4 ms·
The flat sequential thread was a reaction to threaded messages as seen on Usenet and mailing lists. It works reasonably well if users are careful to quote the
by zozbot234 3y ago
The flat sequential thread was a reaction to threaded messages as seen on Usenet and mailing lists. It works reasonably well if users are careful to quote the messages they're responding to.
- tquinn 3y agoSuper interesting, I didn't know it was a reaction. Looking at Usenet thread screenshots, I think the UX issue with their threads is that they actually listed the title, not the actual message in a branch format. Whereas Reddit has the actual message content in a branch format. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conversation_threading#/media/File:Nntp.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conversation_threading#/media/... VS https://preview.redd.it/r7k2gf1kav6z.png?auto=webp&s=9fd7a0bf3ccc158399cb499f85881ed77348d18e https://preview.redd.it/r7k2gf1kav6z.png?auto=webp&s=9fd7a0b... I think the flat sequential thread works fine with a limited number of messages. Eventually with enough replies it degrades to being very unwieldy like traditional forums.
- iso1631 3y agoI'm sure slashdot showed the messages in threads (at least in some modes) at least 5 years before reddit was a thing. In fact here's a screenshot from 2005 https://www.flickr.com/photos/third/18260796 https://www.flickr.com/photos/third/18260796
- iso1631 3y agoThe web based forum I ran in the late 90s was threaded, then things like UBB came along and the flat structure seemed to win out.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoUsenet and mailing lists had different UX problems, unrelated to tree vs. linear model - starting with all the little friction associated with browsing threads and replying to messages. Web forums improved on that. I suspect that back then, the linear model got popular incidentally, because of aforementioned UX improvements. Later on, however, people ported the tree model to the web, which gains all the same UX improvements while still not having the drawback of linear threads. > It works reasonably well if users are careful to quote the messages they're responding to. Unsurprisingly, they mostly weren't. Linear threads worked reasonably well when you were participating in or following a discussion as it unfolded; otherwise, they quickly became impenetrable.