3 ms·
I think HN underestimates the truth behind #1. (Don't shoot the messenger! Just adding some objective data amid the flames.) Roughly half of the biggest subre
by paulddraper 3y ago
I think HN underestimates the truth behind #1.
(Don't shoot the messenger! Just adding some objective data amid the flames.)
Roughly half of the biggest subreddits went dark. And almost all of them are back (r/funny, r/gaming, r/aww, r/todayilearned, /r/pics, etc)
AFAIK the only huge holdouts are r/videos and r/music.
Mods and some users have been very vocal...but there's a quieter, larger group that is fine with the official app and just wants a place to post.
---
EDIT: My bad. r/aww, r/gaming, and r/pics have disabled new posts.
Plenty of others...r/funny, r/askscience, r/earthporn, r/explainlikeimfive, r/food, r/gadgets, r/nottheonion, r/space, r/sports went dark and are now back.
Total affected subscriber count has fallen ~60% [1] since the peak.
FWIW, I think #2 is true as well. This is by no means a inconsequential disruption. But it's also far from "the death of Reddit."
[1] https://blackout.photon-reddit.com/ https://blackout.photon-reddit.com/
- sdfghswe 3y agoAnd this is why I always say that "but but but the mods aren't getting paid" argument makes no sense. Clearly the mods are getting _something_ out of modding, and that's their reward.
- Majromax 3y ago> And this is why I always say that "but but but the mods aren't getting paid" argument makes no sense. Clearly the mods are getting _something_ out of modding, and that's their reward. That cuts both ways, however. If moderators get compensated with a sense of satisfaction rather than money, then site changes that affect their "quality of life" carry extra weight. In plain English: if you do this for fun, then you stop doing it once it's no longer fun. The API changes are the proximate cause of the protest, but the widespread participation suggests that many moderators were already near the breaking point. (ed: was capitulation)
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y agoI posit that this means there is (c) Mods are out, making a tempest in a teapot, but consumers are fine -for now. Medium/longerm, no one really knows if mods will permanently quit, and whether anyone replacing them (or not) will have an effect in traffic. It appears like a bet. Not sure if its one i'd take though if i were the CEO.
- revscat 3y agoWhile this is true, a significant part of Reddit's appeal are the smaller communities, and they are staying closed in droves [1] [2]. There are thousands and thousands of these that are still dark, and have announced no intention of opening back up until their demands are met. I understand that the big subs are either no longer dark, or can be forced to reopen. But that is significantly more difficult to force upon the smaller, more numerable subs. [1] https://old.reddit.com/r/ModCoord/comments/148ks6u/indefinite_blackout_next_steps_polling_your/ https://old.reddit.com/r/ModCoord/comments/148ks6u/indefinit... [2] https://reddark.untone.uk https://reddark.untone.uk
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Kye 3y agoMore to the point: it's that long tail of niche communities where people talk about the things that make for good site: searching. In marketing terms, these are extremely qualified leads. Many of them are people looking for reviews for something they're about to buy, or who want to talk about something they bought. It's exactly the kind of impression advertisers want to run an ad on.
- ehsankia 3y agoThe important thing is, what's the overlap between vocal users, and reddit contributors. It's always been known that reddit (as well as most of the internet really) is driven by a small % of power users. The posting, the commenting, the moderating. /u/spez says 90% of users use the default app, but I would wager that if you look at people who are actively contributing, that number will be much different. Every person I know who uses reddit app does so very passively. They are read-only users who just ingest posts and rarely contribute. Yes the vocal minority is mostly mods and power users, but the argument here is that those are also the people who make reddit what it is.
- DSMan195276 3y ago> Roughly half of the biggest subreddits went dark. And almost all of them are back (r/funny, r/gaming, r/aww, r/todayilearned, /r/pics, etc) Are they? They're not private, but (last I checked) at least some of those were not allowing new posts or comments.
- bordercases 3y agoAs the resevoir of astroturfed marketing that is still a problem for Reddit.
- Majromax 3y ago> Roughly half of the biggest subreddits went dark. And almost all of them are back (r/funny, r/gaming, r/aww, r/todayilearned, /r/pics, etc) As of this writing, per https://blackout.photon-reddit.com/ https://blackout.photon-reddit.com/, r/aww, r/gaming, and r/pics are all restricted to new submissions. r/music is the largest subreddit still in private mode.
- das_keyboard 3y agoWhile I think it is true, that many are overestimating the impact, I'd like to correct your comment: At least r/gaming, r/aww and r/pics are still restricted and do not allow new post or comments. So the protest is still going with some really big subreddits supporting the cause.
- btown 3y agoThere's no doubt that Reddit, in some form, would survive if Spez were to keep a firm line, unilaterally replace volunteer moderators, and cater to that "larger group." But that in some form should be terrifying to institutional investors evaluating or underwriting this IPO. Will users under the new status quo have significantly different retention patterns and lifetime value when consuming content moderated by the moderators that led Reddit to the point where it's able to IPO in the first place? It's very possible that retention numbers drop through the floor because subreddits lose the unique character that made Reddit different from any other social media platform - a character traced through a continuous history of mods on large and small subreddits, chosen as stewards of established per-subreddit culture, now to be wiped away. In the current market environment, doesn't that make Reddit a riskier investment than ever? And it wouldn't take a lot to fix. Spez doesn't even necessarily need to reverse the API restrictions. He just needs to communicate and listen to mods with empathy, and establish that empathy publicly and privately as a top company priority. It's not too late for him to do that and save the company. And the more he refuses to do that, the more questions investors will ask about his readiness to lead.
- hackinthebochs 3y ago>But that in some form should be terrifying to institutional investors evaluating or underwriting this IPO Far more terrifying is a site that is perpetually at the mercy of a handful of powerusers. That if the winds change, they collectively could tank the value of the product with no way for investors to intervene. If I were going to invest in Reddit, I would want the CEO to show that ultimately he/reddit is in control. He is a known, predictable quantity. He is also someone that can be replaced if things go too far off the rails. The whims of the pseudo-aristocracy is completely out of my control.
- zozbot234 3y agoThat 'handful of power users' is behind much of the value creation on that site. Reddit.com was always at their mercy, nothing substantial has changed here.
- 3y ago
- EMM_386 3y ago> but there's a quieter, larger group that is fine with the official app and just wants a place to post. That'd be me, although slightly different. I've been on that site a long time. I have an account is amongst the first thousand to join it. 17 years. The official app is fine for me when I decide to use it, which is rare. I just don't use my phone for "apps" that often unless I really need to. Otherwise I'm still on the site daily, on a computer. I don't get the hatred. It shows ads, unlike what you can get on the computer. Other than that? I guess I'm not the target market. It works.
- paulddraper 3y agoI'm the same. PC master race, as they say ;)
- officeplant 3y agoJust like the new site, I can't comprehend how people like the official app. Although I've been using Reddit since 2008, having access on a mobile phone has always been vastly more convenient for me personally. Redditisfun, Diode, BaconReader, Apollo; all of these third party apps kept me going to reddit. For me reddit without the superior functionality of a group of competing third party apps just isn't worth participating in anymore. But I recognize a lot of people don't care, or won't be bothered by the changes. For me it just gets added to the list of sites I watched crumble to a shell of their former selves. I was addicted to Reddit in 08/09 and had many sleepless nights digging around niche subs for interesting stories. But like my daily slashdot habit from the early 2000's I move on when its time to give up on a site. The lifecycle of website enshitification rolls on.
- vicktour 3y agoI'm glad it works for you, but its never worked right for me. It always seemed to be messing up links and the UI is so bad. I prefer my client to be minimal and functional and that's why I went with Reddit is Fun. Simple UI that worked and could manage the comment section successfully. Honestly, it feels like the Reddit team saw one of the "Everything Apps" from China and thought its UI and UX where something to be modeled after. I simply wish they would have attempted to buy Apollo and RiF. Then offer them up as official clients. RiF is the only way that I will interact with Reddit because of the way it is laid out and how functional it is. That's where my hate come from. They are effectively killing Reddit for many of us.