sense of moral obligation. But as a society we might want to consider the instability that every example throughout history suggests. When the peasants revolt, they don't tax the rich, they chop their heads off. (And for the record, I am not advocating that either, sheesh).
- WalterBright 3y agoThe deficits are completely unnecessary - just stop the massive wasteful spending.
- titzer 3y agoI have heard the same refrain for 40 years. It's a vacuous non-statement which is 0% profound and yet always, always hides a deep disdain for helping actual people with an ironic exuberance for stimulus spending the second corporate profits are threatened. We'd have more than enough money if we had sensible tax policies (read: higher taxes on corporations and the rich) and didn't literally set it on fire by blowing so much dough on weapons. I mean, I'd like to give you the benefit of the doubt here, because I can't really know what you really think in depth about such issues, but if you wanna sling meme solutions then it's hard for me to not to fill in the blanks with the rest of it, which is a bunch of corporatist stuff masquerading as today's libertarianism.
- WalterBright 3y agoDo you really think that the non-deficit spending of the government is not helping people? The growth in government spending in the last handful of years has been unprecedented and enormous. > We'd have more than enough money if we had sensible tax policies (read: higher taxes on corporations and the rich) There isn't enough there to fund the trillions in deficits. As for who benefits from corporations doing well, did you know that something like 60% of Americans have investments in the stock markets and much of the rest have pension plans invested in stocks?
- andrepd 3y agoHonestly, what absurd straw man is this? Who talked about "the gobmint" or "confiscating wealth". Honestly, it's not worth it having a conversation with someone who is clearly not arguing in good faith. > As for Musk, if he didn't make a lot of money, SpaceX never would have been possible. Sure, (1) every centibillionaire calculated that they would only do what they do if they got 100,000,000,000$ out of it, for (say) 50,000,000,000$ they wouldn't have gone through the trouble, and (2) no other human could possibly do what Elon Musk does[1]. Praise Space Jesus, hallowed be His name. Give me a break... [1] Hint: good marketeers are a dime a dozen.
- WalterBright 3y ago> no other human could possibly do what Elon Musk does Except everyone told Musk that what he was doing was impossible, and nobody else did it. > good marketeers are a dime a dozen Read one of the many biographies of Steve Jobs and then get back to me!